- Shopping Bag ( 0 items )
Posted November 10, 2002
Mr. Parenti has written a book about the system and what actually is happening in the court rooms, police stations, and prisons of America. Regarless of Parenti's political ideology and personal background he has indeed presented the reader with actual facts. The arguement here is valid, and begs the reader to ask, "what does this mean to me?" From my experience with the prison system, I can say that everyone in this country needs to start paying attention, and asking questions. 'O Freedom!' What is your price ? Review, former Corrections Officer.Was this review helpful? Yes NoThank you for your feedback. Report this reviewThank you, this review has been flagged.
Posted June 28, 2002
A Hate-Filled Tirade
When I embarked upon this book, I expected a fair, analytical study of the American criminal justice system. What I got was anything but that. Parenti makes no secret of the fact that he has an agenda in this book. While I concede that Parenti is a bright man who clearly knows a great deal about the criminal justice system, the problems with this book were many: 1. Conspiracy Theory - I could not help but get the impression that this book promulgated a giant conspiracy theory. Parenti unambiguously asserts that the primary function of the law is to oppress African-Americans. While racism exists in this Country, I believe it a bit looney to believe that every law and every police initiative serves the primary function of advancing hate against minorities. 2. One-Sided - He tells many tales of police brutality, botched investigations, etc. but NEVER mentions anything that the criminal justice system has done to protect Americans. There are two sides to every story and Parenti ignores that fact. 3. Childish Insults - Parenti obviously harbors a great deal of anger towards the Republican Party and police departments nationwide. He often lets those feelings manifest themselves in a childish, often acidic manner. He calls Rudy Giuliani a 'ghoul,' he sarcastically calls Dan Quayle a 'towering intellect,' he calls Reagan's federal court appointees 'mean-spirited anti-crime zealots,' and he even goes so far as to mock the way New York Police Chiefs dress while off duty. 4. 250 Pages Of Complaining - All Parenti does in this book is complain. This makes it rather unfulfilling. Complaining is fine, but if you complain you should offer up some kind of solution to the problem. Parenti gives no ideas, no solutions, no recommendations as to what should be done to ameliorate the criminal justice system. The fact that Parenti is so biased certainly takes all credibility away from him. If you are looking for a scholarly, fair-minded study of the American criminal justice system, I HIGHLY recommend that you skip this book and look elsewhere.Was this review helpful? Yes NoThank you for your feedback. Report this reviewThank you, this review has been flagged.