The Book Borrower: A Novel [NOOK Book]


On the day they first meet in a city playground, Deborah Laidlaw lends Toby Ruben a book called Trolley Girl, the memoir of a forgotten trolley strike in the 1920s, written by the sister of a fiery Jewish revolutionary who played an important, ultimately tragic role in the events. Young mothers with babies, Toby and Deborah become instant friends. It is a relationship that will endure for decades—through the vagaries of marriage, career, and child-rearing, through heated discussions of politics, ethics, and ...

See more details below
The Book Borrower: A Novel

Available on NOOK devices and apps  
  • NOOK Devices
  • NOOK HD/HD+ Tablet
  • NOOK
  • NOOK Color
  • NOOK Tablet
  • Tablet/Phone
  • NOOK for Windows 8 Tablet
  • NOOK for iOS
  • NOOK for Android
  • NOOK Kids for iPad
  • PC/Mac
  • NOOK for Windows 8
  • NOOK for PC
  • NOOK for Mac
  • NOOK Study
  • NOOK for Web

Want a NOOK? Explore Now

NOOK Book (eBook)
$10.99 price


On the day they first meet in a city playground, Deborah Laidlaw lends Toby Ruben a book called Trolley Girl, the memoir of a forgotten trolley strike in the 1920s, written by the sister of a fiery Jewish revolutionary who played an important, ultimately tragic role in the events. Young mothers with babies, Toby and Deborah become instant friends. It is a relationship that will endure for decades—through the vagaries of marriage, career, and child-rearing, through heated discussions of politics, ethics, and life—until an insurmountable argument takes the two women down divergent paths. But in the aftermath of crisis and sorrow, it is a borrowed book, long set aside and forgotten, that will unite Toby and Deborah once again.

