By a Slow River

By a Slow River

3.9 10
by Philippe Claudel

View All Available Formats & Editions

A bestseller in France and winner of the Prix Renaudot, By a Slow River is a mesmerizing and atmospheric tale of three mysterious deaths in an oddly isolated French village during World War I.The placid daily life of a small town near the front seems impervious to the nearby pounding of artillery fire and the parade of wounded strangers passing through its


A bestseller in France and winner of the Prix Renaudot, By a Slow River is a mesmerizing and atmospheric tale of three mysterious deaths in an oddly isolated French village during World War I.The placid daily life of a small town near the front seems impervious to the nearby pounding of artillery fire and the parade of wounded strangers passing through its streets. But the illusion of calm is soon shattered by the deaths of three innocents–the charming new schoolmistress who captures every male heart only to kill herself; an angelic ten-year-old girl who is found strangled; and a local policeman’s cherished wife, who dies alone in labor while her husband is hunting the murderer. Twenty years later, the policeman still struggles to make sense of these tragedies, a struggle that both torments and sustains him. But excavating the town's secret history will bring neither peace to him nor justice to the wicked.

Editorial Reviews
Barnes & Noble Discover Great New Writers
"We kill a lot in the course of a day, in thoughts and in words, without fully realizing it. In light of all these abstract crimes, actual murders are pretty rare when you consider it. In fact, it's only in wars that our actions keep up with our impulses."

In this masterfully seamless translation, Claudel's dark and mysterious novel, narrated by a retired French gendarme, builds to a devastating conclusion. The setting is World War I, in eastern France, where the frozen body of a young girl is hauled from an icy river one December morning. She has been strangled, and a military deserter is apprehended. But is he the murderer?

Twenty years later, our narrator, grief-stricken in the wake of his wife's death in childbirth, is still obsessed with this crime, and with the suicide of a young schoolteacher who seemingly had everything to live for. Returning to the scene of the crime, he releases memories and untold regret, as ghosts surface from the murky past, causing him to consider man's inhumanity to man, and his own tendency to rush to judgment without considering his own guilt.

