Companions of Paradise

Companions of Paradise

4.7 7
by Thalassa Ali

View All Available Formats & Editions

In A Singular Hostage and A Beggar at the Gate, Thalassa Ali introduced us to the lush, intriguing world of nineteenth-century British India—and to Mariana Givens, a brave, beautiful Englishwoman. Now, as vengeful Afghan tribesmen close in, Mariana must face the repercussions of her marriage to a Punjabi Muslim, and choose between the people she


In A Singular Hostage and A Beggar at the Gate, Thalassa Ali introduced us to the lush, intriguing world of nineteenth-century British India—and to Mariana Givens, a brave, beautiful Englishwoman. Now, as vengeful Afghan tribesmen close in, Mariana must face the repercussions of her marriage to a Punjabi Muslim, and choose between the people she calls her own—and the life that owns her heart.

Mariana Givens aches to return to the rose-scented city of Lahore, home of Hassan Ali Khan, the Muslim stranger she has come to love, his mystical family, and his prescient little son. But her own reckless behavior has sent her into exile at the British cantonment near Kabul, on the eve of the First Afghan War. There, she embarks on a dangerous double life, pretending to be a proper young Victorian lady while secretly traveling Kabul’s violent, fascinating streets to visit the Sufi seer who possesses the answers she needs.

But the mystic’s help comes with a price, and her family wants her to marry a British officer. As Afghanistan descends into violence and her hopes of rescue fade, Mariana must make a fateful decision: can she abandon her old life and allow herself to be drawn toward her destiny—whatever it may be?

From the Trade Paperback edition.

Editorial Reviews

Publishers Weekly

The final installment of Thalassa's Paradise Trilogy (following A Singular Hostageand A Beggar at the Gate) finds Mariana Givens living within the confines of the British cantonment at Kabul in 1841, on the eve of the first Afghan war. An assassination attempt in Lahore thwarted by her husband, Hassan Ali Khan (son of a Sufi sheikh), has forced Mariana to leave Lahore, abandoning Hassan (and her stepson, Saboor). Mariana lives miserably in an English microsociety that doesn't recognize her marriage, full of dinner parties and eager suitors. Hassan, meanwhile, is recovering slowly from wounds, and his family is second-guessing Mariana's intentions. As tension escalates between the British (who have deposed the Afghan king, Amir Dost Muhammad, and installed a more friendly rival, Shah Shuja) and the Afghans (who are preparing to attack the British army and its 10,000 "camp followers"), Mariana faces dangerous choices. As in the other books, Ali does a highly credible job creating the clannish atmospheres of the British and Sufi subcultures, and makes the strictures that Mariana and Hassan face (and those of their servants) palpable. The detail she offers (including mystic writings from a variety of traditions) is nicely wedded to the plot, which moves with brisk and engaging efficiency. (Apr.)

Copyright 2007 Reed Business Information
Library Journal

This final volume of Ali's colonial India trilogy (following A Singular Hostageand A Beggar at the Gate) takes place in Kabul, Afghanistan, where Mariana Givens and her fellow Brits are living in a military camp. Tensions between the Afghanis and the British are on the rise, but the British feel that their military might and modern weaponry are enough to crush the Afghan rebels. Mariana's marriage to Hassan Ali Khan makes her an outcast, since Englishwomen aren't expected to interact with the "natives." The two are separated and may divorce; the status of their marriage drives much of the plot. Mariana vacillates between hoping they'll stay married so that she can continue to learn from Hassan's aunt, a charismatic Muslim mystic, and hoping for divorce so that she can take up with former flame Harry Fitzgerald and lead a traditional life. As the situation in Kabul deteriorates and becomes violent, Mariana once again steps up to help protect the people she has grown to love. Despite the historical context, the clash between Christianity and Islam seems contemporary and relevant given current world events. Recommended for popular and historical fiction collections.
—Nanette Donohue

Kirkus Reviews
Final installment in a historical trilogy (A Singular Hostage, 2002, etc.) setting a feisty English heroine against a backdrop of political upheaval in Victorian-era India and Afghanistan. In March 1841, Mariana Givens settles in a British fort north of Kabul with her Aunt Claire and Uncle Adrian, a colonial intelligence officer. Surrounded by military and government officials' families, Mariana hides the fact that she is still married to Hassan Ali Khan, a Punjabi Muslim courtier whose household in Lahore, India, she fled several weeks earlier. After overhearing him discuss an Englishman's attempt to assassinate the new maharajah, she wrongly accused Hassan of plotting to kill her aunt and uncle, their British traveling companions, perhaps even herself. Demanding a divorce, Mariana bolted, but she soon rues her hotheadedness. She misses Hassan and her four-year-old stepson Saboor, a pint-sized diviner who remains in Lahore with his father and grandfather, a famed Sufi mystic. Receiving no response from Hassan to her apologetic letters, Mariana reluctantly accepts the renewed attentions of an English lieutenant but secretly consults a Kabul soothsayer about her romantic destiny. She also observes the mounting unrest of local tribesmen under Shah Shuja, installed in 1839 by British forces after they ousted the Afghan king. As warfare erupts, Mariana finds her loyalties divided; she eventually seeks asylum from a fierce chieftain allied with the deposed king's son. Pluck, Qur'anic verse, invocations of Allah's blessings and Saboor's otherworldly powers guide her back to Hassan. Mariana passionately defends Islam and its practitioners against the prejudices of the "self-satisfied,overstuffed people" who comprise the worst of her peers, but the novel never explores the implications of having as its protagonist a white adventuress who is preternaturally understanding of native customs. Painstaking reconstruction of a period with great contemporary relevance, marred by one-note characters and the use of heavy-handed shtick such as dreams to advance the plot. Agent: Jill Kneerim/Kneerim & Williams

