Both Ways Is the Only Way I Want It

( 33 )


Award-winning writer Maile Meloy's return to short stories explores complex lives in an austere landscape with the clear-sightedness that first endeared her to readers.

Meloy's first return to short stories since her critically acclaimed debut, Both Ways Is the Only Way I Want It is an extraordinary new work from one of the most promising writers of the last decade.

Eleven unforgettable new stories demonstrate the emotional power and the clean,...

See more details below
Other sellers (Hardcover)
  • All (69) from $1.99   
  • New (8) from $7.24   
  • Used (61) from $1.99   
Both Ways is the Only Way I Want It

Available on NOOK devices and apps  
  • NOOK Devices
  • Samsung Galaxy Tab 4 NOOK 7.0
  • Samsung Galaxy Tab 4 NOOK 10.1
  • NOOK HD Tablet
  • NOOK HD+ Tablet
  • NOOK eReaders
  • NOOK Color
  • NOOK Tablet
  • Tablet/Phone
  • NOOK for Windows 8 Tablet
  • NOOK for iOS
  • NOOK for Android
  • NOOK Kids for iPad
  • PC/Mac
  • NOOK for Windows 8
  • NOOK for PC
  • NOOK for Mac
  • NOOK for Web

Want a NOOK? Explore Now

NOOK Book (eBook)
$12.99 price


Award-winning writer Maile Meloy's return to short stories explores complex lives in an austere landscape with the clear-sightedness that first endeared her to readers.

Meloy's first return to short stories since her critically acclaimed debut, Both Ways Is the Only Way I Want It is an extraordinary new work from one of the most promising writers of the last decade.

Eleven unforgettable new stories demonstrate the emotional power and the clean, assured style that have earned Meloy praise from critics and devotion from readers. Propelled by a terrific instinct for storytelling, and concerned with the convolutions of modern love and the importance of place, this collection is about the battlefields-and fields of victory-that exist in seemingly harmless spaces, in kitchens and living rooms and cars. Set mostly in the American West, the stories feature small-town lawyers, ranchers, doctors, parents, and children, and explore the moral quandaries of love, family, and friendship. A ranch hand falls for a recent law school graduate who appears unexpectedly- and reluctantly-in his remote Montana town. A young father opens his door to find his dead grandmother standing on the front step. Two women weigh love and betrayal during an early snow. Throughout the book, Meloy examines the tensions between having and wanting, as her characters try to keep hold of opposing forces in their lives: innocence and experience, risk and stability, fidelity and desire.

Knowing, sly, and bittersweet, Both Ways Is the Only Way I Want It confirms Maile Meloy's singular literary talent. Her lean, controlled prose, full of insight and unexpected poignancy, is the perfect complement to her powerfully moving storytelling.

One of the New York Times Book Review's Top 10 Books of 2009

Read More Show Less

Editorial Reviews

From the Publisher
"Though it might seem strange to praise a writer for the things she doesn't do, what really sets Meloy apart is her restraint. She is impressively concise, disciplined in length and scope. And she's balanced in her approach to character, neither blinded by love for her creations, nor abusive toward them. . . . She's such a talented and unpredictable writer that I'm officially joining her fan club; whatever she writes next, I'll gladly read it."
-Curtis Sittenfeld, The New York Times Book Review

"After two well-received novels, Meloy returns to the short story, the form in which she made her notable debut and to which her lucid style is arrestingly well suited. Many of these stories are set in Meloy's native Montana, and all are about domestic distress-about love, mostly, and the trouble stirred up by its often inconvenient insistence. Several are poised in the limbo of adultery, in the time between act and confession. Always true to her wide-ranging though consistently introspective characters, Meloy convincingly depicts the inchoate emotion that drives people, while also distilling meaning from it."
-The Atlantic

"If life is all about choices, as the saying goes, then what happens when we simply can't make up our minds about what's most important? In her second volume of short stories, Both Ways Is the Only Way I Want It acclaimed; novelist Maile Meloy (Liars and Saints, A Family Daughter), who first stunned critics in 2002 with her debut story collection, Half in Love, cracks at our nagging desire to have it all (the answers, the romance, the payout, and, in one case, the late grandmother come back to life) in 11 tightly written, remarkably fluid narratives, most of which unfold in sleepy towns across Meloy's native Montana."

Curtis Sittenfeld
Almost all her characters are flawed…They are people who act irrationally, against their own best interests—by betraying those they care about, making embarrassing romantic overtures and knowingly setting in motion situations they'd rather avoid—and Meloy's prose is so clear, calm and intelligent that their behavior becomes eminently understandable.
—The New York Times
Publishers Weekly

Meloy (Liars and Saints) hits some high notes in these stories of people juggling conflicting emotions with varying shades of success. In "The Children," a man's resolve to leave his wife for his now-grown children's former swimming instructor is unexpectedly "doomed to ambivalence and desire" when he's confronted by the comforting "habit of his marriage." Marital tensions are also at the heart of "O Tannenbaum," in which a couple, while hunting for a Christmas tree with their daughter, pick up a stranded couple whose bickering casts into relief the cracks in their own relationship. Other pieces focus on loneliness, as in the opening story about a young ranch hand's efforts to connect with a lawyer moonlighting as a night-school teacher, or as in "Agustín," where an elderly widower yearns for a lost, illicit lover. Meloy's characters frequently leave each other or let each other down, and it is precisely that-their vulnerabilities, failures and flaws-that make them so wonderful to follow as they vacillate between isolation and connection. (July)