Read More Show Less

Editorial Reviews

New York Times Book Review
A of those uncommon writers who are genuinely tickled by the ids and egos they commit to paper.
New York Times
In deceptively quiet, guileless prose, she has described the mind numbing routine of child-care and the fraught, complex relations of men and women. Only Margaret Atwood (in Cat's Eye has written as knowingly about the frienship between women. Emotionally wrenching, beautifully realized work.
New Yorker
This excellent novel weaves the story of a 1921 trolley strike...Mattison is concerned with the small decisions and coincidences that alter the course of our lives. Are they accidents, or impulses born of something deeper? Mattison's observations are so minutely compelling that each one feels like a shiny object, once lost but found unexpectedly.
Wall Street Journal
An ambitious and original novel...The author's determination not to tie things up is refreshing.
Washington Post Book World
Publishers Weekly - Publisher's Weekly
The pleasures, intimacies, tensions and failures of female friendship frame this subtle, psychologically rich novel, which chronicles the volatile relationship between two women and highlights issues of loyalty, sacrifice and guilt. In brisk, energetic prose, Mattison (Hilda and Pearl) investigates the prickly territory between affection and unconscious jealousy, avowals of devotion and secret betrayals, commitment and selfishness. On the day in 1975 when they meet in a Boynton, Mass., playground with their respective young children, Deborah Laidlaw loans Toby Ruben Trolley Girl, a book about a tragic trolley-car accident that occurred in the town in 1920. Ample, embracing, generous Deborah is a Catholic earth mother. Ruben (she thinks of herself only by her surname) is a harder person, Brooklyn-born, rough-edged, subconsciously resentful, Jewish. Despite their apparent incompatibility and Ruben's competitive streak, the two women sustain a deep attachment over two decades, interrupted twice when Ruben causes Deborah grief (and her job) by denigrating her teaching ability (a profession they both share). But an essential affinity always draws them back together, and they debate existential questions in a quirky sort of verbal shorthand, until the day when Deborah declares to Ruben: "You have a kindness defect,'' and admits she's frightened of Ruben's harsh assessment of herself and others. Suddenly, Deborah's death in an auto accident and the reappearance of the book Ruben borrowed long ago (passages from which have been interspersed in the narrative) connect. Trolley Girl's protagonist--an unrepentant anarchist who caused the deadly accident when she was young--turns out to be an elderly sculptor already entwined in Ruben's life. Through her, Ruben achieves insights into the insidious ways unconscious anger can undermine relationships. Mattison constructs her layered plot with the skill of a gem-setter, showing small facets of Ruben's growing understanding of her own failings as a friend and human being, and as she finally understands Deborah's legacy of tolerance and hope. Agent, Zoe Pagnamenta, Wylie. (Oct.) Copyright 1999 Cahners Business Information.
Library Journal
When Toby meets Deborah at the playground, they strike up a conversation about their children and become friends. Deborah lends Toby a book about a trolley strike in the 1920s, which she reads sporadically and then puts aside and forgets. Twenty years later, after Deborah is killed in a car crash, the devastated Toby discovers that sculptress Berry Cooper, who features prominently in the book, is living nearby. Prompted to rediscover the book, Toby finally finishes it, thus coming to terms with Deborah's death. The novel unfolds in jerky fits and starts at ten-year intervals, and the parallel story lines interweave, showing how the past is inextricably linked to the present. The characters are well drawn and realistic, the language and culture vivid. A worthwhile follow-up to Mattison's 1997 hit story collection, Men Giving Money, Women Yelling.--Joanna M. Burkhardt, Univ. of Rhode Island Coll. of Continuing Education Lib., Watch Hill Copyright 1999 Cahners Business Information.
John Freeman
{A} powerfully told story, likely to become for the Atlanta child murders what Kurt Vonnegut's Slaughterhouse Five became for the firebombing of Dresden... These Bones is a brave achievement.
Time Out: New York
Daphne Uviller
Alice Mattison is a pro at creating profound connections between unlikely people, places and now, even books...a serious, significant examination of the institution of friendship.
Time Out: New York
Kirkus Reviews
Mattison's third novel (after Hilda and Pearl, 1995, etc.) is actually a successful graft of two tales: one written by a 1920s feminist and radical, the other about the woman who reads that "first book" in the late 20th century. While Deborah Laidlaw and another mother, Toby Ruben, look after their children in the park, Deborah lends Toby a memoir, Trolley Girl, recounting the Lipkin sisters' involvement in a 1921 trolley strike. Miriam Lipkin writes of her two sisters; Jessie, a young radical determined to support the strike, participates in protests and stands in contrast to quiet, cheerful Sarah, who is killed in a trolley collision. Later, Jessie is implicated in what is seen as a murder, and though she's acquitted, she's alienated forever from her family. Miriam, meanwhile, changed her name to Berry Cooper and enjoyed modest success as a sculptor. The "second book" deals with difficult, sometimes unpleasant people. Toby describes her friendship with Deborah from the '70s to the present, often behaving like a younger, respectful sister toward her. When she meets Deborah's husband, Jeremiah, in a drawing class, he tells Toby of Berry Cooper's career. After Deborah dies in an auto accident, Toby cautiously returns to the memoir she'd abandoned long ago. Berry then enters Toby's real life when her grown-up son Peter becomes a care-giver to the now-elderly artist, and Toby takes over when Peter disappears. Still grieving for Deborah, Toby also has to confront the possible loss of her son. It's through this ordeal that Berry serves as an oracular, nonsensical/wise guide. She's a wonderful creation, and Mattison writes her as a quirky, unpredictable spirit, simultaneously maintainingToby's grave meditations on her best friend's death. A rich, textured exploration of misfortune and its consequences: a book that will reward any reader willing to go slowly and absorb its course.
Read More Show Less

Product Details

  • ISBN-13: 9780062232014
  • Publisher: HarperCollins Publishers
  • Publication date: 8/7/2012
  • Format: eBook
  • Pages: 304
  • Sales rank: 533,315
  • File size: 321 KB

Meet the Author

Alice Mattison is the award-winning author of four story collections and five novels, including Nothing Is Quite Forgotten in Brooklyn. She teaches fiction in the graduate writing program at Bennington College in Vermont and lives in New Haven, Connecticut.

