Beethoven: Symphony No. 5; Symphony No. 1

Beethoven: Symphony No. 5; Symphony No. 1

by Paavo Järvi
     
 

With performances this strong, subtle, and vital, there are only two negative charges that can be made against this disc by Paavo J�rvi and the Deutsches Kammerphilharmonie Bremen coupling Beethoven's "First" and "Fifth" symphonies: why does the sound have so much echo and why does the "Fifth Symphony" come before the "First"? UsingSee more details below

Overview

With performances this strong, subtle, and vital, there are only two negative charges that can be made against this disc by Paavo J�rvi and the Deutsches Kammerphilharmonie Bremen coupling Beethoven's "First" and "Fifth" symphonies: why does the sound have so much echo and why does the "Fifth Symphony" come before the "First"? Using B�renreiter's New Urtext Edition, with its thousands of corrections big and small, J�rvi and the Bremen musicians have created performances of both works that rival the greatest ever recorded. Their "First" is poised and witty with plenty of energy in the Allegros, lots of charm in the Andante cantabile, and a sly sense of humor in the phrasing of the finale's Adagio opening that is truly Beethovenian. Great as their "First" is, their "Fifth" is immeasurably greater: vigorously contended, inspiringly idealistic, and victorious. No matter how many "Fifths" one may have heard, J�rvi and the Bremen's opening motif will be a welcome surprise. True, the Bremen strings' vibrato is minimal and the brass and tympani are often well forward in the balances. But the former is historically appropriate, the later undeniably effective, and taken in context of J�rvi's amazing combination of textural fidelity and interpretive charisma, they are wholly justifiable. So why do the performances sound as if either they were recorded in a large empty hall or were doctored afterwards to enhance the reverb? In longer pauses after louder tuttis, the sound of the last notes has not faded before the next notes are sounded, an effect that inevitably diminishes the impact of the next notes. And why was the "Fifth" programmed before the "First"? Certainly, starting the disc with the slashing attack of the most famous four notes in classical music is more exciting than starting with the piquant harmonic twist, but wouldn't the blazing brass perorations of the "Fifth"'s finale also have made a more exciting conclusion? Still, in the final analysis, J�rvi and the Deutsches Kammerphilharmonie Bremen recording of Beethoven's "Fifth" and "First" symphonies will be mandatory listening for anyone seriously interested in the composer.

Read More

Product Details

Release Date:
01/06/2009
Label:
Rca
UPC:
0886973383520
catalogNumber:
733835
Rank:
8120

Related Subjects

Tracks

  1. Symphony No. 5 in C minor ("Fate"), Op. 67  - Ludwig van Beethoven  - Paavo Järvi  - Paavo Järvi  -  German Chamber Philharmonic, Bremen  -  German Chamber Philharmonic, Bremen
  2. Symphony No. 1 in C major, Op. 21  - Ludwig van Beethoven  - Paavo Järvi  - Paavo Järvi  -  German Chamber Philharmonic, Bremen  -  German Chamber Philharmonic, Bremen

Read More

Album Credits

Read More

Customer Reviews

Average Review:

Write a Review

and post it to your social network

     

Most Helpful Customer Reviews

See all customer reviews >