A Disturbing Installment
I've had a hard time reconciling the positives and negatives of this book. The plot starts with a dramatic revelation, but then seems to just chase its tale with a lot of false starts, dead ends and confounding attacks on Harry. Although the story is compelling with high emotional stakes, the circular plot is frustrating until Harry finally uncovers useful information well past the story's mid-point. In the last quarter of the book an exciting confrontation occurs featuring well-described action and magic.
Unfortunately, the book's climax also exhibits both positive and negative aspects. At the outset the plot's resolution is surprising and inventive with a bombshell twist. However, it takes a decidedly disturbing and disappointing direction as Harry coldly manipulates and misuses an ally (and one of the good guys). As a result, Harry's character is irrevocably blackened. Further, the plot's resolution reveals an uncaring, some might say hostile, attitude towards motherhood. Moreover, the whole sequence of events during the climax is illogical as the innocent victim would surely have been dispatched by the bad guy(s) before Harry summons his will and acts decisively.
In the concluding scenes Harry's narcissistic concern for his material losses and self-centered plans to get drunk and get laid reveals a complete lack of remorse concerning his earlier misuse of his ally. Further, he experiences no grief over the loss of someone who should mean something to him. His total lack of remorse and sorrow paints the portrait of a selfish and shallow individual. I found myself asking what happened to the caring and heroic Harry. It's not just that Harry becomes 'gray' and makes compromises for the greater good, it's as if he looses his ability to feel compassion when it suits his purposes.
The finish of the book is likewise unsatisfactory. At first I thought it was an abrupt end to the series. Then I realized that it was being interpreted as a cliffhanger. IMO, the book's finish is a completely frustrating and feeble way to end any book, regardless of whether that book constitutes a stand-alone novel or is an installment in an ongoing series.
As regards other aspects of the story, the pace is fast exhibiting Butcher's trademark infusion of periodic action scenes featuring vividly described magic, heart-thumping combat and inventive monsters. Some of the characters, however, lose complexity and become Harry's 'fan girls'. In particular, Harry becomes romantically attractive to the two supporting female regulars despite one's past reservations and irrespective of the lack of any established romantic interest on the part of the other. Virtually all the female characters are simplistically divided into two groups. One is composed of scary monsters to be destroyed and/or feared. The other is composed of women who have a 'thing' for Harry. That division of female characters, (between monsters and fan girls), indicates a chauvinistic and somewhat juvenile attitude towards women. Plus, chauvinistic comments periodically pepper the dialogue. In sum, this book just seemed extraordinarily dismissive towards women.
So, do I recommend this book? Yes, it's a must read installment for fans of the series. However, if I was asked whether or not I liked the book, I'd have to answer no. I didn't like what happened in this book, and I didn't like the manner in which some characters, including Harry, were diminished.
13 out of 37 people found this review helpful.
Was this review helpful? Yes NoThank you for your feedback.
Report this reviewThank you, this review has been flagged.