- Shopping Bag ( 0 items )
Posted January 28, 2002
I had high hopes for this since I thought 'The Lone Ranger and Tonto Fistfight in Heaven' was maybe the funniest book I've ever read... but it didn't really live up to my hopes. Some of the stories are good, some others I just gave up on completely. On the plus side, Alexie always does a neat job of writing about Indians in all walks of life - professional, homeless, city, rural, etc.Was this review helpful? Yes NoThank you for your feedback. Report this reviewThank you, this review has been flagged.
Posted January 17, 2002
kind of a mixed bag
this collection of stories contains some gems and some that are pretty bad. it's tough to judge sherman alexie on this collection. 'Assimilation' is a story that had a lot of potential until it started to become choppy and just ended. 'toughest indian in the world' was a good story until the end, when it took a homosexual twist for no purpose at all. and in the closing words of the story alexie seemed to be trying to say something, just not anything the reader will pick up. 'south by southwest' made some sort of attempt at being profound gay fiction but failed almost as miserably as the plot. 'the sin eaters' is by far the best piece in the collection. it's what kafka would have written if he were indian. this story is a rarity in the collection, it starts off well and doesn't fizzle out. 'saint junior' is a sweet story about love that just isn't interesting. 'dear john wayne'...it's tough to figure out just what alexie was trying to do here. 'one good man' is another sweet story about the love between a father and son, that, like 'saint junior' just isn't interesting, though the candy hunt passage was good. i can't say not to purchase this collection, because you should read 'the sin eaters' but maybe you should borrow it if you know someone who has a copy.Was this review helpful? Yes NoThank you for your feedback. Report this reviewThank you, this review has been flagged.