Vonray's self-titled
Elektra debut is a collection of guitar anthems and
ballads that should appeal to fans of middling
adult alternative groups like
Live,
Vertical Horizon, and
Remy Zero.
Vaughan Rhea is the band's namesake, frontman, and one of three guitarists. He is joined by brother
Dave Rhea on bass, drummer
Jeff Irizarry, and fellow guitarists
Garrett Coleman and
Todd Hackenburg. While
Vaughan seems to have a strong voice, his delivery here is an irritating three-part impersonation of
Eddie Vedder,
Ed Kowalczyk, and
Scott Stapp. Each lyrical couplet ends with a short, emotive intake of air; most choruses erupt in the throaty, arena-ready bellow
Vedder bequeathed to
Stapp. Musically, the band evokes the stilted, tentative
pop style of
CCM groups such as
Jars of Clay. Quasi-spiritual lyrics ("Evil deeds that breed temptation," from the
Pearl Jam-meets-
Live songwriting project
"Part of Me") don't help matters any. The rousing first single
"Inside Out" has gained exposure for the band through its inclusion on the
Smallville soundtrack; there, it is in good company with sound-alikes
Lifehouse and
Steadman.
"Inside Out" is also one of only two songs on
Vonray written exclusively by
Rhea or his band. The majority of the record was co-written by
Rhea and producer
Marc Tanner, who has worked with
the Calling, another overly dramatic modern
rock combo with a strikingly derivative sound. Since so many of these groups lack even the relative grit of a band like
Creed, yet aren't talented enough as players or songwriters to appeal to the more discerning
alternative music consumer, they are destined to fill the middle spots on soundtracks to romantic comedies, or, in
Vonray's case, to programs on
the WB. ~ Johnny Loftus