Claudel's novel is disturbing, and its melancholy hangs suspended over the story like a shroud. "It's surprising how you can know things without having ever learned them," he writes. This page-turning mystery will keep readers guessing until the very last page. (Fall 2006 Selection)
Richard Eder
In this grave, achingly beautiful novel by Philippe Claudel (gravely and beautifully translated from French by Hoyt Rogers), a village policeman writes out his sorrow-laden journal of the plague years. Their miasma envelops individuals' evils, decencies and mutual distances, and the deaths of four innocents.
— The New York Times
Publishers Weekly
Nimbly translated, French former screenwriter Claudel's little gem of a debut novel is, in essence, a whodunit. On a frigid morning in December 1917, the body of a 10-year-old girl is discovered, strangled, on the banks of the "slow" river that slices through a small, unnamed French village. The townsfolk are stunned by the murder, though they're curiously oblivious to the seemingly endless slaughter taking place on the nearby Western front. Told by Dadais, a former policeman with a sharp memory and (it gradually becomes apparent) a shadowy history of his own, the story is a re-creation of his dogged pursuit of the killer. Was it the town's haughty prosecutor, Pierre-Ange Destinat? Was it the Breton deserter who confesses under duress? Could it possibly have been Dadais himself? The answer, like everything else in the story, is far from tidy-aside from its construction, that is. Psychologically complex, elegantly written and tightly plotted, this is far from your average policier. (June 15) Copyright 2006 Reed Business Information.
KLIATT - Nola Theiss
In a small French town during WW I, the characters who live along a slow river also live within the shadow of battles taking place right over the hill that shields them from the war. Yet the war, in the form of wounded soldiers and deserters passing through, and the sound of gunfire, fills their lives. The story is told in the voice of a police officer who must deal with three townspeople's deaths, including his own wife's. One woman, the young beautiful schoolteacher, is found dead by suicide as she grieves over the loss of her lover to the war; a young girl is found murdered by the river; and the police officer's wife dies as a result of hemorrhaging during childbirth while he was out investigating the child's murder. As typical of small towns, the characters are all connected and as the story unfolds, it becomes clear that the deaths are also connected. No one is completely innocent and some of the characters are guiltier than the reader thinks. There are surprising twists to the story's end that makes the distinction between guilt and innocence as foggy as the atmosphere that pervades the story. Reviewer: Nola Theiss
Library Journal
On a bleak winter morning in 1917, a ten-year-old girl is found strangled near a riverbank in rural France. Mere miles away teenage soldiers die on the battlefields of the First World War. The extent to which these events are related is the subject of one elderly policeman's memoirs, which encompass not only "The Case," as it has come to be known, but the thicket of lies and secrets that underpins everyday life in the narrator's village. Evidence points to Pierre-Ange Destinat, the town prosecutor, but could such an upright man truly be a killer? Originally published as Les Ames Grises, the novel earned Claudel the 2003 Prix Renaudot. In this lyrical yet earthy translation, it's easy to see why: tales of murder, torture, and suicide unfold gradually, like the petals of a poisonous flower, delivering staggering plot twists up to the final page. The novel's true genius, however, lies in its ability to explore war's effects on civilians without resorting to clich s or excessive gore. Recommended for libraries where world literature is in demand.-Leigh Anne Vrabel, Carnegie Lib. of Pittsburgh Copyright 2006 Reed Business Information.
Kirkus Reviews
Untimely death and existential angst in a small French village. The narrator is a retired policeman. The main characters include a prosecutor and a judge. And there's a dead girl, her small body marred by signs of strangulation. At this point, though, all similarities between this novel-the winner of last year's Prix Renaudot-and the typical murder mystery cease. First, there is the matter of pacing. The title refers to the listless waterway that winds alongside the town of V, in the French countryside, but it also seems to describe this meandering narrative. The central story concerns the unnamed policeman's long obsession with the case of a murdered girl, but the digressions are many and prolonged. The narrator pauses to recount the fate of the town whore, for example, and to offer a secondhand account of a dinner at the prosecutor's house. He is also something of a philosopher. While some of his dictums are eloquent-"Brutally, death spirits beautiful things away yet keeps them intact"-others are less so: "Madness is a land that's not open to day-trippers; it has to be booked in advance." This novel also lacks the moral certainty of most detective fiction. Set during the Great War, the story highlights the absurdity of prosecuting a single murder when whole battalions of boys are killing each other just a few miles away. There are few true innocents here, and no heroes. Justice, if it happens at all, happens by accident. The mystery that propels this story is not the question of who strangled a little girl, but the deeper, universal mystery of human existence. Claudel's policeman is not driven by matters of crime and punishment, but by a kind of dogged despair resulting from his beliefthat life is meaningless and ugly, and that each of us is-ultimately and essentially-alone. A bloodless, nihilistic, open-ended whodunit.
From the Publisher
"A grave, achingly beautiful novel. . . . He endows the people he writes about with a jagged humanity." —The New York Times"A haunted, grief-shadowed tale. . . . Claudel has a talent for swift, sure characterization." —The New York Times Book Review"[Claudel] evokes, with Poe-like mastery, the fog of apprehension that seeps into a small town after the murder of a young girl." —Vogue

Product Details

Knopf Doubleday Publishing Group
Publication date:
Edition description:
Product dimensions:
5.70(w) x 8.40(h) x 1.10(d)

Read an Excerpt

By a Slow River

By Philippe Claudel

Random House

Philippe Claudel
All right reserved.

ISBN: 1400042801

Chapter One


It's very difficult to find the beginning. So much time has gone by that words will never bring back--and the faces too, the smiles, the wounds. Even so, I must try. I have to cut open the belly of the mystery and stick my hands deep inside, even if none of that will change a thing.

If somebody were to ask me how on earth I know all the things I'm going to recount, I'd answer that I just do. I know them because for twenty years they've been as familiar to me as the fall of night and the dawn of day. Because in fact I've spent my life trying to piece them together, to put them into place. So they can speak and I can listen. That used to be my job, more or less.

I'll be calling forth a lot of shadows, but one will be out front. It belongs to a certain Pierre-Ange Destinat. He was the prosecutor in V for more than thirty years, and he plied his trade like clockwork, never faltering, never breaking down. Actually, you could say he was an artist, and he didn't even need a museum to show his art. In 1917, at the time of the Case--as people here called it, always with a sigh, it seemed--he was over sixty and had retired only the previous year. Though he hardly spoke, he always made a great impression. He was a tall impassive man who resembled an indifferent bird, far-off and majestic, with pale eyes that never seemed tomove and lips whose thinness he didn't bother to disguise with a moustache. His forehead was high and his hair a most distinguished gray.

