- Shopping Bag ( 0 items )
Most Helpful Favorable Review
3 out of 3 people found this review helpful.
I really liked this book a lot, but having said that, I actually
Island is about a man who ends up in this "paradise" and people who truly have found synergy in the way they live, interact and love. The place where they have found a way, as many try, to "harness human spirit". They tend to think of themselves as individuals, but working towards common goal and trying to better their society while still keeping their individual thinking. It all sounds great and as many have tried, to create a perfect world, but once again, we see that it is not possible. Not because it just can't be done, but because there is always someone, those, who tend to want something different from the rest. Whether it is good, bad, evil or however someone wants to judge that behavior, there are always those who do not give in or don't want to go along with the rest, no matter how good it might be.
The book, or better yet the society, that Huxley describes is pointing out that all the organized religions have a flow. At the same time, it points out that Buddhism allows the individual to be part of society, but still be an individual in their own sense of being. Well, I don't know enough about Buddhism to know for sure if that is the way of the Buddha or this is just their, Pala's way of Buddhism. I am pretty sure that if the book wanted to take a point of religion or lack of religion is either too constrictive or too relaxed, respectively, wouldn't it apply to most or all? Just pointing out that Huxley, in this fictional Utopian paradise, describes Buddhism or their form of Buddhism as a way of living in "here and now", therefore enjoying every moment and not some distant eternal life.
Through my martial arts training, I have read, taken and tried multiple forms of medication and ways of zen being. In the book, they talk in some depth about how meditating or inducing subconscious thinking, either naturally or through moksha-medicine, they are able to find their inner being, restore balance and "be happy". Everyone on the island can and should be able to induce this state at any given time. Huxley's fascination with describing induced Utopia involves suggestive or subconscious state. In Brave New World we have seen Soma and here through Moksha-medicine.
Even though they live in more or less equal society, if that was ever possible, they do have royalties and they do have those with more than normal human "greed" and "ambitions". In Pala, they don't have Socialism and they don't Capitalism. They live in harmony, where everyone contributes to society, to better that society and try various tasks, jobs that will better channel their natural ability and peek their interest for full satisfaction. They claim to have found a way to channel Muscle Man and Peter Pan types into challenges that make them non dangerous to society and also valuable in the sense of those abilities. It is a great way to ponder on something that can be done as such, but this is a fiction and in reality, there are those who can not be tamed and therefore lash out and develop on their natural human character. Human spirit is not possible to harness, condition or tame. Whether that spirit is good, to be an individual to strive for something that is not available or that spirit is to do evil and dwell on all that is wrong in the world, it cannot be contained. That is the nature behind any "Utopian" thinking and the problem behind it.
The human nature is to want to do what it tends to do with unpredictable and unconditional thought process. Even in every "type" and every "character" of specific group, there are still multiple personal characteristics to each and every being. Even in the same family, same upbringing and same genetic structure, you can never predict what and how each one of the kids, even those who are exactly alike, will react in any given situation and preventing that behavior, would be almost, and actually, impossible.
Overall, I really liked this book. It is not a fast reading page turner, but yet, it is a page turner nevertheless and I really enjoyed it for many reasons. I also kept thinking and comparing it a lot to "Celestine Prophesy". Somehow the spiritual aspect of the book kept remind me of that novel. If you are expecting something, as I have, you might be disappointed at first, but yet, I found it to be very well delivered message and a very interesting topic. I am glad that I picked it up and even though, not what I expected originally, still enjoyed it a lot. I was torn, because I wish there was 4.5 starts instead of like(4) and love(5) decision.
posted by JakeNJ on December 9, 2013Was this review helpful? Yes NoThank you for your feedback. Report this reviewThank you, this review has been flagged.
Most Helpful Critical Review
3 out of 4 people found this review helpful.
posted by Anonymous on September 5, 2003Was this review helpful? Yes NoThank you for your feedback. Report this reviewThank you, this review has been flagged.
Posted August 10, 2012
Join Moonclan at moonchild first result. All warriors get one extra life and medicine cats can have mates, because we are favored by Starclan. All spots except leader are open. If you want to join, respond as "To Moonstar". I also need somebody to rp Silkfur, our medicine cat. She is a silver she cat with light blue eyes. Plz join!
~Moonstar of Moonclan~
0 out of 4 people found this review helpful.Was this review helpful? Yes NoThank you for your feedback. Report this reviewThank you, this review has been flagged.
Posted April 7, 2012