Copyright © Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
Time Magazine
These 11 stories are quick, powerful jabs, startling in their economy; you're propelled toward each ending, cetain she won't be able to wrap it up in one more page, and you're proved wrong every time
—Mary Pols
Los Angeles Times
In the best short stories -- by Poe, Raymond Carver, Hemingway, Flannery O'Connor or Alice Munro -- there is always malaise, if not outright heartache, on the horizon. In less able hands this convention turns lugubrious and contrived. But Meloy's lean, targeted descriptions and her ultimately compassionate eye make this journey hurt so good.
—Samantha Dunn
Here, as in previous works like Half in Love, Meloy has a gift for portraying the tedium of waiting for things to happen in a place where they rarely do-and the shock that comes when something finally occurs. And if the mark of a good summer read is adultery and violence . . . well, it has that too.
—Sarah Goldstein
Precise and restrained, Meloy's diagnoses of a very American malignancy have an authentic moral force. So does her merciful treatment of the characters in its grip and of the victims of its spread. Young as she is (she's 37), she has a scope and maturity that at their most rigorous attain the grandeur of prophecy. We need to listen to our Cassandras when they're as wise as Meloy is. Nonetheless, it must be said-and this is a shameful thing to admit-that people who want it both ways are more interesting than the wreckage they leave in their wake.
—Judith Shulevitz
Library Journal

Readers drawn to the short story are sometimes disappointed upon reading a collection by a single author, even one they favor. The collection might seem padded, or the voice that struck us as original and engaging becomes boringly familiar halfway through. No such hazard awaits the readers of this new collection. The award-winning Meloy (Half in Love) continues to deliver stories that please and surprise as each narrative's small world unfolds. As one would expect from its cunning title, taken from a poem by A.R. Ammons, this collection features desire in its many, often contradictory elements, encounters that take a character by surprise but hardly make a ripple in anybody else's world. For example, the young Montana ranch hand in "Travis, B," finds himself smitten by the harried young teacher of an adult education class he happens upon just by following people into the classroom building. It's the act of entering the building that frees him, not the unlikely possibility of romance, and the reader comes to know him just as he begins to know himself. VERDICT Readers who have waited impatiently for Meloy's return to this genre, perhaps the one in which Meloy herself seems most at home, have a treat in store.—Sue Russell, Bryn Mawr, PA

—Sue Russell
Kirkus Reviews
Meloy (A Family Daughter, 2006, etc.) explores loneliness in 11 stories set mostly in her native Montana. "Travis, B." depicts a young cowboy, working away from his family and desperately lonely, attempting to woo an adult-ed teacher. His growth in self-awareness does not mitigate the heartbreak of his failure. "Lovely Rita" is another lost young adult; after her lover dies in a power-plant accident, she raffles herself off to raise money to find the father who abandoned her years before. While Travis and Rita are cut off from family, most of Meloy's characters are alone within their families. The adolescent protagonist of "Red from Green" loves her father but goes away to school; recognizing his inability to protect her, she chooses loneliness as a permanent state. In "Liliana," a Los Angeles man's supposedly dead grandmother shows up on his doorstep, alive and ready to reject him all over again. "Nine" is Valentina's age when her mother begins an affair with an Italian professor. It soon becomes clear that the affair is doomed, but Valentina mourns the loss of the man's ten-year-old son in her life. "Spy vs. Spy" shows a man and his brother dealing with long-simmering sibling rivalry. Despite their relative brevity, these are complex stories, often showing several characters being pulled in different directions. In what may be the volume's masterpiece, Leo meets with "The Girlfriend" of the man who raped and murdered Leo's daughter. In an anti-O'Henry twist, the loving father unearths a truth better left buried: that his own protectiveness may have caused his daughter's death. The author seldom allows a trickle of hope to lighten her characters' anguish, but she gives them aconsciousness and dignity that make their experiences deeply moving.
The Barnes & Noble Review
After two exceedingly good novels (Liars and Saints was shortlisted for the Orange Prize), Maile Meloy has returned with a full collection of the terse, emotionally compact short stories that she nails with precision and grace. This collection is loaded with daddy issues. Taken together, they create an interesting arc about the effect of a father's love or lack thereof on young girls: The daughter of a single father is unnerved when he can't protect her; a father confronts the girlfriend of his daughter's killer; two brothers, a ski bum and a bourgeois doctor, despise one another but compete over their fierce love for the doctor's teenage daughter, whom he regards as "the best thing [he] had ever done." Meanwhile, a wealthy Argentinian patriarch who discovers his former mistress is now working as maid, can look at his two indulged daughters and think that "children were experiments and his had failed." Many of these stories take place in Meloy's native Montana, with its big skies, vast spaces, and freakish summer snow. She is particularly deft when describing men of few words and compelling actions: In "Travis B.," a small-town ranch hand courts a big-city lawyer by showing up to take her to dinner on his horse. And in the exceptional "Lovely Rita," a young factory worker, confronted with death and a love he can't quite seem to grasp or even acknowledge, chooses to exile himself from his home as a way to distance himself from regret. Each one of these stories is a tiny, perfectly crafted masterpiece. --Amy Benfer
Read More Show Less

Product Details

  • ISBN-13: 9781594488696
  • Publisher: Penguin Publishing Group
  • Publication date: 7/9/2009
  • Pages: 240
  • Sales rank: 777,048
  • Product dimensions: 5.80 (w) x 8.30 (h) x 1.00 (d)

Meet the Author

Maile Meloy

Maile Meloy is the author of the story collection Half in Love, and the novels Liars and Saints, shortlisted for the 2005 Orange Prize, and A Family Daughter. Meloy’s stories have been published in The New Yorker, and she has received The Paris Review’s Aga Khan Prize for Fiction, the PEN/Malamud Award, the Rosenthal Foundation Award, and a Guggenheim Fellowship. In 2007, she was chosen as one of Granta’s Best American Novelists under 35. She lives in California.

Read More Show Less
    1. Hometown:
      Los Angeles, California
    1. Date of Birth:
    2. Place of Birth:
      Helena, Montana
    1. Education:
      M.F.A. in Fiction, University of California, Irvine, 2000

Read an Excerpt

Travis, B .

Chet Moran grew up in Logan, Montana, at a timewhen kids weren’t supposed to get polio anymore. InLogan, they still did, and he had it before he was two. He recovered,but his right hip never fit in the socket, and hismother always thought he would die young.

