- Shopping Bag ( 0 items )
Posted March 6, 2012
This is a wonderful book. Very comprehensive and covers the his
This is a wonderful book. Very comprehensive and covers the history of Florida, the politics surrounding the Everglades and the history of the Everglades itself. I thought the book would be dry, but it was so well written with so many interesting anecdotes, that I found it very easy to read. Every Floridian, every person who loves Florida, and anyone who cares about the environment should read this book.
1 out of 1 people found this review helpful.Was this review helpful? Yes NoThank you for your feedback. Report this reviewThank you, this review has been flagged.
Posted December 6, 2013
It's hard to critic a book that you genuinely enjoyed reading. I
It's hard to critic a book that you genuinely enjoyed reading. I can only find positive things to say about his writing and research. Grunwald gives an unbiased report. I never heard his opinion, but he did make it obvious. This is not a book saying that the Everglades do not need to be restored, or that we did not wreck the natural beauty. It's all cold hard fact. He presented the history of the Everglades like a storybook. He starts off at the beginning, the most important part. We cannot begin to learn of what happened to the Everglades without first knowing what it used to be. The detailed history gives the most important vision of all the things that once lived in this gorgeous ecosystem. Every important character is explained and described. Unlike most books, you could see the tale as you read the book. When he described Seminole Osceola, it was like I was looking at a picture of him.Was this review helpful? Yes NoThank you for your feedback. Report this reviewThank you, this review has been flagged.
He quotes diaries of discoverers and of the others outsiders who first set foot on this “wasteland”. While hunting Seminole Indians, a US soldier in the nineteenth century wrote, “it seems like a vast sea, filled with grass and green trees” (pg. 9). While not the most descriptive of the many quotes, it gives us the idea of what once used to be. This “wild and lonely” place has been picked and poked at for more than a century. “It's being made susceptible of cultivation – and instead of being, as now, a waster of waters, fit only for the resort of reptiles – would be a happy epoch for Florida,” said US Army General William Harney (pg. 54). Grunwald gives the “story of water’s journey and man’s effort to reroute it.” Through the eyes of an outsider, we're given an inside look of all the developers and politicians that made the swamp what it is today.
He made connections that were easy to understand. Comparing the Seminole War(s) to the guerilla warfare of Vietnam, he made this history relatable. We have seen videos and many pictures of Vietnam, but not of the lesser known Seminole Wars. He also gave such a great background on many of the main contributors to the history of the Everglades. It was fascinating to know how these people came into the position they were in. Reading a lot of text can be difficult, even if it is well written. Grunwald included eighteen pages of black and white photos and seven maps, giving the reader a reference to physically look at.Even though his words were as descriptive as the pictures, it gave the reader a full vision of not only the landscape, but the people involved.
This book is a great read, not just for the information but in general. I would have never guessed I would want to read a book about the Everglades, but my mind has been changed. Not only has it given me a new outlook on the environment of south Florida, but I also have learned the reason that my Florida State sweatshirt says “Seminoles” on it, and who their mascot is. Being an Environmental Studies minor, I catch myself referencing this book for other classes as well. Not only did it completely engulf me in it's history, it taught me the importance of preservation and how hard it is to try to fix a mess that we have made in the environment. I have never been to the Everglades, let alone learned anything about them. With the perfect mix of environmentalism and politics, I now know what a treasure they are.
Posted June 26, 2013
Posted May 30, 2012