Read More Show Less

Read an Excerpt

The Book Borrower
A Novel

Chapter One

Though she was pushing a baby carriage, Toby Ruben began to read a book, On a gray evening in late November 1920 and the wheel of the carriage a big, skeletal but once elegant Perego she'd found in somebody s trash rolled into a broken place in the sidewalk. The baby, tightly wrapped in a white receiving blanket, glided compactly from carriage to sidewalk. He didn't cry. Like his mother, the baby would be troubled more by missed human connections than by practical problems; also the three-second rule held: as if he were a fallen slice of bread, Ruben snatched him up and ate him. Kissed him passionately and all over, dropping the wicked book into the carriage. She put the baby back where he belonged and picked up the book, but she didn't read for at least a block. Then she did read.

On a gray evening in late November 1920, an observer who happened to be making his way up the hill from Dressier's Mills to the streetcar line that ran to the principal square of Boynton, Massachusetts, might have noticed a sturdy young woman hurrying through the mill s gates. The air was full of cinders, which must have been why she reached up to tie a veil over her face, though she did so with a gesture so casual, so obviously

Ruben had to cross a street. She closed the book. It was thin, with black covers, not new.

Want a book? a woman in the park had said. The woman wore a blue-and-white-checked dress like a pioneer s, but sleeveless. A wide neckline bared her freckled chest; with good posture she chased serious, muddy daughters in pink pinafores. Ruben s baby, Squirrel, was three months old. Go, Squirrel, go, Ruben shouted, just sothe woman, sweeping by, would speak.

What? Sunny hair rose and settled.

He's trying to put his thumb in his mouth.

The woman leaned over to look, her hair over her face, and Squirrel found his thumb for the first time. Excellent, said the woman, Deborah Laidlaw, straightening, then giving a push to the small of her back. She left her hand there. When their conversation, skipping some subjects, arrived at sex and husbands, Deborah said, Jeremiah has intercourse only to music.

Any music?

Folk songs.

It was 1975.

Fuck songs! Ruben was surprised to have said that. Her hair was dark red but thin, and she was shorter than this impressive Deborah. In the songs, Ruben supposed, people built dams, harpooned whales, or cut down trees, while Jeremiah penetrated his wife.

History. He'll read any book about history, said Deborah, but mostly trolleys.


Streetcars. He s obsessed with the interurbans. But there aren't any songs about trolleys.

Clang, clang, clang went the trolley! sang Ruben, flat who never sang for anyone but the baby.

Doesn't count. Want a book?

Jeremiah had found it in a used bookstore. He had begged Deborah to read it, but she only carried it back and forth to the park in a striped yellow-and-white cotton tote bag.

I am not interested in trolleys, said Deborah. Jeremiah has a theory about the person in the book. I don t care.

It s history?

A woman writing about her early life. About her sister.

It sounds interesting, said Ruben politely.

Good. You read it.

Ruben took the book: Trolley Girl, by Miriam James.

You can t keep it, said Deborah; Ruben was embarrassed but they d meet again. The daughters were Jill, who talked, and Rose, a big baby. Jill collected sticks and demanded to throw them into the river, a narrow glinty stream visible through trees. So Deborah carried Rose on her hip, striding away from Ruben, down a wooded slope where the carriage couldn't follow. Ruben watched: the back of a muscular woman walking in sandals, her dress disheveled by a child on her hip, and an earnest child running carefully, turning every few feet--this way!--as if only she knew where to find the river. Ruben had never been in this park, though she d lived in the city for most of a year, busy being pregnant. Forever she would have to remind herself that Deborah hadn't made the river.

She pushed her glasses up her nose and started for home. How snug and well-outfitted she would be when the Squirrel could ride on her hip, leaning confidently against her arm one short leg in front and one behind her--pointing like Rose, who used her mother as a friendly conveyance. Now he was only a package. At the sidewalk she opened the book. Then came--terrible to think about--the broken place, and then, when she d just begun the book again, the street to cross, and a dog she looked at. But now.