When he was fourteen, he started riding spoiled and un-brokehorses, to prove to her that he was invincible. Theybucked and kicked and piled up on him, again and again. Hedeveloped a theory that horses didn’t kick or shy becausethey were wild; they kicked and shied because for millionsof years they’d had the instinct to move fast or be lion meat.

“You mean because they’re wild,” his father had saidwhen Chet advanced this theory.

He couldn’t explain, but he thought his father was wrong.He thought there was a difference, and that what peoplemeant when they called a thing “wild” was not what he sawin the green horses at all.

He was small and wiry, but his hip made it hard for himto scramble out from under the horses, and he broke hisright kneecap, his right foot, and his left femur before he waseighteen. His father drove him to Great Falls, where thedoctors put a steel rod in his good leg from hip to knee.From then on, he walked as though he were turning to himselfto ask a question.

His size came from his mother, who was three-quartersCheyenne; his father was Irish and bullheaded. They hadvague dreams of improvement for their sons, but no ideasabout how to achieve them. His older brother joined thearmy. Watching him board an eastbound train, handsomeand straight-limbed in his uniform, Chet wondered whyGod or fate had so favored his brother. Why had the cardsbeen so unevenly dealt?

He left home at twenty and moved up north to the highline.He got a job outside Havre feeding cows through thewinter, while the rancher’s family lived in town and the kidswere in school. Whenever the roads were clear, he rode tothe nearest neighbors’ for a game of pinochle, but mostly hewas snowed in and alone. He had plenty of food, and goodTV reception. He had some girlie magazines that he got toknow better than he’d ever known an actual person. Hespent his twenty-first birthday wearing long johns undertwo flannel shirts and his winter coat, warming up soup onthe stove. He got afraid of himself that winter; he sensedsomething dangerous that would break free if he kept somuch alone.

In the spring, he got a job in Billings, in an office withfriendly secretaries and coffee breaks spent talking about rodeosand sports. They liked him there, and offered to sendhim to the main office in Chicago. He went home to hisrented room and walked around on his stiff hip, and guessedhe’d be stove up in a wheelchair in three years if he kept sittingaround an office. He quit the job and bucked bales allsummer, for hardly any money, and the pain went out of hiship, unless he stepped wrong.

That winter, he took another feeding job, outside Glendive,on the North Dakota border. He thought if he wenteast instead of north, there might not be so much snow. Helived in an insulated room built into the barn, with a TV, acouch, a hot plate, and an icebox, and he fed the cows witha team and sled. He bought some new magazines, in whichthe girls were strangers to him, and he watched Starsky andHutch and the local news. At night, he could hear the horsesmoving in their stalls. But he’d been wrong about the snow;by October it had already started. He made it throughChristmas, with packages and letters from his mother, but inJanuary he got afraid of himself again. The fear was not particular.It began as a buzzing feeling around his spine, a restlessnesswithout a specific aim.

The rancher had left him a truck, with a headbolt heateron an extension cord, and he warmed it up one night anddrove the snowy road into town. The café was open, but hewasn’t hungry. The gas pumps stood in an island of bluishlight, but the truck’s tank was full. He knew no pinochleplayers here, to help him pass the time. He turned off themain street to loop through town, and he drove by theschool. A light was on at a side door and people were leavingtheir cars in the lot and going inside. He slowed, parked onthe street, and watched them. He ran a hand around thesteering wheel and tugged at a loose thread on its wornleather grip. Finally he got out of the truck, turned his collarup against the cold, and followed the people inside.

One classroom had its lights on, and the people he hadfollowed were sitting in the too-small desks, saying hello asif they all knew each other. Construction-paper signs andpictures covered the walls, and the cursive alphabet ran alongthe top of the chalkboard. Most of the people were about hisparents’ age, though their faces were softer, and they dressedas though they lived in town, in thin shoes and clean brightjackets. He went to the back of the room and took a seat. Heleft his coat on, a big old sheepskin-lined denim, and hechecked his boots to see what he might have dragged in, butthey were clean from walking through snow.

“We should have gotten a high school room,” one of themen said.

A lady—a girl—stood at the teacher’s desk at the front ofthe room, taking papers from a briefcase. She had curly lightcoloredhair and wore a gray wool skirt and a blue sweater,and glasses with wire rims. She was thin, and looked tired andnervous. Everyone grew quiet and waited for her to speak.

“I’ve never done this before,” she said. “I’m not sure howto start. Do you want to introduce yourselves?”

“We all know each other,” a gray-haired woman said.

“Well, she doesn’t,” another woman protested.

“You could tell me what you know about school law,”the young teacher said.

The adults in the small desks looked at each other. “Idon’t think we know anything,” someone said.

“That’s why we’re here.”

The girl looked helpless for a second and then turned tothe chalkboard. Her bottom was a smooth curve in the woolskirt. She wrote “Adult Ed 302” and her name, Beth Travis,and the chalk squeaked on the h and the r. The men andwomen in the desks flinched.

“If you hold it straight up,” an older woman said, demonstratingwith a pencil, “with your thumb along the side, itwon’t do that.”

Beth Travis blushed, and changed her grip, and began totalk about state and federal law as it applied to the publicschool system. Chet found a pencil in his desk and held itlike the woman had said to hold the chalk. He wonderedwhy no one had ever showed him that in his school days.

The class took notes, and he sat in the back and listened.Beth Travis was a lawyer, it seemed. Chet’s father told jokesabout lawyers, but the lawyers were never girls. The class wasfull of teachers, who asked things he’d never thought of,about students’ rights and parents’ rights. He’d never imagineda student had any rights. His mother had grown up inthe mission school in St. Xavier, where the Indian kids werebeaten for not speaking English, or for no reason. He’d beenluckier. An English teacher had once struck him on the headwith a dictionary, and a math teacher had splintered a yardstickon his desk. But in general they had been no trouble.

Once, Beth Travis seemed about to ask him something,but one of the teachers raised a hand, and he was saved.

