- Shopping Bag ( 0 items )
Posted March 29, 2006
Nice illustrations but----
a HORRIBLE GUIDE! I am an arborist and use field guides all of the time. This is the WORST guide I have ever tried to use. There is little or no organization in the way each tree is described. Sometimes a tree's height is given in the opening description, other times you have to search for it in the body of the entry. Sometimes a flower is described, other times no description appears at all. Each feature that may define a tree is thrown in, in a slapdash manner, or left out, completely. It's as if the authors knew that NG was paying them big bucks for a guide, and they simply threw it together as fast as they could to get their paychecks. Forget ever trying to read this guide if you don't have your degree in the sciences, as I do. The terminology is straight out of Botany 101/102, and you'll use the glossary to make it through each and every tree description. FWIW, the measurements are given using the metric system. I guess it's a guide for Canadians, so if you're in the US and haven't been raised with metric measurements, you'll be frustrated on this count, as well. The tiny symbol key that lets you know which symbol stands for each type of area a given tree may be found in is almost impossible to make out. If you have a magnifying lense, you'll be OK. Again, if you like great illustrations of trees and their constituent parts, this guide may be for you. If you want a good guide that helps you identify trees easily--PASS THIS ONE BY!
3 out of 3 people found this review helpful.Was this review helpful? Yes NoThank you for your feedback. Report this reviewThank you, this review has been flagged.