Just as the
rock mainstream was turning its attentions toward
techno,
Moby abandoned
electronic music to refashion himself as an alternative rocker -- sort of like a cross between
Nine Inch Nails and
Smashing Pumpkins -- for
Animal Rights.
Moby attempted
rock on
Everything Is Wrong, but on
Animal Rights, his thin, psuedo-
industrial guitar riffs dominate the proceedings, with his
ambient soundscapes being pushed to the back of the record. Though
Moby could be commended for having the courage to diversify, he simply isn't very good at
alternative rock -- his voice is thin and undistinguished, his rhythms are too tight, his guitars sound anemic, and he can't write a hook. In fact, he even buries the hook in his ill-conceived cover of
Mission of Burma's
post-punk classic
"That's When I Reach for My Revolver." Consequently,
Animal Rights ranks as one of the classic failed albums, right alongside
Sinead O'Connor's big-band
Am I Not Your Girl? ~ Stephen Thomas Erlewine