At nine o’clock the class was over, and the teachersthanked Miss Travis and said she’d done well. They talked toeach other about going someplace for a beer. He felt heshould stay and explain himself, so he stayed in his desk. Hiship was starting to stiffen from sitting so long.

Miss Travis packed up her briefcase and put on her puffyred coat, which made her look like a balloon. “Are you staying?”she asked.

“No, ma’am.” He levered himself out from behindthe desk.

“Are you registered for the class?”

“No, ma’am. I just saw people coming in.”

“Are you interested in school law?”

He thought about how to answer that. “I wasn’t beforetonight.”

She looked at her watch, which was thin and gold-colored.“Is there somewhere to get food?” she asked. “I haveto drive back to Missoula.”

The interstate ran straight across Montana, from the edgeof North Dakota, where they were, west through Billingsand Bozeman and past Logan, where he had grown up, overthe mountains to Missoula, near the Idaho border. “That’s anawful long drive,” he said.

She shook her head, not in disagreement but in amazement.“I took this job before I finished law school,” she said.“I wanted any job, I was so afraid of my loans coming due. Ididn’t know where Glendive was. It looks like Belgrade, theword does I mean, which is closer to Missoula—I must havegotten them confused. Then I got a real job, and they’re lettingme do this because they think it’s funny. But it took menine and a half hours to get here. And now I have to drivenine and a half hours back, and I have to work in the morning.I’ve never done anything so stupid in my life.”

“I can show you where the café is,” he said.

She looked like she was wondering whether to fear him,and then she nodded. “Okay,” she said.

In the parking lot, he was self-conscious about his gait,but she didn’t seem to notice. She got into a yellow Datsunand followed his truck to the café on the main drag. Heguessed she could have found it herself, but he wanted moretime with her. He went in and sat opposite her in a booth.She ordered coffee and a turkey sandwich and a browniesundae, and asked the waitress to bring it all at once. Hedidn’t want anything. The waitress left, and Beth Travis tookoff her glasses and set them on the table. She rubbed her eyesuntil they were red.

“Did you grow up here?” she asked. “Do you know thoseteachers?”

“No, ma’am.”

She put her glasses back on. “I’m only twenty-five,” shesaid. “Don’t call me that.”

He didn’t say anything. She was three years older than hewas. Her hair in the overhead light was the color of honey.She wasn’t wearing any rings.

“Did you tell me how you ended up in that class?” sheasked.

“I just saw people going in.”

She studied him and seemed to wonder again if sheshould be afraid. But the room was bright, and he tried tolook harmless. He was harmless, he was pretty sure. Beingwith someone helped—he didn’t feel so wound up andrestless.

“Did I make a fool of myself ?” she asked.


“Are you going to come back?”

“When’s it next?”

“Thursday,” she said. “Every Tuesday and Thursday fornine weeks. Oh, God.” She put her hands over her eyes again.“What have I done?”

He tried to think how he could help her. He had to staywith the cows, and driving to pick her up in Missoula didn’tmake any sense. It was so far away, and they’d just have todrive back again.

“I’m not signed up,” he finally said.

She shrugged. “They’re not going to check.”

Her food came, and she started on the sandwich.

“I don’t even know school law,” she said. “I’ll have tolearn enough to teach every time.” She wiped a spot of mustardfrom her chin. “Where do you work?”

“Out on the Hayden ranch, feeding cattle. It’s just a winterjob.”

“Do you want the other half of this sandwich?”

He shook his head, and she pushed the plate aside andtook a bite of the melting sundae.

“I’d show you if you could stay longer,” he said.

“Show me what?”

“The ranch,” he said. “The cows.”

“I have to get back,” she said. “I have to work in themorning.”

“Sure,” he said.

She checked her watch. “Jesus, it’s quarter to ten.” Shetook a few quick bites of sundae and finished her coffee. “Ihave to go.”

He watched as the low lights of the Datsun disappearedout of town, then he drove home in the other direction.Thursday was not very far from Tuesday, and it was almostWednesday now. He was suddenly starving, when sitting acrossfrom her he hadn’t been hungry. He wished he’d taken theother half of the sandwich, but he had been too shy.

Thursday night, he was at the school before anyoneelse, and he waited in the truck, watching. One ofthe teachers showed up with a key, unlocked the side door,and turned on the light. When more people had arrived,Chet went to his seat in the back of the classroom. BethTravis came in looking tired, took off her coat, and pulleda sheaf of paper from her briefcase. She was wearing agreen sweater with a turtleneck collar, jeans, and black snowboots. She walked around with the handouts and noddedto him. She looked good in jeans. “KEY SUPREME COURT DECISIONSAFFECTING SCHOOL LAW,” the handout said acrossthe top.

The class started, and hands went up to ask questions. Hesat in the back and watched, and tried to imagine his oldteachers here, but he couldn’t. A man not much older thanChet asked about salary increases, and Beth Travis said shewasn’t a labor organizer, but he should talk to the union. Theolder women in the class laughed and teased the man aboutrabble-rousing. At nine o’clock the class left for beers, andhe was alone again with Beth Travis.

“I have to lock up,” she said.

He had assumed, for forty-eight hours, that he would goto dinner with her, but now he didn’t know how to makethat happen. He had never asked any girl anywhere. Therehad been girls in high school who had felt sorry for him, buthe had been too shy or too proud to take advantage of it. Hestood there for an awkward moment.

“Are you going to the café?” he finally asked.

“For about five minutes,” she said.

In the café, she asked the waitress for the fastest thing onthe menu. The waitress brought her a bowl of soup withbread, coffee to go, and the check.

When the waitress left, she said, “I don’t even know yourname.”

“Chet Moran.”

She nodded, as if that were the right answer. “Do youknow anyone in town who could teach this class?”

“I don’t know anyone at all.”

“Can I ask what happened to your leg?”

He was surprised by the question, but he thought shecould ask him just about anything. He told her the simplestversion: the polio, the horses, the broken bones.

“And you still ride?”

He said that if he didn’t ride, he’d end up in a wheelchairor a loony bin or both.

