- Shopping Bag ( 0 items )
Posted March 27, 2012
I loved the book because of its wit and humor. It has drama and
I loved the book because of its wit and humor. It has drama and yet it still seems realistic. The only problem is that the ghost is never really explained, but that's life, isn't it? No bad guy to come out of the shadows and explain his brilliant plot...Was this review helpful? Yes NoThank you for your feedback. Report this reviewThank you, this review has been flagged.
Definitely read it! I engulfed this book in one sitting, but when you read it, don't rush. Instead, let Hicks' literary and artistic skills seep into your mind and lift your spirits. No pun intended.
Posted February 28, 2012
Charming Writing Prevails!
Book Review by Chris for Book SakeWas this review helpful? Yes NoThank you for your feedback. Report this reviewThank you, this review has been flagged.
The artist, who also happens to be the writer, has a very charming style. Her characters have expressive faces and all look unique. It is really easy to fall in love with Maggie right away.
The story has a bunch of fun moments. Maggie, the main character, getting accustomed to high school is just plain fun and creative. The problem I had was that it just seems like a collection of events that don’t really build on each or lead up to a conclusion.
In a way it reminded me of a Wes Anderson movie (Royal Tenenbaums, Life Aquatic). A group of semi-dysfunctional people who have lives that aren’t perfect and they don’t really get a happy ending. In a way though, you realize that this was the happiest ending they could hope for. I guess you could call that a more realistic ending, real life doesn’t have a swelling orchestra as the hero defeats the villain.
That being said, the ending did feel rather abrupt. Also the pitch of the story is ‘A coming-of-age tale with a spooky twist!’. The ghost element seems rather unneeded. At the end it isn’t explained. If anything, it tags on another element to the ghost story to make it more confusing.
Book Rating: 4/5
Book Review by Jessica for Book Sake
I wasn’t sure if I was going to like this book as much as Chris did, so before I read it I asked him if I should read it as well. I’ve had a love/hate relationship with graphic novels as I’m in it more for the story and often times I find graphic novels to be lacking in that department. This is a big exception to that thought. I freaking loved Friends with Boys.
While I agree with Chris that this story didn’t need the paranormal aspect to make the story, it didn’t detract from how much I liked the book. The ghost portion isn’t a huge part, but it’s touched on a few times throughout the story, so it’s not like it’s mentioned once and then never thought of again. However there is really no reason for it to be in the story and it would have stood up well without it.
What I did love about Friends with Boys was the fact that it had character development and a storyline that advanced forward smoothly. The main character Maggie is realistic and I felt for her being the new kid out of her element. Her family is entertaining and awesome even with their problems. The artwork was not only appropriate for the story, but was done very well and helped to show the storyline instead of hindering it. I was able to follow along with each frame – the artwork helping to lead my eye to the next frame easily. I finished this book in one sitting…instead of sleeping…and I love my sleep. This is definitely a graphic novel I’d recommend to those that have never read graphic novels and those that are avid readers.
Book Rating: 5/5