AnnaLeigh is the wife of the successful Reverend Isaiah Scott. Their marriage was deeply rooted in the church that they built together. Somehow, they lost sight of eachother as their congregation multiplied like loaves and fishes and they each became consumed with separate day-to-day routines.

AnnaLeigh's mysterious disappearance and her husband's delayed reaction lead police investigators to suspect foul play. As more evidence is uncovered in the search, the police are left to conclude that there is more to her life than Bible study and singing in the choir. The real question is: What does her husband know and was it enough to push him over the edge to break the first commandment?