She nodded, as if that were the right answer, too, andlooked out the window at the dark street. “I was so afraidI’d finish law school and be selling shoes,” she said. “I’msorry to keep talking about it. All I can think about is thatdrive.”

That weekend was the longest one he’d had. He fedthe cows and cleaned the tack for the team. He curriedthe horses until they gleamed and stamped, watchinghim, suspicious of what he intended.

Inside, he sat on the couch, flipped through the channels,and finally turned the TV off. He wondered how he mightcourt a girl who was older, and a lawyer, a girl who livedclear across the state and couldn’t think about anything butthat distance. He felt a strange sensation in his chest, but itwasn’t the restlessness he had felt before.

On Tuesday, he saddled one of the horses and rode it intotown, leaving the truck. There was a chinook wind, and thenight was warm, for January, and the sky clear. The plainsspread out dark and flat in every direction, except where thelights glowed from town. He watched the stars as he rode.

At the school, he tethered the horse to the bike rack, outof sight of the side door and the lot where the teacherswould park. He took the fat plastic bag of oats from hisjacket pocket and held it open. The horse sniffed at it, thenworked the oats out of the bag with his lips.

“That’s all I got,” he said, shoving the empty plastic bagback in his pocket.

The horse lifted its head to sniff at the strange townsmells.

“Don’t get yourself stolen,” Chet said.

When half the teachers had arrived, he went in and tookhis seat. Everyone sat in the same seat as they had the weekbefore. They talked about the chinook and whether it wouldmelt the snow. Finally Beth Travis came in, with her puffycoat and her briefcase. He was even happier to see her thanhe had expected, and she was wearing jeans again, whichwas good. He’d been afraid she might wear the narrow woolskirt. She looked harassed and unhappy to be there. Theteachers chattered on.

When the class was over and the teachers had cleared out,he asked, “Can I give you a ride to the café?”

“Oh—” she said, and she looked away.

“Not in the truck,” he said quickly, and he wonderedwhy a truck might seem more dangerous to a woman. Heguessed because it was like a room. “Come outside,” hesaid.

She waited in the parking lot while he untied the horseand mounted up. He rode it around from the bike rack—aware that he could seem like a fool, but elated with thefeeling of sitting a horse as well as anyone did—to whereBeth Travis stood hugging her briefcase.

“Oh, my God,” she said.

“Don’t think about it,” he said. “Give me your briefcase.Now give me your hand. Left foot in the stirrup. Now swingthe other leg over.” She did it, awkwardly, and he pulled herup behind him. He held her briefcase against the pommel,and she held tightly to his jacket, her legs against his. Hecouldn’t think of anything except how warm she was, pressedagainst the base of his spine. He rode the back way, throughthe dark streets, before cutting out toward the main drag andstopping short of it, behind the café. He helped her down,swung to the ground after her, gave her the briefcase, andtied the horse. She looked at him and laughed, and he realizedhe hadn’t seen her laugh before. Her eyebrows went upand her eyes got wide, instead of crinkling up like mostpeople’s did. She looked amazed.

In the café, the waitress slid a burger and fries in front ofBeth Travis and said, “The cook wants to know if that’s yourhorse out back.”

Chet said it was.

“Can he give it some water?”

He said he’d appreciate it.

“Truck break down?” the waitress asked.

He said no, his truck was all right, and the waitress wentaway.

Beth Travis turned the long end of the oval plate in hisdirection, and took up the burger. “Have some fries,” shesaid. “How come you never eat anything?”

He wanted to say that he wasn’t hungry when he wasaround her, but he feared the look on her face if he said it,the way she would shy away.

“Why were you afraid of selling shoes?” he asked.

“Have you ever sold shoes? It’s hell.”

“I mean, why were you afraid you couldn’t get anythingelse?”

She looked at the burger as if the answer was in there.Her eyes were almost the same color as her hair, and ringedwith pale lashes. He wondered if she thought of him as anIndian boy, with his mother’s dark hair. “I don’t know,” shesaid. “Yes, I do know. Because my mother works in a schoolcafeteria, and my sister works in a hospital laundry, and sellingshoes is the nicest job a girl from my family is supposedto get.”

“What about your father?”

“I don’t know him.”

“That’s a sad story.”

“No, it’s not,” she said. “It’s a happy story. I’m a lawyer,see, with a wonderful job driving to fucking Glendive everyfifteen minutes until I lose my mind.” She put down theburger and pressed the backs of her hands into her eyes. Herfingers were greasy and one had ketchup on it. She took herhands away from her face and looked at her watch. “It’s teno’clock,” she said. “I won’t get home before seven-thirty inthe morning. There are deer on the road, and there’s blackice outside of Three Forks along the river. If I make it pastthere, I get to take a shower and go to work at eight, and doall the crap no one else wants to do. Then learn more schoollaw tomorrow night, then leave work the next day beforelunch and drive back here with my eyes twitching. It’s betterthan a hospital laundry, maybe, but it’s not a whole fuckinglot better.”

“I’m from near Three Forks,” he said.

“So you know the ice.”

He nodded.

She dipped her napkin in her water glass and washedoff her fingers, then finished her coffee. “It was nice ofyou, to bring the horse,” she said. “Will you take me back tomy car?”

Outside, he swung her up onto the horse again, and sheput her arms around his waist. She seemed to fit to his bodylike a puzzle piece. He rode slowly back to the school parkinglot, not wanting to let her go. Next to the yellow Datsun,he held her hand tight while she climbed down, and then hedismounted, too. She tugged her puffy coat where it hadridden up from sliding off the horse, and they stood lookingat each other.

“Thank you,” she said.

He nodded. He wanted to kiss her but couldn’t see anyclear path to that happening. He wished he had practiced,with the high school girls or the friendly secretaries, just tobe ready for this moment.

She started to say something, but in his nervousness hecut her off. “See you Thursday,” he said.

