Commonsense Justice / Edition 1

Commonsense Justice / Edition 1

by Norman J. Finkel
     
 

ISBN-10: 0674005562

ISBN-13: 9780674005563

Pub. Date: 04/16/2001

Publisher: Harvard University Press

For the first time in our history, U.S. prisons house over a million inmates, enough to populate a city larger than San Francisco. Building prisons is the new growth industry, as the American public reacts to a perceived increase in violence and politicians take a hard line toward crime. But this eagerness to construct more prisons raises basic questions about what

…  See more details below

Overview

For the first time in our history, U.S. prisons house over a million inmates, enough to populate a city larger than San Francisco. Building prisons is the new growth industry, as the American public reacts to a perceived increase in violence and politicians take a hard line toward crime. But this eagerness to construct more prisons raises basic questions about what the community wants and will tolerate and what the Supreme Court will sanction.

In this timely book, Norman Finkel looks at the relationship between the "law on the books," as set down in the Constitution and developed in cases and decisions, and what he calls "commonsense justice," the ordinary citizen's notions of what is just and fair. Law is an essentially human endeavor, a collection of psychological theories about why people think, feel, and behave as they do, and when and why we should find some of them blameworthy and punishable. But is it independent of community sentiment, as some would contend? Or, as Finkel suggests, do juries bring the community's judgment to bear on the moral blameworthiness of the defendant? When jurors decide that the law is unfair, or the punishment inappropriate for a particular defendant, they have sometimes nullified the law.

Nullification represents the jury's desire not to defeat but "to perfect and complete" the law. It is the "no confidence" vote of commonsense justice refusing to follow the path the law has marked out--and pointing to a new path based on what seem to be more just grounds. Finkel brings to life the story behind the jury and judicial decisions, interweaving anecdotes, case law, and social science research to present a balanced and comprehensive view of important legal and social policy issues.

Product Details

ISBN-13:
9780674005563
Publisher:
Harvard University Press
Publication date:
04/16/2001
Edition description:
New Edition
Pages:
404
Product dimensions:
6.00(w) x 9.00(h) x 0.83(d)

Table of Contents

Introduction

1. In Search of Community Sentiment

2. Understanding Nullification

3. Revealing Jurors' Sentiments

4. How Jurors Construct Reality

5. Objectivity versus Subjectivity in the Law

6. The Sacred Precinct of the Bedroom

7. The Right to Die

8. Cruel and Unusual Punishment

9. Murther Most Foul

10. Death Is Different

11. The Juvenile Death Penalty

12. On Self-Defense justice

13. The Self-Defense Drama

14.The Maddening Changes in Insanity Law

15. How Jurors Construe Insanity

16. Murderous Passions, Mitigating Sentiments

17. The Path of Commonsense Justice

Notes

Index

Customer Reviews

Average Review:

Write a Review

and post it to your social network

     

Most Helpful Customer Reviews

See all customer reviews >