Well, it's sad.
Just a couple of years ago, before Twilight became a phenomenon, I read the first book just to get some free ice cream at my middle school. I remember finishing the book and not thinking much about it; sure, it was very emotional, but not wonderful. Then, some of my friends became obsessed and I decided to continue reading the series as the books came out, curious to see why it was so great.
Well, it didn't improve. A few points that had disturbed me in Twilight were even more apparent in New Moon and Eclipse: Bella didn't grow as a character (and I had hoped to see her learn that love isn't all-consuming, but she didn't learn), Edward wasn't fleshed out (honestly, I don't want to read about being in love with Michelangelo's David; I like to read about romances involving two people with personalities, not two cardboard cutouts in love with each other based on looks), and the plot was terrible. The supporting characters got little attention (Jasper, Alice, Rosalie, Emmett, Jacob, etc) and they had the most potential. Jacob, perhaps the most fleshed out secondary character, seemed to be hated by Meyer.
Which leads me to Breaking Dawn, which brought the Twilight series crashing down from rather cliched pulp novels with potential to a irredeemable mess. The characters, already cookie-cutter, were slammed and most of the time, shelved for the main characters to angst and moan (Alice, Rosalie, Emmett, Jasper, Carlisle, etc etc. were not mentioned as often as before; Alice was gone because of a headache??? What? Also, Jacob was handed off to a baby so that the love triangle wouldn't be an issue anymore. Talk about throwing out a character.) This should have made room for Edward and Bella to grow, but Edward was actually diminished and any growth Bella had was actually counterproductive: she became all too perfect and boring to read about. There was no epic fight at the end because the author couldn't bear killing her own characters (it's called a STORY; they're not REAL. If it helps the story, you SHOULD kill them).
Meyer also pushes her beliefs about premarital sex, abortion, education, and sexism onto the reader: don't have sex before you're married, do not, even if the mother is in danger, abort the baby, a woman's education isn't all that important, and the man usually dominates the relationship (this was pushed more in the first three books than the last). While I'm fine with her having set beliefs on abortion, she shouldn't promote in a book that she knows will be read by millions of pre-teens and teenagers. I appreciate her stance on sex, but she claims to NOT be promoting any message, and I'm angered by her characters' casual derision of education (yes, she has the rest of eternity to get an education, but to just throw it out the window temporarily for a dream honeymoon and marriage is ridiculous; it sends a dangerous message to kids.)
Twilight was decent, although highly emotionally charged (as the entire series was), and there were some characters who had some real potential, but they were given up for the sake of expanding the lust between Edward and Bella (after four books, I'm still not sure what they see in each other, other than tasty blood and a beautiful body). I would share this with friends, if only for the laughs. It was unforgettable in a bad way; my generation is enthralled by THIS series? No wonder parents despair.
8 out of 14 people found this review helpful.
Was this review helpful? Yes NoThank you for your feedback.
Report this reviewThank you, this review has been flagged.