She paused before nodding, and he took this for encouragement.He caught up her hand again and kissed it, becausehe had wanted to do that, and it was soft and cold. Then heleaned over and kissed her cheek, because he had wanted todo that, too. She didn’t move, not an inch, and he was aboutto kiss her for real when she seemed to snap out of a trance,and stepped away from him. She took her hand back. “I haveto go,” she said, and she went around to the driver’s side ofthe Datsun.

He held the horse while she drove out of the parking lot,and he kicked at the snow. The horse sidestepped away. Hefelt like jumping up and down, in excitement and anxietyand anguish. He had run her off. He shouldn’t have kissedher. He should have kissed her more. He should have let hersay what she wanted to say. He mounted up and rodehome.

Thursday night he drove the truck in, no cowboyantics; he was on a serious mission. He was going toanswer her questions honestly, such as the one about why hedidn’t eat. He was going to let her say the things she intendedto say. He didn’t wait for the crowd to arrive beforegoing into the classroom; he went in early and took his seatin the back. The class filled up, and then a tall man in a graysuit with a bowling-ball gut came in and stood behind theteacher’s desk.

“Miss Travis,” he said, “found the drive from Missoula tooarduous, so I will take over the class for the rest of the term.I practice law here in town. As some of you know, andthe rest of you would find out soon enough, I’m recentlydivorced and have some time on my hands. That’s why I’mhere.”

While the man talked on, Chet got up from his seat andmade his way up the aisle to the door. Outside he stoodbreathing the cold air into his lungs. He let the lights oftown swim in his eyes until he blinked them clear again andclimbed into the rancher’s truck. He gave it enough gas sothe engine wouldn’t quit, and it coughed and steadied itselfand ran.

He knew Beth Travis lived in Missoula, six hundred mileswest, over the mountains, but he didn’t know where. Hedidn’t know where she worked, or if she was listed in thephone book. He didn’t know if it was he who had scared heroff or the drive. He didn’t know if the truck would make itall that way, or what the rancher would do when he foundout he’d gone.

But he put the truck in gear and pulled out of town inthe direction he had three times watched the yellow Datsungo. The road was flat and straight and seemed to roll underneaththe truck, dark and silent, through a dark and silentexpanse of snow-covered land. He stopped outside of MilesCity, and again outside of Billings, to hobble around on hisstiffened-up leg until he could drive again. Near Big Timber,the plains ended and the mountains began, black shapes risingup against the stars. He stopped in Bozeman for coffeeand gas, and drove the white line on the empty road pastThree Forks and Logan, to stay out of the ice that spreadfrom the shoulder in black sheets. Somewhere off to hisright in the dark, his parents were sleeping.

It was still dark when he reached Missoula, and he stoppedat a gas station and looked up “Travis” in the phone book.There was a “Travis, B.” with a phone number, but no address.He wrote down the number, but didn’t call it. He asked thekid at the cash register where the law offices were in town,and the kid shrugged and said, “Maybe downtown.”

“Where’s that?”

The kid stared at him. “It’s downtown,” he said, and hepointed off to his left.

Downtown, Chet found himself in dawn light amongshops and old brick buildings and one-way streets. He parkedand got out to stretch his hip. The mountains were so closethey made him feel claustrophobic. When he found a carvedwooden sign saying “Attorneys at Law,” he asked the secretarywho came to open the office if she knew a lawyernamed Beth Travis.

The secretary looked at his twisted leg, his boots, and hiscoat and shook her head.

In the next law office, the secretary was friendlier. Shecalled the law school and asked where Beth Travis had goneto work, then cupped her hand over the receiver. “She tooka teaching job in Glendive.”

“She has another job, too. Here.”

The secretary relayed this information on the phone, thenwrote something down on a piece of paper and handed itto him.

“Down by the old railroad depot,” she said, pointingtoward the window with her pencil.

He pulled up at the address on the piece of paper ateight-thirty, just as Beth Travis’s yellow Datsun pulled intothe same parking lot. He got out of the truck, feeling jittery.She was rummaging in her briefcase and didn’t see him rightaway. Then she looked up. She looked at the truck behindhim, then back at him again.

“I drove over,” he said.

“I thought I was in the wrong place,” she said. She let thebriefcase hang at her side. “What are you doing here?”

“I came to see you.”

She nodded, slowly. He stood as straight as he could. Shelived in another world from him. You could fly to Hawaii orFrance in less time than it took to do that drive. Her worldhad lawyers, downtowns, and mountains in it. His world hadhorses that woke hungry, and cows waiting in the snow, andit was going to be ten hours before he could get back to getthem fed.

“I was sorry you stopped teaching the class,” he said. “Ilooked forward to it, those nights.”

“It wasn’t because—” she said. “I meant to tell you onTuesday. I’d already asked for a replacement, because of thedrive. They found one yesterday.”

“Okay,” he said. “That drive is pretty bad.”

“You see?”

A man in a dark suit got out of a silver car and lookedover at them, sizing Chet up. Beth Travis waved and smiled.The man nodded, looked at Chet again, and went into thebuilding; the door closed. Chet suddenly wished that she hadquit teaching the class because of him, that he’d had any effecton her at all. He shifted his weight. She pushed her hairback and he thought he could step forward and touch herhand, touch the back of her neck where the hair grew darker.Instead he shoved his hands into his jeans pockets. Sheseemed to scan the parking lot before looking at him again.

“I don’t mean any harm,” he said.


“I have to go feed now,” he said. “I just knew that if Ididn’t start driving, I wasn’t going to see you again, and Ididn’t want that. That’s all.”

She nodded. He stood there waiting, thinking she mightsay something, meet him halfway. He wanted to hear hervoice again. He wanted to touch her, any part of her, just herarms maybe, just her waist. She stood out of reach, waitingfor him to go.

Finally he climbed up into the truck and started the engine.She was still watching him from the parking lot as hedrove away, and he got on the freeway and left town. For thefirst half hour he gripped the steering wheel so hard hisknuckles turned white, and glared at the road as the truckswallowed it up. Then he was too tired to be angry, and hiseyes started to close and jerk open. He nearly drove offthe road. In Butte he bought a cup of black coffee, and drankit standing next to the truck. He wished he hadn’t seen herright away, in the parking lot. He wished he’d had a minuteto prepare. He crushed the paper coffee cup and threw itaway.

