One Good Turn (Jackson Brodie Series #2)

A Potpourri of Characters in a Mystery Novel

This tale opens with an incident of road rage, scary and all too real....but you are only seeing the tip of the iceberg. Here you are exposed to romance, mystery, greed, parenting, relationships, sickness and funny characters. The threads all weave together very nicely, even though you are doubtful any of what you are reading will relate to the mystery here. And, there are some memorable people you do not want to leave when the story ends. Jackson Brodie...a man who deals with his emotions and shares his thoughts and is also quite the crime fighter to boot. And my absolute favorite, Gloria Hatter who is manipulated by life itself and very slowly starts to realize what a victim she allowed herself to be. Her life becomes her focus when her husband becomes 'ill' under rather unpleasant circumstances and Gloria begins to see exactly what is terribly wrong in the world. The mystery is solved and you find yourself very intrigued when all the people scheduled for demise wind up in the same room with the killer...it would make a wonderful scene for a movie. And, the cherry on top of this wonderfully sweet treat is Gloria's renewal and growth and her take charge attitude for her future. Just absolutley delicious...Read this book.

5 out of 5 people found this review helpful.

E-Book formatting is terrible

Para-graphs are bro-ken up; full of hyphens in the mid-dle of sen-tences; question marks lit-ter the pages ? in random spots...WHO IS ? PROOFING THE E-EDI-TIONS OF YOUR BOOKS, BARNES??? & NO-BLE?

3 out of 3 people found this review helpful.

too much back story and not enough plot

The core plot was intriguing. Unfortunately, there was so much back story to flesh out the characters, it really seemed more like page fillers. I found myself skipping paragraphs just to get back to the main story.

1 out of 1 people found this review helpful.

Don not know what the fuss is about

I struggled to get through both her last 2 books. Won't be a third.

1 out of 3 people found this review helpful.

FUN, FUN, FUN!

Plan on sitting down and reading the entire book as reading a chapter here & there will not deliver. I loved this book - it offered me everything I want - a crime mystery, humour especially, humanity & reality. Greatly woven characters. I was surprised that I could not predict anything in this book - finally a plot that is fresh & fun.

1 out of 1 people found this review helpful.

ABSORBING STORY - FIRST-RATE NARRATION

Voice performer Robin Atkin Downes is a more than proficient actor - he's equipped to narrate in some 40 dialects. Television aficionados recognize him for his appearances on Nash Bridges, Beverly Hills 90210, Buffy the Vampire slayer and others. His London stage performances include starring in Dracula, Taming of the Shrew, Much Ado About Nothing, and more. He delivers a stellar reading of 'One Good Turn,' by Whitbread First Novel Award winner Kate Atkinson. What does a Good Samaritan get for his trouble? In the case of 50¿year-old Martin Canning, a second tier crime novelist who spends much time in wishful thinking, maybe a star in his crown but only a wealth of woes on this earth. Set in Edinburgh, Scotland, our story opens with a crowd of people witnessing what appears to be a minor bumper bash but quickly turns ugly. The driver of one of the vehicles jumps from his car and brutally attacks the other driver with a baseball bat. Just as a perhaps fatal blow is about to be delivered, someone in the crowd tosses a laptop case which deflects the attacker's aim. The tosser is Martin. For his life saving act, surely the most untoward thing he has ever done, Martin is robbed and worse. The crowd is quick to disperse, leaving listeners to believe that is the end of them. Not at all. Atkinson's magic pen brings them back, weaves them throughout her narrative in surprising ways. While we never know what life may hold in store, this author leads us on a fascinating journey of what it might. - Gail Cooke

1 out of 1 people found this review helpful.

Love the Character

I saw the first books in the series brought to life recently on PBS. The books were a definite "must read" after that. Like the character, and love the wit and dry humor Atkinson injects - makes me laugh out loud even while I marvel at the situations in which these characters find themselves. Will continue reading the series.

Amateur effort

While Case Histories was very good, One Good Turn is a failed effort as a mystery/thriller. The main character, Jackson Brodie, former cop and PI, witnesses a road rage incident. He can ID the culprit and gets license his plate BUT DOESN'T TELL THE COPS. Then he's attacked by the culprit BUT HE DOESN'T TELL THE COPS the guy who attacked him is wanted in the road rage incident. Instead, Brodie is arrested and he pleads guilty to assault. I'm not making this up. Atkinson did. If Brodie just said a couple of things to the cops, the book would come to an abrupt end. Instead, Atkinson, after hyping her hero as observant and smark, makes him stupid for no reason except to keep the plot going. She altered character to accommodate plot - an amateur mistake for novice mystery writers.

