- Shopping Bag ( 0 items )
Posted February 19, 2014
For people interested in World II, Imperial Japan, and combat ps
For people interested in World II, Imperial Japan, and combat psychology, I highly recommend this book. The book has much fascinating information about the rise of the imperialist Japan and combat psychiatry.
In addition the book is very easy to read.
After World War II, there were a series of trials that were similar to the Nuremberg trials that were held in Germany. The book
is about the author's grandfather, Daniel S. Jaffe, who declared a major Japanese defendant, Okawa Shumei, in the Japanese
war crimes incapable of standing trial because of the defendant was insane. After the war trials were over, Okawa appeared to
regain his sanity and lived a fairly comfortable life while his codefendants were either hanged or spent life in prison. The question
had risen whether Okawa was able to fake his insanity to get out of being tried by the United States for war crimes.
However, what makes the book compelling is not the unsolved mystery on whether Okawa was really insane. What makes the book
so highly informative are the biographies of Dr. Jaffe and Okawa before these two people meet.
The book describes Dr. Jaffe's early years and his training in psychiatry and about the practices of psychiatry in the 1930s and 1940s.
What I found most interesting was the history of combat psychiatry the role combat psychiatry plays in wars(it stills seems to be an
issue of how to manage soldiers in the military so they don't become totally psychology scarred from war). I had no idea that there
were treatments that started in World War I, that could take what then was called a "shell shocked" solider, treat at the front and
send them back to battle with a high rate of success. The book also describes how low the morale in the armed services could be
The book also describes the rise of imperil Japan and Okama Shumei’s role this process. Until I read this book, I had no idea
that rise of military Japan was so similar to the rise of Nazism and Fascism. Like its counterparts in the West, the rise of
Japanese militarism involved a popular movement combined with staged events, coups and assignations.
The mystery of whether Okama really was insane is a little bit anti-climatic
. It involved using the conventional psychiatry of the times; I thought there might have been a lot of cross cultural issues.
The one criticism of the book that I have is that it made Okawa Shumei seem more sympathetic then he deserved.
Eric Jaffe writes about how Okawa wanted to lead a Pan Asian nationalist movement against the West with Japan being its leader
. However, Japan was brutal to the Asian countries it invaded. I doubt many Asians from the countries that Japan invaded saw Japan
as a kindly country fighting Western expansion. Jaffe does acknowledge that the results of Okawa’s philosophy were violent
but not strongly enough. Okawa did play a key role in starting brutal wars.
When I was reading the book, I was furious with Okawa and I believe sane or insane he had a lot of blood on his hands.
Received ARC from Netgalley
1 out of 2 people found this review helpful.Was this review helpful? Yes NoThank you for your feedback. Report this reviewThank you, this review has been flagged.
Posted January 26, 2014
This book has more twists and turns it makes your head spin. I h
This book has more twists and turns it makes your head spin. I highly recommend it for anyone interested psychiatric devastation of war and its aftermath. Also a great read is Hector's Juice.
1 out of 1 people found this review helpful.Was this review helpful? Yes NoThank you for your feedback. Report this reviewThank you, this review has been flagged.