As he drove past Logan, he thought about stopping, buthe didn’t need to. He knew what his parents would say. Hismother would worry about his health, driving all night, hersickly son, risking his life. “You don’t even know this whitegirl,” she’d say. His father would say, “Jesus, Chet, you left thehorses without water all day?”

Back at the Hayden place, he fed and watered the horses,and they seemed all right. None of them had kicked throughtheir stalls. He rigged them up in the harness, and loaded thesled with hay, and they dragged it out of the barn. He cut theorange twine on each bale with a knife and pitched the hayoff the sled for the cows. The horses trudged uncomplainingly,and he thought about the skittery two-year-olds who’dkicked him every where there was to kick, when he wasfourteen. The ache in his stomach felt like that. But he hadn’tbeen treated unfairly by Beth Travis; he didn’t know what hehad expected. If she had asked him to stay, he would havehad to leave anyway. It was the finality of the conversation,and the protective look the man in the dark suit had givenher, that left him feeling sore and bruised.

In the barn, he talked to the horses, and kept close totheir hind legs when he moved behind them. They weresensible horses, immune to surprise, but he had left themwithout water all day. He gave them each another coffeecanful of grain, which slid yellow over itself into theirbuckets.

He walked back outside, into the dark, and looked outover the flat stretch of land beyond the fences. The moonwas up, and the fields were shadowy blue, dotted with cows.His hip was stiff and sore. He had to pee, and he walked awayfrom the barn and watched the small steaming crater formin the snow. He wondered if maybe he had planted a seed,with Beth Travis, by demonstrating his seriousness to her.She wouldn’t come back—it was impossible to imagine herdoing that drive again, for any reason. But she knew wherehe was. She was a lawyer. She could find him if she wanted.

But she wouldn’t. That was the thing that made him ache.He buttoned his jeans and shifted his hip. He had wantedpractice, with girls, and now he had gotten it, but he wishedit had felt more like practice. It was getting colder, and hewould have to go inside soon. He fished her phone numberout of his pocket and studied it a while in the moonlight,until he knew it by heart, and wouldn’t forget it. Then hedid what he knew he should do, and rolled it into a ball, andthrew it away.

Read More Show Less

Interviews & Essays

A Message from the Author
Both Ways Is the Only Way I Want It is a story collection, as was my first book, Half in Love. Lately people have been asking me about how you decide which stories to include in a collection, and what order they go in, which was (and still is) a big question of mine.

When I was writing the stories that became Half in Love, I read great collections to see how it was done: Philip Roth's Goodbye, Columbus; J. D. Salinger's Nine Stories; Merce Rodereda's My Christina; D. H. Lawrence's England, My England; Hemingway's In Our Time. I wanted to know how the arrangement of eight or ten or twelve stories could create a complete experience that the reader could move through, when the stories weren't linked in any way except for the fact that one writer wrote them, but it was hard to see how I could transfer that information to my own book.

I was taking a class from Ann Patchett then, and she said, about the number of stories in a collection, that Salinger's Nine was like eight hours' sleep -- a little more was okay, a little less was fine, but it was a good general guideline. About variety, she said that a collection was like a mall: it needed a few big stories with broad horizons, like the big anchor stores, to make a space in which the smaller, quirkier stories could survive.

That made sense, so in putting Half in Love together I took some stories out, and left others in, and set aside two linked ones to start a novel with. I made lists of the titles, and annotated them with codes about what was in each story, some of which were so obscure I can't decipher them now. (One was "adbhj." I have no idea what that means.) The easily breakable codes indicated that the story was in first person, or third, or second, and whether the protagonist was male or female, and where the story was set. Then I cut the lists apart and moved the titles around on the kitchen table. I spent a long time trying to keep the first-person stories away from each other, before realizing that I didn't need to, that it wasn't difficult to move from one first-person narrator to another. We're used to hearing different voices telling us things about their lives, and I ended up having four in a row.

I did the same thing for Both Ways Is the Only Way I Want It, with the annotated titles on cut-up pieces of sticky note, so they would stay in place -- an improvement on the method. Otherwise, the arranging hadn't gotten any easier. I knew which title went first, and had a sense about which one might go last, but I moved the middle around for days, trying different sequences.

I got out Salinger's Nine again, because it struck me as the Platonic ideal of a story collection, and I thought about it as a template, wondering which story was my "DeDaumier Smith's Blue Period," and which was my "Teddy." But that came to seem futile and silly, and I went back to thinking about my own stories.

I put a story set in Connecticut third, after two Montana stories, so it was clear that the collection was going to go to other places. And there were two stories that made sense near each other, but needed to be separated, like quarreling siblings. The story about a man whose daughter has been murdered couldn't go early. It had to go somewhere in the middle, at a point when the reader was already in the book. And it seemed good to have a lighter story after it, about a grandmother who comes back from the dead.

Sometimes the arranging felt like lining up the batting order for a baseball game: which story leads off? And sometimes it felt like seating people at a dinner party: boy-girl-boy-girl if possible, and certain stories shouldn't go next to each other, and try to encourage interesting conversation. And sometimes it felt like making a mix tape for someone you love. But mostly it felt like a puzzle with a discoverable solution, and moving the pieces around was part of the pleasure. --Maile Meloy
Read More Show Less

Customer Reviews

Average Rating 3.5
( 33 )
Rating Distribution

5 Star


4 Star


3 Star


2 Star


1 Star


Your Rating:

Your Name: Create a Pen Name or

Barnes & Review Rules

Our reader reviews allow you to share your comments on titles you liked, or didn't, with others. By submitting an online review, you are representing to Barnes & that all information contained in your review is original and accurate in all respects, and that the submission of such content by you and the posting of such content by Barnes & does not and will not violate the rights of any third party. Please follow the rules below to help ensure that your review can be posted.