I love Kate Atkinson's books

This is no exception.

Would not recommend

Interesting twists and turns but a very disjointed book. Only grabbed me in the last 100 pages.

Great read!

Everyone comes together in this story, and even though it's a mystery, it's also funny

Highly recommended

Loved this book! Well developed and likable characters with wonderful twists and turns! Didn't want it to end.

0 out of 1 people found this review helpful.

Outstanding author, good story

This is the second book I have read by Kate Atkinson. She reminds me of our American author, John Irving. All the storylines throughout the novel are tied up neatly together at the end of the book. One trend I have noticed with many authors lately is having one or more Russian characters who are usually the bad guys. There was quite a varied cast of characters in this book. There were also variations on the long-suffering wife who comes out victorious. You do have to pay close attention as you read to keep the characters and storylines in order, but it is definitely worth the effort.

A Fun Mystery!

One incident at the beginning of this story ties a bunch of strangers together. Only they don't know it yet.

Kate Atkinson's characters are fun, quirky, and completely unique. Individually and together, they carry the plot along many twists and turns. A master of mystery, Atkinson kept me guessing until the very end.

This book has no serial killers, mass violence, or creepy, nail-biting suspense. Atkinson's talent for storytelling kept me turning the pages, [...] me in to her characters' world. No gimmicks required.

Kate Atkinson at her best

It is hard to express just how much I loved this book. After reading Case Histories, I was excited to read another novel featuring Jackson Brodie and I was not let down. Like Atkinson's other novels, this one is full of snarky humor, with a touch of sadness, and a fantastic mystery at it's heart. The characters stayed with me long after I was through reading it and the thing that impressed me most about this novel, was how satisfied the ending made me feel. I absolutely loved this book.

the ripple effect...

Sometimes, one event causes a ripple effect. This one tiny little occurrence causes people to come together who in other circumstances may never have met before. It also causes a chain of events that would otherwise never have happened. This story revolves around this ripple effect; a simple fender-bender at the beginning topples the very first domino.

I loved the characters in this book. Each one was definitely unique and real at the same time. I could relate to bits and pieces of Gloria, Louise, Jackson...even Martin. I loved getting into their heads and understanding their thoughts and emotions, as well as seeing the same event from their different perspectives. I also enjoyed the pictures of the Edinburgh scenery that the author paints for her readers. I have been there before, and it was great to be able to place the characters on the street that I have walked or the castle that I have visited.

The one downfall to this book was that the author was long-winded at times. In some parts she just talked too much. It did get a bit tedious, and we didn't really need that much information. The book could have been shorter and still brought the same idea across to her readers.

All in all, it was a great mystery and the twist at the end is definitely intriguing. You find out the true event that really started it all, and then it all comes together like a finished puzzle. Toward the end, I became a bit concerned because I was about 10 pages away and the author was teasing me with the loose ends still flapping about, but once I turned the last page I breathed a sigh of relief and was happy.

One Bad Turn

I had a difficult time getting into this book. One of the main characters was a writer who allowed everyone to walk all over him. He wrote a popular book series which he hated and constantly daydreamed about changing his life which always seemed to include having an old fashioned wife who would knit, cook, etc. I found myself mentally groaning when I came to a chapter featuring him and skimming to get through as quickly as possible. Essentially I finished the book because I spent money on it and felt guilty not doing so.

0 out of 1 people found this review helpful.

Good story, but goes soooooo slowly

I agree with most of the former reviewers. The basic twists and turns of the plot are wonderful, especially at the end when they finally come together. You certainly get to know the psyches of the characters, but a bit too well. That's what makes this story drag a bit more than it otherwise would. It did not hold my constant attention like such a book often does. By the book's second half I had developed more curiosity about the end, but it took too much muddling through the background thoughts of each character to get there. I have to admit that the unique prose style of the author is enjoyable, I just could have done without all the extraneous details.

Sure to please

Anyone who enjoys a mystery within a mystery will want to read One Good Turn. Like one of Atkinson's other books, Case Histories, the characters are woven together throughout the book. They are not your everyday mystery.

0 out of 1 people found this review helpful.

Twisting mystery

This is a fun read, a very British mystery. It starts with an 'incident', brutal road rage. Everyone involved, perpetrator, victim, bystanders and authorities are woven into the twisting, fun tale of a small town in Scotland.

0 out of 1 people found this review helpful.