Blue-Eyed Child of Fortune: The Civil War Letters of Colonel Robert Gould Shawby Robert Shaw, Russell Duncan, William S. McFeely
Pub. Date: 11/18/1999
Publisher: University of Georgia Press
On the Boston Common stands one of the great Civil War memorials, a magnificent bronze sculpture by Augustus Saint-Gaudens. It depicts the black soldiers of the Fifty-fourth Massachusetts Infantry marching alongside their young white commander, Colonel Robert Gould Shaw. When the philosopher William James dedicated the memorial in May 1897, he stirred the assembled
On the Boston Common stands one of the great Civil War memorials, a magnificent bronze sculpture by Augustus Saint-Gaudens. It depicts the black soldiers of the Fifty-fourth Massachusetts Infantry marching alongside their young white commander, Colonel Robert Gould Shaw. When the philosopher William James dedicated the memorial in May 1897, he stirred the assembled crowd with these words: "There they march, warm-blooded champions of a better day for man. There on horseback among them, in the very habit as he lived, sits the blue-eyed child of fortune."
In this book Shaw speaks for himself with equal eloquence through nearly two hundred letters he wrote to his family and friends during the Civil War. The portrait that emerges is of a man more divided and complexthough no less heroicthan the Shaw depicted in the celebrated film Glory. The pampered son of wealthy Boston abolitionists, Shaw was no abolitionist himself, but he was among the first patriots to respond to Lincoln's call for troops after the attack on Fort Sumter. After Cedar Mountain and Antietam, Shaw knew the carnage of war firsthand. Describing nightfall on the Antietam battlefield, he wrote, "the crickets chirped, and the frogs croaked, just as if nothing unusual had happened all day long, and presently the stars came out bright, and we lay down among the dead, and slept soundly until daylight. There were twenty dead bodies within a rod of me."
When Federal war aims shifted from an emphasis on restoring the Union to the higher goal of emancipation for four million slaves, Shaw's mother pressured her son into accepting the command of the North's vanguard black regiment, the Fifty-fourth Massachusetts. A paternalist who never fully reconciled his own prejudices about black inferiority, Shaw assumed the command with great reluctance. Yet, as he trained his recruits in Readville, Massachusetts, during the early months of 1963, he came to respect their pluck and dedication. "There is not the least doubt," he wrote his mother, "that we shall leave the state, with as good a regiment, as any that has marched."
Despite such expressions of confidence, Shaw in fact continued to worry about how well his troops would perform under fire. The ultimate test came in South Carolina in July 1863, when the Fifty-fourth led a brave but ill-fated charge on Fort Wagner, at the approach to Charleston Harbor. As Shaw waved his sword and urged his men forward, an enemy bullet felled him on the fort's parapet. A few hours later the Confederates dumped his body into a mass grave with the bodies of twenty of his men. Although the assault was a failure from a military standpoint, it proved the proposition to which Shaw had reluctantly dedicated himself when he took command of the Fifty-fourth: that black soldiers could indeed be fighting men. By year's end, sixty new black regiments were being organized.
A previous selection of Shaw's correspondence was privately published by his family in 1864. For this volume, Russell Duncan has restored many passages omitted from the earlier edition and has provided detailed explanatory notes to the letters. In addition he has written a lengthy biographical essay that places the young colonel and his regiment in historical context.
- University of Georgia Press
- Publication date:
- Edition description:
- New Edition
- Sales rank:
- Product dimensions:
- 6.12(w) x 9.25(h) x 1.22(d)
Most Helpful Customer Reviews
See all customer reviews
Colonel Shaw was an outstanding american. He gave his life for freedom. In that time period, even for the Union Army, blacks wernt considered a "real man" yet. Shaw looked past the socitey's veiwpoints, on african americans. He was proud of his men and died for his men. He was a HERO.
Russell Duncan's compilation of war letters from Colonel Shaw of the 54th Massachusetts succeeds in one area and flounders in another. The letters themselves are eloquent and enjoyable: they provide a graphic portrayal both of the hardships this young soldier endured, his struggles to become his own man in the face of intelligent, reformist and sometimes domineering parents, and his development and leadership of his black regiment (we need to notice that this is a selection; Duncan has left out some letters which would introduce a more mature, humanitarian and politically canny Shaw to the reader). The notes, with a few exceptions, clarify the letters and make them accessible. My problem is with Duncan's introductory biography. He doesn't seem well-grounded in mid-19th Century family relationships, and his transposition of 20th Century mother-love battles doesn't help understand Shaw's family or his place in it. Duncan also seems to struggle with concepts like abolitionism, egalitarianism, elitism, and what we would call today 'classism' and 'racism.' He blurrs these together and measures them against a baseline of today's thinking, a controversial practice which gives some historians pause. Readers need to salt this collection with Fredrickson's 'The Inner Civil War' (a classic available since 1965) and the more recent 'The Vacant Chair' (1992, Reid Mitchell). In sum, the letters are worth the cost of the book, the prologue and some of the conclusions he draws in the notes, less so.