the Imagination Failure
Asked and answered is the central insight of The 9/11 Commission Report. Richard Holbrooke posed the question: ¿How can a man in a cave outcommunicate the world¿s leading communications society?¿ (Pp. 377.) [This is the most vital of all the components of the attack and this war we find ourselves in. It is a war about ideas, the future, and hope. And these are uniquely human properties best understood via the framework of language and communication.] The Commission answered: ¿¿four kinds of failures: in imagination, policy, capabilities, and management. (pp.339) The latter three spill down from the first. And in reading the step-by-step account of the attack reported in the Commission¿s book¿the salient Imagination, or lack of, belongs to the 43rd President of the United States, George W. Bush. Contrary to what the administration has repeatedly said in framing its defense-- the terrorists don¿t, or in this case didn¿t, have to be right just once. In fact, they have to have so many contingencies break in their favor to be successful in an attack of the magnitude of 9/11-- that it seems nearly impossible that they did succeed! In other words, that attack was a sort of ¿perfect storm¿. The report specifies what is necessary in order for terrorists to succeed: leadership; communication; personnel; training; security; intelligence; travel; money; coordination; timing and time itself. Any misstep or bad luck and the spectacular attack of 9/11 would not have happened. That it did happen is not so much a case of the systems and capabilities not being sufficient¿they were; but rather the mindset (imagination) of the President. The report details just how remarkable the intelligence information and its significance must be in order to reach the status of headlining the PDB (presidents daily brief). On August 6th, 2001 the terrorist threat had crossed that threshold and screamed: ¿Bin Laden Determined to Strike in US.¿ This followed intelligence reports with these declarations: Qaeda activity ¿had reached a crescendo¿; something ¿very,very,very,very¿ big was about to happen; ¿Bin Ladin Planning High-Profile Attacks.¿ [the threat] could not ¿get any worse¿. The President pooh-poohed it as ¿historical¿. I am familiar enough with Bush¿s mannerisms that I can picture him reading that PDB, looking up from his desk and saying ¿Yeah¿ and then proceed to tell anyone and everyone just how it 'really¿ is¿and get ready for his vacation back at the ranch. Historical in his mind was likely defined as anything left over from the previous president. He had his own ideas (or the ideas of his advisors) about what was, or was not, a threat and that¿s the way it is! I cannot help but think that in all likelihood, had Clinton still been President¿the attack would have been foiled. Clinton took al Qaeda as real and the most menacing foreign threat facing America. He would have responded differently to ¿The System Blinking Red¿. [I have no idea how Al Gore would have responded.] The point is this: the attack of 9/11 succeeded because the ability to respond to a ¿system blinking red¿ was not inherent in President Bush. He did not take the threat seriously. He lacked the imagination to see it and to take any additional steps to counter it. Period. And now¿the threat has changed and he can¿t see that. All that has been done since September of 01 has done two things. First, made the repeat of that attack impossible, (Yes, in that regard we are safer. Steps have been taken that have undoubtedly sufficiently disrupted the necessary components, that made it possible that domestic jet airliners could be hijacked and used as missiles to attack targets in America.) That won¿t happen again. And second, America¿s foreign policy has significantly increased the hatred towards America throughout the world. That hatred spawns individuals willing to wage an unconventional war against America. The number of such individuals has greatly increased. In that re
Was this review helpful? Yes NoThank you for your feedback.
Report this reviewThank you, this review has been flagged.