V is about twenty kilometers from our town. Twenty kilometers in 1917 was very far indeed, especially in winter-especially in a war that showed no interest in ending. The war caused great commotion on the roads as they became jammed with handcarts and trucks, flooded with stinking fumes and thousands of thunderclaps. Even though the front was fairly nearby, from our town it seemed an invisible monster, another country.

Destinat was known by different names, depending on whom one asked and where. Among the inmates in the jail at V, he was generally called Bloodsucker. In one cell I even saw a drawing of him, carved with a knife on the thick oak door--not a bad likeness, in fact. Admittedly, the artist had had plenty of time to admire the model during the fifteen long days of his trial.

When we ran into Pierre-Ange Destinat on the street, the rest of us called him Mr. Prosecutor. Men raised their caps to him, and women of the humbler sort curtsied. Fine ladies of his own social class would incline their heads ever so slightly, like little birds when they drink from gutters. Whatever the greeter or greeting, it seemed no matter. He didn't answer--or did it so faintly you would've needed four well-polished opera glasses to see his lips move. But it wasn't disdain, as most believed; I think it was simply detachment.

All the same, there was one young lady who had almost understood him, a girl I will speak of again and who called him Sadness, a nickname she kept to herself. Maybe it's her fault that everything happened--but then, she never knew anything about it.

At the beginning of the century, a prosecutor was still a figure of great importance. And in time of war, when a single hail of bullets could mow down a whole company of solid lads, seeking the death of one lone man in chains required craftsmanship. I don't think he acted out of cruelty when he went after the head of some poor slob who had battered the postman or disemboweled his mother-in-law. The jerk stood in front of him between two officers, with handcuffs on his wrists, but at best Destinat hardly noticed him. He looked right through, as if the man had already ceased to exist. Destinat never prosecuted a flesh-and-blood criminal; he defended an idea, simply an idea: his own idea of good and evil.

When his sentence was pronounced the convicted criminal would howl, burst into tears, or fly into a rage. Sometimes he'd raise his hands to heaven, as if he'd suddenly remembered his catechism. By now, though, he was entirely invisible to Destinat. The prosecutor would be putting his notes away in his briefcase, four or five sheets on which he'd composed his closing argument, purple ink in his small refined script, a handful of well-chosen words that reliably made the court shudder and the jurors reflect, unless they were asleep; a few words that sufficed to erect a scaffold as if in an instant, surer than two journeyman carpenters could have done in a week.

He bore no grudge against the condemned. I saw the proof of that with my own eyes, in a hallway just following the verdict. Destinat emerged with his Cato-like air, his beautiful ermine still on his back, and came face-to-face with the Widow's future husband--the Widow, that's what they called the guillotine. The prisoner harangued him plaintively, eyes still red from having just heard his awful fate, and now full of remorse that he'd ever pumped those gunshots into his boss's gut. "Mistah Prosecutor," he whined, "Mistah Prosecutor . . ." Destinat looked him right in the eye, oblivious to the bailiff and the handcuffs, put a hand on his shoulder, and answered, "Yes, my friend. We've already met, haven't we? What can I do for you?" As sincere as you please--no mockery at all. The condemned man looked stunned. It was as if a second sentence had been pronounced on top of the first.

Following the end of every trial, Destinat would have lunch at the Rebillon, across from the cathedral. The owner is a fat man with a head white and yellow, like an endive, and a mouthful of rotten teeth. His name is Bourrache. He's not very clever, but he has a good head for money. That's his nature: no fault of his. He always wears a large apron of blue wool that makes him look like a girthed-up barrel. He used to have a wife who never left her bed; she suffered from sluggishness, as we say in this region, where it's not uncommon for certain women to confuse the November fogs with their own distress. When she finally died it was less on account of this illness--which after a time she'd probably put on as a permanent mantle--than because of what had happened, because of the Case.

At the time, the Bourrache daughters were like three little lilies, but with a pure touch of blood that brightened their complexions to a glow. The youngest was barely ten. She had no luck--or maybe she had a lot. Who knows?

The other two merely bore their first names, Aline and Rose, while everyone called the smallest one Belle and a few would-be poets made it Belle-de-jour--Morning Glory. When I would see all three of them in the room, carrying carafes of water, liters of wine, and silverware, among dozens of men who talked too loudly and drank too much, it seemed as if someone had arranged the flowers to relieve the sordidness of the atmosphere. And even in the company of her sisters, the little one looked so unspoiled as to seem not of our world.

