- Shopping Bag ( 0 items )
Posted June 26, 2006
A wonderfully compact dual biography
Music is the centerpiece of this wonderfully compact biography of two men confronting the great Enlightenment collision of faith and reason. I like the topic. Many people who question things wrestle with it, as Gaines admits he does, and it is still relevant 250+ years later with faith-based initiatives and ¿intelligent design¿ being part of public discourse. The prose and musical discussions are accessible, especially after having read some of the more scholarly works of Maynard Solomon (excellent biographies of Mozart and Beethoven), and I especially appreciated the glossary, being a mere lover of music and not a student of it, especially the Baroque period. Sometimes the presentation becomes a little to conversational for me, a tiny tick, however, compared to the fine work Gaines does in succinctly illuminating several centuries of European history. I was dismayed by the barely clothed assertion in the epilog of Bach¿s musical superiority to Mozart. I have never believed in comparing artists from different generations, because each artist writes for his own time and has to make a living there. The comparison can only be done in the context of one¿s own personal taste and really is a similar intellectual exercise to one¿s balance between faith and reason. Of course, Bach gave people who like to debate such things plenty of ammunition. The prelude to the first unaccompanied cello suite is almost sufficient in itself to end any argument.Was this review helpful? Yes NoThank you for your feedback. Report this reviewThank you, this review has been flagged.
Posted March 6, 2005
Best book of this or any year
I have never read a book that moved me quite as much as this one, or one from which I learned more. Maybe I have special interests, but honestly I don't think so. This book explained to me things like why I love the music of Bach, why I distrust so much the suppposedly 'scientific' ideas of life, why I have always had a dislike of people in power, why I have always identified with people who were a little bit down and out, as Bach was. Really, I can't say enough about this book. Everybody, whatever their interest, will get a great deal from reading this book.Was this review helpful? Yes NoThank you for your feedback. Report this reviewThank you, this review has been flagged.