The Book Borrower
A Novel
. Copyright © by Alice Mattison. Reprinted by permission of HarperCollins Publishers, Inc. All rights reserved. Available now wherever books are sold.
Read More Show Less

Reading Group Guide

Plot Summary
Toby Ruben and Deborah Laidlaw meet in 1975 in a New York City playground, where the two women are looking after their babies. Deborah lends Toby a book, Trolley Girl -- a memoir about a 1920s trolley strike and three Jewish sisters -- that will appear, disappear, and reappear throughout the years in which these women are friends. Toby and Deborah raise children in the seventies, arguing over Patty Hearst and the meaning of life. They find work teaching inner-city day-care workers, a job that leads to conflict between them. Meanwhile, Toby reads the opening chapters of Trolley Girl with interest, but puts the book aside when its story turns tragic. Jump ahead ten years and we find Toby and Deborah adjunct English instructors at a college. They are mothers of school-age children, stealing time to drink a beer, still deeply involved in their difficult friendship. The borrowed book has long since disappeared from Toby's consciousness. Another decade passes. One day during a hike, they have an argument that cannot be resolved-and the two women take different, permanent paths, one of which leads to a heartwrenching tragedy. In the midst of mourning and loss, it is ultimately the borrowed book that brings them back together. With sensitivity and grace, Alice Mattison shows how books can rescue us from our deepest sorrows; how the events of the outside world play into our private lives; and how the bonds between women are enduring, mysterious, and laced with surprise. Discussion Questions
  • When the two women meet, Deborah Laidlaw is depicted as a mainstream mother and wife with many friends and ties withinthe community. Yet she becomes best friends with Toby Ruben, a prickly and strange newcomer. Why do you think she chooses Toby? What qualities about Toby attracted Deborah?
  • The author always refers to the main character as "Ruben," the character's last name. But when others address her, they call her "Toby," her first name. Why do you think the author chose to refer to her this way? Did it affect your feelings toward Toby Ruben (i.e. make you feel more or less intimate with her?)
  • The saying goes: "With friends like these, who needs enemies?" Twice, Toby Ruben sabotages her best friend's employment by telling her bosses that she doesn't think Deborah is a good teacher. Why does Toby do this? Is it a breach of friendship? How do you think they continue to be friends after these episodes? Could you?
  • Toby Ruben is accused by her best friend Deborah of having a "kindness deficit." But ultimately she ends up taking care of a cantankerous old woman. Is Toby truly unkind?
  • Toby Ruben does not have a strong sense of sympathy for others. Why do you think the story of The Trolley Girl was painful for her to read?
  • The anarchist, rabble-rousing sculptor Berry Cooper/Gussie Lipnick jumps from the pages of the long-borrowed book The Trolley Girl into real life just at the time when Toby needs her most. Why do you think the troublesome Berry Cooper is an antidote to Deborah's death? Have you ever experienced a coincidence that changed your life?
  • After Deborah's death, the rumor surfaces that she had a lover who she was on her way to meet when her car crashed. Deborah had never told Toby about this. Do you think it was true? Why or why not?
  • Husbands and children are secondary characters in The Book Borrower-in fact, Deborah speaks of wanting to keep husbands out of their friendship. Why did Deborah loan Toby her husband's favorite book? What was the nature of Toby and Jeremiah's relationship?
    About the Author: Alice Mattison grew up in Brooklyn and studied at Queens College and Harvard. Her collection of intersecting stories, Men Giving Money, Women Yelling, was a New York Times Book Review Notable Book of the Year. She is also the author of Hilda and Pearl and Field of Stars, two collections of stories, Great Wits and The Flight of Andy Burns, and a collection of poems, Animals. She has been published in The New Yorker, Glimmer Train, Southern Humanities Review, North American Review, Boulevard, and the Threepenny Review. She resides in New Haven, Connecticut and teaches fiction in the Bennington Writing Seminars, a low-residency Master's program at Bennington College in Vermont. She is currently at work on her next novel as well as a new collection of short stories.
Read More Show Less

Customer Reviews

Average Rating 3
( 2 )
Rating Distribution

5 Star


4 Star


3 Star


2 Star


1 Star


Your Rating:

Your Name: Create a Pen Name or

Barnes & Review Rules

Our reader reviews allow you to share your comments on titles you liked, or didn't, with others. By submitting an online review, you are representing to Barnes & that all information contained in your review is original and accurate in all respects, and that the submission of such content by you and the posting of such content by Barnes & does not and will not violate the rights of any third party. Please follow the rules below to help ensure that your review can be posted.