When Destinat entered the restaurant, Bourrache--a man of habit--always treated him to the exact same greeting: "Another one cut down to size, Mr. Prosecutor!" Destinat would never answer, and Bourrache would show him to his seat. The prosecutor's table, one of the best, was reserved for him year-round. I didn't say the best, because that would have been the one nearest the enormous earthenware stove beside the window hung with crocheted curtains giving onto the entire Courthouse Square; that table was for Judge Mierck. A regular, Judge Mierck ate there four times a week. His belly told the tale, sagging down well beyond his waist; so did his skin, scored with broken veins as though all the Burgundies he'd drunk were waiting in line to be flushed out. Mierck didn't like the prosecutor very much. The feeling was mutual. I might even be putting it too mildly. Yet we would see them greet each other solemnly, doffing their hats, like two men opposed in life's every matter who share its daily course all the same.

The oddest thing was that Destinat went so rarely to the Rebillon that his table remained unoccupied about three quarters of the time. That caused Bourrache a fine loss of income, but he wouldn't have given that table to someone else for anything in the world, even on big fair days when all the peasants from miles around, having felt the rumps of all the prized cows, came to stuff themselves. By lunchtime they would have become insistent, on a liter of plum brandy, their heads spinning with thoughts of winding up at Ma Nain's whorehouse to ease themselves. But the table stayed unoccupied even as patrons were being turned away. One time Bourrache went so far as to eject a cattle trader who had dared to demand it. The man never came back.

"Better to have a king's table without the king than to seat somebody with manure all over his shoes!" That was Bourrache's romantic explanation, one day when I was needling him.


The first Monday of December 1917 was freezing cold. The clatter of the ground under your heels could be felt reverberating up to your neck. The large blanket they'd thrown over the body got soaked in a hurry as the two other cops, Berfuche, a short guy with ears like a wild pig, hairs sticking out of them, and Grosspeil, an Alsatian whose family had emigrated forty years earlier, stood watching over it near the bank of the canal. A little farther back stood young Brechut. A boxy fellow with hair as stiff as broom straw, he yanked on his vest, not too sure what he ought to do: stay or leave. He was the one who'd spotted her in the water on his way to work at the port authority, where he kept the accounts. (He still does, only he's twenty years older now and every straw has fallen out of the broom.)

Lying on the ground, a ten-year-old's body seems even smaller, especially when it's drenched by winter water. Berfuche pulled back a corner of the blanket to confirm what he knew and puffed into his hands for warmth. Morning Glory's face appeared.

She looked like a fairy with her eyelids blanched and lips turned blue, her hair entangled with the grass, withered brown by morning frosts. Her little hands had clutched at emptiness. It was so cold that day that all our moustaches whitened with hoarfrost as we huffed and stamped our feet like bulls getting ready to charge. In the sky some dim-witted geese were circling. They seemed to have lost their way. The sun huddled in his mantle of fog, which was fraying more and more. Even the cannon in the distance seemed to have frozen. You couldn't hear a thing.

"Maybe it's peace at last," ventured Grosspeil.

"Peace my ass!" His colleague snorted as he replaced the wet blanket over the little girl's body.

We were waiting for the gentlemen from V. Finally they arrived, accompanied by the mayor, who looked very much out of sorts, as you might too if you'd been jerked out of bed at the crack of dawn, especially in weather you wouldn't put a dog out in. There was Judge Mierck; his court clerk, whose name I never knew, though everyone called him Crusty because of a nasty eczema that ate away at the left half of his face; three cocksure policemen; and a military officer. I don't know what he was doing there, but he didn't hang around for long; one look at the murder scene and he keeled right over and we had to carry him to Jacques's Cafe. I figured the closest that slicker had ever come to a bayonet was in the armory, and maybe not even then. You could tell from his flawlessly ironed uniform, tailored for a mannequin at Poiret's. He must have been waging war beside a good cast-iron stove--sitting in a big velvet armchair--and then in the evening telling young ladies in long gowns all about the action, under gilded moldings and crystal chandeliers, among the bewigged musicians of a chamber orchestra, a glass of champagne in his hand.