Reviews by Our Customers Under the Age of 13

We highly value and respect everyone's opinion concerning the titles we offer. However, we cannot allow persons under the age of 13 to have accounts at or to post customer reviews. Please see our Terms of Use for more details.

What to exclude from your review:

Please do not write about reviews, commentary, or information posted on the product page. If you see any errors in the information on the product page, please send us an email.

Reviews should not contain any of the following:

  • - HTML tags, profanity, obscenities, vulgarities, or comments that defame anyone
  • - Time-sensitive information such as tour dates, signings, lectures, etc.
  • - Single-word reviews. Other people will read your review to discover why you liked or didn't like the title. Be descriptive.
  • - Comments focusing on the author or that may ruin the ending for others
  • - Phone numbers, addresses, URLs
  • - Pricing and availability information or alternative ordering information
  • - Advertisements or commercial solicitation


  • - By submitting a review, you grant to Barnes & and its sublicensees the royalty-free, perpetual, irrevocable right and license to use the review in accordance with the Barnes & Terms of Use.
  • - Barnes & reserves the right not to post any review -- particularly those that do not follow the terms and conditions of these Rules. Barnes & also reserves the right to remove any review at any time without notice.
  • - See Terms of Use for other conditions and disclaimers.
Search for Products You'd Like to Recommend

Recommend other products that relate to your review. Just search for them below and share!

Create a Pen Name

Your Pen Name is your unique identity on It will appear on the reviews you write and other website activities. Your Pen Name cannot be edited, changed or deleted once submitted.

Your Pen Name can be any combination of alphanumeric characters (plus - and _), and must be at least two characters long.

Continue Anonymously
See All Sort by: Showing 1 – 20 of 33 Customer Reviews
  • Posted August 20, 2009

    more from this reviewer

    I Also Recommend:

    Isn't that they way it always goes?

    As an avid reader of short story collections, I plowed through this book in too short a time. I was saddened when I realized I had reached the final story. Much like Maile Meloy's characters, I longed for something I knew was unattainable, yet against my better judgment put off completion to draw out the experience. Focusing on intimate familial and romantic relationships, both real and imagined, Meloy masters the art of creating characters both despicable and relatable. We are all fallible and Meloy points this out in the most gut-wrenching ways. I found during some of the stories, my emotional reaction was followed by an equally surprising physical reaction. I hesitate to recommend this book to every reader, as it points to all the poor choices made for us and by us which we are capable of, but I cannot stop myself from recommending it given the exceptional writing and Meloy's ability to deftly show an interior life and the outside world with equal insight and delicacy.

    8 out of 8 people found this review helpful.

    Was this review helpful? Yes  No   Report this review
  • Posted February 27, 2012

    Great short story collection!

    I like to keep a short story collection on my Nook for times when I just have a few minutes to read. I ended up ignoring the other books I was reading until I finished this. I loved the characters in these stories and the choices they had to make.

    2 out of 2 people found this review helpful.

    Was this review helpful? Yes  No   Report this review
  • Posted November 29, 2010

    These short stories work nicely in the audio format.

    Both Ways Is the Only Way I Want It is a collection of short stories mostly featuring men and women living in the fringes of the American West. They inhabit those small, western towns were people still have one foot in older, more simple ways and one foot edging into the fast-paced, more technological world. The stories are written in a plain, honest language that feels natural for the setting and characters.

    In general I'm not a big fan of short stories. They either draw me in and then leave me wanting more or they fail to capture my attention. Maile Meloy did a good job of making me feel immediately connected to the characters and also of creating a clear beginning and an end in her stories. I enjoyed the feeling of getting a brief glimpse into some of the most intimate moments of these ordinary lives. Books written with the flavor of life in the West are always a particular favorite of mine and she invokes the landscape and people with a tenderness and truthfulness that really drew me in. I did wish for a little more hope and happiness for her characters, but that's me always wanting a happy ending.

    I listened to the audio version of Both Ways Is the Only Way I Want It. It is read by Kirsten Potter and Bronson Pinchot. They do a fine job of narrating the stories, using unembellished, plain-spoken voices and intonations as suits the people they are narrating. The short stories work nicely in the audio format.

    2 out of 4 people found this review helpful.

    Was this review helpful? Yes  No   Report this review
  • Anonymous

    Posted March 28, 2010

    do not waste your time or money

    I thought this book was horrible. I felt like I was reading a book written by elementary school students. I can not believe I actually paid for this, which is the only reason I finished it in the first place.

    1 out of 7 people found this review helpful.

    Was this review helpful? Yes  No   Report this review
  • Anonymous

    Posted January 28, 2010

    No text was provided for this review.

  • Anonymous

    Posted May 3, 2011

    No text was provided for this review.

  • Anonymous

    Posted January 21, 2010

    No text was provided for this review.

  • Anonymous

    Posted January 29, 2010

    No text was provided for this review.

  • Anonymous

    Posted July 27, 2010

    No text was provided for this review.

  • Anonymous

    Posted January 17, 2010

    No text was provided for this review.

  • Anonymous

    Posted September 4, 2010

    No text was provided for this review.

  • Anonymous

    Posted February 3, 2010

    No text was provided for this review.

  • Anonymous

    Posted December 1, 2010

    No text was provided for this review.

  • Anonymous

    Posted June 27, 2010

    No text was provided for this review.

  • Anonymous

    Posted August 12, 2010

    No text was provided for this review.

  • Anonymous

    Posted December 3, 2009

    No text was provided for this review.

  • Anonymous

    Posted January 27, 2010

    No text was provided for this review.

  • Anonymous

    Posted August 17, 2011

    No text was provided for this review.

  • Anonymous

    Posted December 30, 2010

    No text was provided for this review.

  • Anonymous

    Posted December 21, 2009

    No text was provided for this review.

See All Sort by: Showing 1 – 20 of 33 Customer Reviews

If you find inappropriate content, please report it to Barnes & Noble
Why is this product inappropriate?
Comments (optional)