A History of American Legal Culture: Cases and Materials

A History of American Legal Culture: Cases and Materials

by Kermit L. Hall, William M. Wiecek, Paul Finkelman
     
 

Approaching American legal history from a new perspective, this text employs cases and other legal documents to reveal the law's underlying culture. American Legal History provides a comprehensive selection of the most important documents—well over 170—which integrate the history of public and private law from America's colonial origins to the present. It

Overview

Approaching American legal history from a new perspective, this text employs cases and other legal documents to reveal the law's underlying culture. American Legal History provides a comprehensive selection of the most important documents—well over 170—which integrate the history of public and private law from America's colonial origins to the present. It devotes special attention to the interaction of social and legal change, shows how legal ideas developed in tandem with specific historical events, and reveals a rich legal culture unique to America. Introductions and explanations accompany each document, tying legal developments to broader historical themes and providing a social and political context essential to an understanding of the history of law in America. Offering a thorough examination of both public and private law, American Legal History is essential for students and teachers of constitutional and legal history, the judicial process, and the effects of law on society.

Editorial Reviews

Stephen S. Meinhold
AMERICAN LEGAL HISTORY already had a place on my bookshelf before I was asked to review it for this list. Having used AMERICAN LEGAL HISTORY as a reference in developing my lectures and to answer undergraduates' questions it was a pleasure to reconsider the book in toto. Hall, Wiecek and Finkelman have compiled an authoritative, exhaustive and useful collection of legal and political documents relating to America's legal history. All three of the editors are professors of history and Hall and Wiecek are professors of law. The book is intended for undergraduate and graduate courses in political science and history and is comprised of excerpts from cases and documents. Headnotes that provide an appropriate context are included with each document. The table of contents is well-structured and easy to use. I recommend this book for your personal and institutional libraries. AMERICAN LEGAL HISTORY is organized chronologically into eleven chapters starting with Chapter 1: "Law in the Morning of American: The Beginnings of American Law, to 1760" and ending with Chapter 11: "Individual and Community in the Legal Culture, 1988-1994." Each chapter begins with an introduction written by the editors, followed by appropriate cases and documents and substantive notes linking the various documents together and providing social, political and legal context. The chapters vary in the balance between cases and documents, with some including mostly cases and others mostly documents. One can quibble about the editing of the cases and documents and the decisions regarding which ones to include or exclude, but, in my opinion, the editors have safely captured the entire sweep of American legal history in a volume of reasonable length. While most of the cases excerpted in AMERICAN LEGAL HISTORY can be found in other popular casebooks, it is rare to find so many legal and political documents in a single place. The inclusion of a wide variety of documents relating to the development of law in America strengthens the reader's ability to place the cases in an appropriate context. Hall, Wiecek and Finkelman include excerpts from a variety of sources such as presidential addresses, political philosophy, constitutions and statutes. A sample of the material from Chapter 4: "Slavery, the Civil War, and Reconstruction" includes case excerpts from DRED SCOTT v. SANDFORD (1857) and The SLAUGHTERHOUSE CASES (1873) and excerpts from Abraham Lincoln's speeches, Mississippi's Black Codes, and the Articles of Impeachment Against Andrew Johnson. Likewise Chapter 8: "Total War, Civil Liberties, and Civil Rights" includes excerpts from well known cases such as SCHENCK v. UNITED STATES (1919), WEST VIRGINIA STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION v. BARNETTE (1943), and OLMSTEAD v. UNITED STATES (1928) as well as Louis D. Brandeis and Samuel Warren's "The Right to Privacy" and Roscoe Pound and Felix Frankfurter's "Criminal Justice in Cleveland" (1922). The inclusion of these original documents increases AMERICAN LEGAL HISTORY's usefulness. Hall, Wiecek and Finkelman include substantive introductions to each chapter, headnotes for each document, and additional substantive notes for many of the documents. This material helps the reader locate the documents and cases in an appropriate social, political, and legal context. I found the material invaluable for improving my lectures and providing background for class discussions. The introductions and notes often make references to additional cases and documents that point the interested reader in directions for further research. For undergraduates writing research papers on the subjects covered in AMERICAN LEGAL HISTORY, it would be a good place to start. The strength of AMERICAN LEGAL HISTORY for most political scientists will be its value as a reference. It is not a book I would consider adopting as the primary text for my undergraduate courses in Constitutional Law or Judicial Politics. While the material is presented thoughtfully and carefully the authors quest to "let the documents of legal history speak for themselves" (p. v) sacrifices the development of lines of inquiry and themes more appropriate for undergraduate political science courses. I can imagine some limited use for it in a graduate seminar on the American Legal System and I leave open the question of its usefulness in history courses to historians. For teachers and researchers in political science who want an excellent collection of cases and documents pertaining to our legal system AMERICAN LEGAL HISTORY fits the bill.

Product Details

ISBN-13:
9780195059076
Publisher:
Oxford University Press, USA
Publication date:
04/25/1991
Pages:
624
Product dimensions:
6.31(w) x 9.56(h) x 1.35(d)

Meet the Author

Ohio State University

Syracuse University

University of Tulsa

Customer Reviews

Average Review:

Write a Review

and post it to your social network

     

Most Helpful Customer Reviews

See all customer reviews >