Underneath his fancy Kronstadt hat and bon-vivant airs, Judge Mierck was a man of no feeling. All those wine sauces may have tinged his ears and nose, but they hadn't made him tender. He lifted the blanket himself and stared at Morning Glory for quite a while. The others were waiting for a word, a sigh: after all, he used to see her almost every day when he gorged himself at the Rebillon. He looked down at the little body as if it were a stone or a piece of driftwood that had been fished out, his eyes as icy as the water that flowed close by.

"It's Bourrache's youngest girl," somebody murmured into his ear, in a tone that bespoke everything he wouldn't say. "The poor little thing, she was just ten years old. Imagine--only yesterday she was bringing my bread and smoothing out my tablecloth."

With a start, Judge Mierck rocked back on his heels toward the man who'd dared to address him. "A corpse is a corpse!"

Before that moment we had all accepted Judge Mierck for what he was. He had his place and he held it, not liked much, but respected. But on that first Monday of December, by the mortal remains of this little girl, his words, and even more how matter-of-factly he said them, almost cheerfully, with a gleam in his eyes at having a murder case at last, a real one, for it was murder, no doubt about it!--in this time of war, when all the killers had forsaken civil life so they could ply their aggression more violently in uniform--after that day, people in our region never thought of him without disgust.

"Well, well, well," he said. As he surveyed the scene he was humming, as if about to play skittles or go hunting. Then he realized he was hungry. He had to have some eggs, eggs right away, there on the bank of the little canal, at ten degrees below.

Excerpted from By a Slow River by Philippe Claudel Excerpted by permission.
All rights reserved. No part of this excerpt may be reproduced or reprinted without permission in writing from the publisher.
Excerpts are provided by Dial-A-Book Inc. solely for the personal use of visitors to this web site.

Meet the Author

• ?;Philippe Claudel was born in 1962. Before becoming a novelist, he was a teacher and a screenwriter. He lives in France.

Customer Reviews

Average Review:

Write a Review

and post it to your social network


Most Helpful Customer Reviews

See all customer reviews >

By a Slow River 3.9 out of 5 based on 0 ratings. 10 reviews.
Guest More than 1 year ago
Former Police officer Dadais reflects back two decades to December 1917, the French villagers are shocked when the strangled corpse of ten years old girl Belle ¿Morning Glory¿ Bourrache is found by the banks BY A SLOW RIVER that slices through a small, unnamed French village. The townsfolk find the crime hideous as the murder of a child could only have been done by an animal. On the other hand he wonders how everyone including him takes for granted that the nearby battles against Germans will leave both sides filled with uncountable numbers of dead.--------------- Dadais remembers how he struggled to uncover the identity of the repulsive killer. Clues are not readily available but the stubborn Dadais insists that two suspects stick out, egotistical retired sexagenarian ¿Mr. Prosecutor¿ Pierre-Ange Destinat and that shadowy Breton war deserter, who admits he committed the murder, but Dadais knows he would have confessed to anything under the torture used to extract his admittance. Others wonder if Dadais wonders if others are as determined to hide the identity of the real culprit as he is to find him..------------------ This is a terrific psychological historical thriller masked somewhat as a police procedural. Dadais is wonderful protagonist looking back at the case that obsessed him and his townsfolk when at the same time they understood the absurdity of caring about one death when millions were ¿legally¿ dying nearby. Philippe Claudel cleverly echoes Joseph Stalin¿s alleged comment that 'one death is a tragedy, a million deaths is a statistic.' Readers will appreciate this off beat suspense thriller as they wonder just who murdered that little girl.------------ Harriet Klausner
Guest More than 1 year ago
This is one of the most beautifully written books I have read in a long time! I would learn French just to read this book in it's original language. But don't be concerned about the translation, it is flawless. This is the story of a police officer investigated the death of a 10 year old girl nicknamed Morning Glory. It takes place in WWI France right next to the front line. It is a typical whodunit except it's anything but typical. This is a book about death and the things humans are capable of in their darkest moments. It's a must read!
Guest More than 1 year ago
The story's narrator is wonderful. The author has created a narrator that elicits both compassion, frustration, and anger from the reader. Claudel has created a stunning murder mystery while deftly unfolding the narrator's mysterious past, present, and future.
Rishcik70 More than 1 year ago
A very good read! Not as powerful as Brodeck but still an excellent story of war and intolerance...
Anonymous More than 1 year ago
Anonymous More than 1 year ago
Anonymous More than 1 year ago
Anonymous More than 1 year ago
Anonymous More than 1 year ago
Anonymous More than 1 year ago