- Shopping Bag ( 0 items )
Posted May 14, 2012
Tell your teacher not to assign this book
This book is poorly written, factually flawed, revisionist garbage. It is put out by theJohns Hopkins University Press. Is that really the prestigious university or is it some fake place, like buying a Rolex and finding out it is fake because it is spelled Rollex on the dial. The author uses a lack of knowledge about world war two and attempts to make points that are all over the place logically, in order to make the United States look bad. He assumes that everyone in the country was brainwashed by Hollywood, and that we are too stupid to know that mistakes, and some bad behavior by our soldiers and politicians occurred. Most intelligent people already know that our veterans suffered throughout their lives from what they saw, and had to do to survive the war.Was this review helpful? Yes NoThank you for your feedback. Report this reviewThank you, this review has been flagged.
The thing to remember if forced by your college/high school teacher into reading this book, is that many of his facts aren't facts at all. For instance he states the US had 300,000 fatal casualties during the war. Look it up, most sources state between 410,000 and 425,000. He also states that the US had the 45th largest army at the start of the war. We had around 195,000 regular army and 200,000 national guard when the war started. True, we were coming out of the depression and had a relatively small army, but the truth is that our army was around the 15th biggest army when the war started depending on your source. If you think this author makes any sense, try and come up with 44 countries that you think had a bigger army than the US. Remember, we were/are the third most populous country in the world. You get to Lichtenstein pretty fast. I point these few of many such errors, not because the actual number matters to points he is poorly making, but to show that: How can his arguments be any good, if he can't do the simple research (or have a graduate student do it for him!) that you would flunk for if you turned this in.
He also tries to make the point twice in the book (for some unknown reason) that the Japanese were foolish because they didn't understand the importance of striking our carriers at Pearl Harbor and Midway. This can be proven wrong two ways. First read any Japanese accounts of these battles and they are full of gut wrenching disappointment that our carriers weren't at Pearl Harbor, and that despite using submarines and search planes at Midway, they were unable to locate our carriers till it was too late. (Remember, we had broken their code, and had a huge advantage.) The second way that you can prove the author wrong is that these Japanese who, according to him, didn't know the importance of aircraft carriers were standing on aircraft carriers! The Japanese had more aircraft carriers than any nation at the start of the war.
If forced to read this book, I suggest you read it near some world war 2 source material written by actual historians. Look up the "facts" used in the authors arguments. Learn more about the battles/history involved. You will quickly realize this author is more about distorting what your Grandmother and Grandfather sacrificed for this country and the world than being a real "history professor." If you are lucky enough to know a WWII veteran ask them about what happened, don't trust a college professor.