- Shopping Bag ( 0 items )
Posted September 5, 2012
A must read
Elizabeth Pisani has written an informative book that gives you a solid look at how governments shape how money is used when trying to help people.Was this review helpful? Yes NoThank you for your feedback. Report this reviewThank you, this review has been flagged.
The book introduces you to people who care about how those with AIDS are treated. You will meet people who although they have this deadly disease live full and interesting lives.
This is a book you will not find boring, it has wit and humor and compassion.
I recommend this be placed on your reading list.
Posted July 11, 2010
An Engaging and Informative Overview of Effective HIV Policy
After nearly a decade of conducting AIDS/HIV research in Southeast Asia, Elizabeth Pisani recants the lessons she has learned while helping governments and NGO's reduce the spread of this disease. From stressing the importance of adequate disease surveillance to clearly outlining the ways that AIDS/HIV spreads throughout societies, Pisani clearly states the measures that must be taken in order to curtail the AIDS/HIV epidemic. In short, needle exchange programs as well as abundant access to condoms and lubricant for at-risk populations--mostly prostitutes, their customers, and drug injectors--offer the most potential for limiting the infection rate.Was this review helpful? Yes NoThank you for your feedback. Report this reviewThank you, this review has been flagged.
Overall, Pisani provides an insightful book. She responds to numerous counterarguments, provides a vast array of empirical evidence, as well as many personal anecdotes as case studies. Her passion and demand for policy clearly shows. She has avoided adopting any degree of ideology, developing policy recommendations that stem directly from evidence. Her work should be commended and utilized.
Pisani is a staunch advocate for HIV/AIDS prevention and her policies stem from that perspective. In other words, her analysis does not include other perspectives within social sciences. For example, Pisani argues that forcing NGOs to purchase supplies and materials from U.S. companies creates a highly inefficient system for providing AIDS/HIV prevention and treatment. However, she does not provide an economic analysis of this policy. In short, the added revenue to U.S. companies and subsequent boost to the American economy may outweigh the ineffectiveness within the HIV/AIDS prevention and treatment industry. Or it may not. Either way, Pisani neglects to provide analysis and her policies should be analyzed from several lenses before being adopted to avoid any unintended consequences.
Lastly, Pisani acknowledges the political dilemma for implementing her policy suggestion: people don't like doing nice things for junkies like needle exchanges. She fails to provide any solutions to overcome this dilemma. Though creating awareness and understanding of the HIV epidemic is certainly one useful strategy (and one assumes this book is part of that strategy), Pisani never explains a framework for moving forward. Then again, Pisani is an epidemiologist and shouldn't be faulted for not developing a strategy of policy advocation.
This book is required reading for anyone involved with AIDS/HIV. Not only has Pisani presented a decades worth of work in an incredibly engaging book, her work has immediate implications for NGOs and governments worldwide. Highly accessible and deeply informative characterizes the entire book.
For more reviews and a summary of Pisani's main points, find us at Hand of Reason.
Posted April 9, 2010
Pisani is an excellent writer and makes a crazy topic understandable while allowing us to even laugh at the ridiculous-ness of the HIV/AIDS world. Being un-afraid to call a spade a spade, her frank-ness is refreshing. Too many of us (myself included) count on this industry for our bread and butter and do not have the skills or the networks and authority to share such wisdom. Glad Pisani is there to do it. I hope the global health donors and other decisionmakers all read this and tune into the fact that we are not doing what needs to be done!Was this review helpful? Yes NoThank you for your feedback. Report this reviewThank you, this review has been flagged.
Posted August 14, 2011
No text was provided for this review.