- Shopping Bag ( 0 items )
Posted October 8, 2013
Congratulations on a book well-written, Monique, and many thanks
Congratulations on a book well-written, Monique, and many thanks for sharing your research with the public. I purchased an e-copy so that my wife and I may share the enjoyment of reading your good work.
However, after the first few pages, my wife remarked: “Here it goes again, this woman was trying to fool another person into believing how saintly she was, the way she did you, Walter!”
Of course, she was flattered that the press had called her “The Dragon Lady”, but, in reality, in her own words, she would have rather been referred to as “Santa Evita” because she wanted to be compared to, and remembered as, the Vietnamese Eva Peron.
She stood me up, too, more than once, a good ten years before she failed to show up at that church to meet you in Paris. The sad part is; you and I weren’t the only persons whom she had successfully misled.
My relationship with Le Xuan was of a love-hate nature. I loved her for the efforts to empower the women of Vietnam and for her sense of style. I loved her even more when she spoke sweetly about putting my picture under her pillow each and every night – if I could believe it. But I also hated her for being so evil and condescending.
Her tale of cradling Le Thuy in her arms and proceeded to cross the bridge under fire accentuated a well-defined exclamation mark to the term “disgust”. Nowhere in her story did she ever revealed that she had ran a high-class brothel in Cho Lon – the Chinatown of Saigon – where foreign dignitaries’ needs were catered to, and where secret microphones and cameras were well hidden from the unsuspecting guests. Also, nowhere did she recall the story of how she had lost her virginity to a 17-year-old university student when she was in Ha Noi.
Worse yet, she painted a final picture of her being a not-well-to-do woman of old age, but in reality, her investments at the former Merrill-Lynch were almost equal to the GDPs of some countries on the African continent.
Again, congratulations on a project which deserves many accolades, Monique
2 out of 2 people found this review helpful.Was this review helpful? Yes NoThank you for your feedback. Report this reviewThank you, this review has been flagged.
Posted October 10, 2013
Women in politics. They are often reduced to the clothes they ar
Women in politics. They are often reduced to the clothes they are wearing and the hairstyle they rock. In a predominantly male driven aspect of society the female is usually merely the wife of, daughter of or mistress of a man in power. Not enough women take center stage in government and when they do they are scrutinized and criticized far harsher than their male counterparts.
Madame Nhu was only the sister in law of the man in charge and yet she and her family exerted the strongest influence on him and the country. She was known for her lack of diplomacy. She refused to stay quiet and called a duck a duck if indeed it quacked and walked like said duck. She put many policies into place that took women back 20 steps into the last century.
Her so called morality laws outlawed abortion,divorce, adultery, contraceptives, dance halls, beauty pageants and she was often called out for being a hypocrite.
Madame Nhu was adamant and very vocal about the fact that the Americans brought about the downfall of her family and in doing so also the country.
"My family has been treacherously killed with either official or unofficial blessing of the American government, I can predict to you now that the story is only at its beginning."
Of course that statement, which implies better the devil you know than the devil you don't, was to be eerily predictive. The US thought they could control the outcome in North Vietnam via South Vietnam by removing Di¿m. Instead the removal of Di¿m and Nhu was the start of even greater instability in South Vietnam.
Demery makes an interesting point about the influence certain foreign press members had in South Vietnam. Openly critical of Madame Nhu and the country ruled by her family members they were actually undermining the US and strengthening the North Vietnamese. Pulling the rug right out from under them in the name of the press.
When the Buddhists starting protesting and the pagoda raids followed Madame Nhu was convinced that the Buddhist protest was backed and planned by the communists and manipulated by the Americans. Many years later a man who worked for many Us newspapers in Vietnam during the Di¿m era was revealed as a North Vietnamese collaborator when he defected to NV.
Often seen as the loud mouthed, bossy Iron Lady of SV, the power behind the throne so to speak Madame Nhu was right on the button when it come to evaluating the political situation in her country. She was right about something so pivotal that if someone had listened they might have understood.
If you do not come from that country and culture then it is nigh on impossible to understand the complexity of past history, traditional values and the mindset of man in that foreign country, especially when it is the complete opposite of Western culture.
Unfortunately that is a mistake still made nearly half a century later.
Demery set out to find and understand the elusive Madame Nhu but I think in the end she remained the misunderstood and often misrepresented enigma that she has been for many decades. Other than the research already presented and written about by others Demery wasn't able to get Madame Nhu to let her guard down. She died with her inner Pandora's Box intact.
The woman was as sharp as knife there is a reason she kept that box closed very tightly.