Reviews by Our Customers Under the Age of 13

We highly value and respect everyone's opinion concerning the titles we offer. However, we cannot allow persons under the age of 13 to have accounts at or to post customer reviews. Please see our Terms of Use for more details.

What to exclude from your review:

Please do not write about reviews, commentary, or information posted on the product page. If you see any errors in the information on the product page, please send us an email.

Reviews should not contain any of the following:

  • - HTML tags, profanity, obscenities, vulgarities, or comments that defame anyone
  • - Time-sensitive information such as tour dates, signings, lectures, etc.
  • - Single-word reviews. Other people will read your review to discover why you liked or didn't like the title. Be descriptive.
  • - Comments focusing on the author or that may ruin the ending for others
  • - Phone numbers, addresses, URLs
  • - Pricing and availability information or alternative ordering information
  • - Advertisements or commercial solicitation


  • - By submitting a review, you grant to Barnes & and its sublicensees the royalty-free, perpetual, irrevocable right and license to use the review in accordance with the Barnes & Terms of Use.
  • - Barnes & reserves the right not to post any review -- particularly those that do not follow the terms and conditions of these Rules. Barnes & also reserves the right to remove any review at any time without notice.
  • - See Terms of Use for other conditions and disclaimers.
Search for Products You'd Like to Recommend

Recommend other products that relate to your review. Just search for them below and share!

Create a Pen Name

Your Pen Name is your unique identity on It will appear on the reviews you write and other website activities. Your Pen Name cannot be edited, changed or deleted once submitted.

Your Pen Name can be any combination of alphanumeric characters (plus - and _), and must be at least two characters long.

Continue Anonymously
Sort by: Showing all of 2 Customer Reviews
  • Posted August 2, 2010

    more from this reviewer

    I wish I hadn't wasted my time.

    As I read this book, my opinion changed many times. I found it hard to get into, mostly because it was terribly boring. The cover compares the author's description of women's frienships to Atwood, and I found this a terrible betrayal of Margaret Atwood. It follows the lifelong friendships of two women, punctuated mostly by ridiculous spats and dull interludes on a book about trolleys. The "twist" is painfully predictable and all of the characters are obnoxious or just so dull you don't care what happens to them. I don't recommend this book at all. Sometimes I regret that once I start a book I have a compulsion to finish it. I will never get the time back I spent trying to finish this book.

    Was this review helpful? Yes  No   Report this review
  • Anonymous

    Posted December 30, 2000

    Modest and Understated, Makes A Large Impact

    One year after reading The Book Borrower, it still stands out from the 50+ books a year that I go through. At the core is the difficult and dear friendship between two very different women raising their families in Boynton, Massachusetts from the 1970's through the early 1990's and the impact of an unusual woman of the early 1900's whose life is chronicled in a book called 'The Trolley Girl.' Be patient with the book and read it all the way through. Mattison has an unusual style and a way of telling a story that can be off-putting until you get used to it, but you will be rewarded. There is a purpose and a reason. The book and its meaning take awhile to permeate, which is surely a mark of good literature. It does come together in a way that is real, honest, and makes total sense. Mattison has a keen eye and ear as well as a compassion for the lives of ordinary people that elevates and deepens the meaning of own lives as well.

    Was this review helpful? Yes  No   Report this review
Sort by: Showing all of 2 Customer Reviews

If you find inappropriate content, please report it to Barnes & Noble
Why is this product inappropriate?
Comments (optional)