I really enjoyed the way the author approached the subject. It was written in a very personal and lighthearted way with factual clarity. Demery is concise without being boring and praises her sources for the groundwork they have already done on the subject in hand. Kudos to the author for both the intricate research and for giving others their due when necessary.
An immensely interesting read.
I received a copy of this book via NetGalley.
1 out of 1 people found this review helpful.Was this review helpful? Yes NoThank you for your feedback. Report this reviewThank you, this review has been flagged.
Posted November 9, 2014
The story of Madame Nhu begins with her life as an upcoming brid
The story of Madame Nhu begins with her life as an upcoming bride living in a Vietnam laced with French dominion and influence. She is about to marry a man who will eventually become the Prime Minister of Vietnam, the man who will wield the real power behind President Ngo Dinh Diem as nations and revolutionary groups vie for power, prestige, and style in Vietnam. For now Tran Le Xuan, Nhu’s name in her youth), is excited about her marriage and upcoming family status. But intrigue is omnipresent and Nhu’s life seems like it is unraveling as she initially fails to beget children and her husband seems more entwined with his secret trips and missions than he is with his young bride.Was this review helpful? Yes NoThank you for your feedback. Report this reviewThank you, this review has been flagged.
At the same time, we learn how North Vietnamese leaders are seeking to combine their rising power with French administration. The French will fall eventually and Tran will learn how the poor and suffering live when she is forced to flee with her family as the Communists from the North approach South Vietnam. From that point on, Madame Nhu reaches deep inside to let her immense strength confront all obstacles in her path. The story continues with American advisers coming to court her husband and Diem will take over after a coup. Madame Nhu’s notoriety grows as she declares her love of power and prestige and comes across as cold and heartless toward the people she is supposed to serve. Indeed the rule of her family and Diem is correctly labeled as repressive, though these rulers always claimed the treatment was to safeguard their people. Her callous remarks about the burning Buddhist monk serve as the vicious, cold benchmark of her future years. Until her husband and Diem are assassinated, she will court power and use her sexy, slim body and charm to keep South Vietnam free.
One aspect that is always clear in this account is how mixed the advice and help from the USA was. American estimation of the rising threat of Ho Chi Minh always seems inaccurate and forthcoming help was the same; the replies of Madame Nhu and the South Vietnam government was partially responsible as they feared a foreign takeover by the Communists, French (again!) or even the Americans if the truth were to be admitted.
Madame Nhu goes into seclusion when she barely manages to escape to America and remains there for over 30 years before her story is told by the author of this account. In order to gain all the information in this book, the author had to play a cat-and-mouse game with Madame Nhu in which the author would be fed bits and pieces of little known information but never wholescale openness and trust. Madame Nhu, we learn, had reason to fear the vengeance of many who considered her responsible for thousands of deaths, losses and disasters that befell the Vietnamese people.
The story never loses the sense of intrigue, mystery, and exposure of truth and thus is a superb nonfiction account of a pivotal time in global history that affected the lives of millions to the present day. Finely crafted account of this very famous lady’s journey through the vicissitudes of Vietnamese and American history!
Posted March 9, 2014
Poorly written and very disappointing read. The author had nothing new. She stated in her book that she felt used by her subject and that her time was wasted. I feel that way as well.Was this review helpful? Yes NoThank you for your feedback. Report this reviewThank you, this review has been flagged.
Posted November 4, 2013
This is the captivating account of another enormously wasteful &
This is the captivating account of another enormously wasteful "dirty war", when national interests compete with personal greed and selfishness... and history is made through individual destinies great and small. Through the author's searching for Madame Nhu, we can share her feelings, between fascination and repulsion, admiration and compassion, and discover the complex personality of the Dragon Lady and the tragic destiny of her family and her people. It is an excellent history book I read like a thriller.Was this review helpful? Yes NoThank you for your feedback. Report this reviewThank you, this review has been flagged.
Posted October 22, 2013
WHAT A PAGETURNER!!!! I am more of a historical FICTION reader
WHAT A PAGETURNER!!!!Was this review helpful? Yes NoThank you for your feedback. Report this reviewThank you, this review has been flagged.
I am more of a historical FICTION reader myself....but I decided to take a chance after I read a few reviews.....
and I was TRANSPORTED by this book! I have so little knowledge of Vietnam and had never heard of Madam Nhu
before, so Mrs. Demery's research and interviews proved fascinating.
EQUALLY compelling, though, was Mrs. Demery's actual painstaking (and extremely patient and empathetic),
journey to accurately document her subject!! I have so many favorite parts, but I don't want to spoil a single page
of it for any new readers! I devoured it....and i think you will too!! How do we get Mrs. Demery to write an excerpt
of this book for Vanity Fair?!?!
Posted October 22, 2013
No text was provided for this review.