Product Details

Random House Publishing Group
Publication date:
Sold by:
Random House
Sales rank:
File size:
5 MB

Read an Excerpt

Companions of Paradise

By Thalassa Ali


Copyright © 2007 Thalassa Ali
All right reserved.

ISBN: 9780553381788

Chapter 1

March 22, 1841

Mariana Givens rode into the capital of Afghanistan on the morning after the Afghan New Year. Riding sidesaddle next to her aunt's palanquin with its twelve trotting bearers, and followed on foot by a tall groom and a tough, albino mail courier, she played only a modest role in the dignified procession of English people that paraded past the great, frowning citadel, then turned toward the British cantonment.

Sir William Macnaghten, the Political Envoy, and his beaming, newly arrived wife, led the march on an elephant, preceded by a cavalry escort. Mariana's uncle rode behind them on horseback with his foppish assistant, Lady Macnaghten's Charles Mott who was also nephew. Mariana and her aunt came next, followed by more cavalry and a long line of trudging servants and coolies and scores of pack animals carrying the camp tents, Lady Macnaghten's silver, bone china, and Bohemian glass; the household goods of Mariana's family; and enough champagne and brandy to last the Residence for a year.

Aunt Claire held the curtain of her palanquin aside, and put her head out. "Sir William seemed very pleased to see his wife again after all these months," she observed in the sonorous tone she reserved for the discussion of senior officials and their families. "And Lady Macnaghten appeared especially happy this morning as we were leaving Bootik, or wherever that was. She lookedpositively girlish!"

Mariana did not respond. Instead, she glanced behind her, over the heads of Yar Mohammad and Ghulam Ali, past the cavalry and the baggage train, toward the forbidding Hindu Kush Range that divided India from Central Asia. Those mountains, whose stony valleys and dangerous passes they had crossed so laboriously, seemed no farther behind them than they had been when the travelers had set out from camp four hours earlier.

She blinked, hoping it was only the bright, deceiving air that made them seem to follow her, then drew her shawls closer about her, longing for the warm plains of India, where she had left her heart.

Dust storms would rise soon from the flat plain of the Punjab, turning the sun to a red disk and filling the air with fine grit that irritated people's eyes and crunched between their teeth. The hot weather would bring the dreaded lu, the hot, arid wind that killed children and old people, and dropped farmers dead of heatstroke in their fields. But for all the discomfort of India, if Mariana's circumstances had allowed it, she would gladly have abandoned her aunt and uncle and the rest of Lady Macnaghten's traveling party and turned back to Shaikh Waliullah's house in the walled city of Lahore. There, while the dust blew in through the haveli's shuttered windows, she would have sung nonsense rhymes to little Saboor, and laid cool compresses on Hassan Ali Khan's forehead--that is, if he had wished her to do so.

Surely she would find a way to return there, and atone for her mistakes. . . .

Ringed by snow-topped mountain ranges and watered by a winding river that bore its name, the city of Kabul stood six thousand feet above sea level. Bounded on the northwest by the Kabul River, on the south by the Sher Darwaza heights, and on the southeast by the Bala Hissar, its great fortress of kings, the city occupied a roughly triangular area on the western edge of its high, fertile plateau.

When Lady Macnaghten's traveling party emerged from the mountains and onto the Kabul plain, its members had found themselves in a demi-paradise. The sky above the tree-lined road was a sharp blue, quite different from the bleached sky of India. Bright light fell upon vast mulberry and apricot orchards, still veiled in the wispy red that precedes the green of spring. The skirts of the surrounding hills, some still boasting ancient fortified walls, were beginning to turn green, while here and there, and tulips and hyacinths pushed their way up through the soil. The air was so clear that Mariana easily made out the facial expressions of three men standing on a distant road.

Traveling west from Butkhak, they had crossed the Logar River at Bagrami, then paraded past the frowning Bala Hissar before turning northwest toward the Kohistan Road and the newly built cantonment, symbol of the recent political triumph of the British, and their powerful military presence in Afghanistan.

Men passed on the road, their loose garments flowing about them, carrying loads on their heads or leading strings of camels. Mariana studied them, amazed by how different they were from the Indians she was accustomed to.

Bristling with weapons, their backs upright, these men moved swiftly, with fluid, ground-covering strides, their eyes fixed on the distance, unlike the Indians, who moved about unarmed, their shoulders hunched thoughtfully.

A stocky fellow stepped toward Mariana. Greasy hair hung below his loosely tied turban. The handle of a knife protruded from an opening in the man's coarse, woolen coat. His face was narrow and harsh. Mariana saw that his eyes were circled with black kohl. He was followed by a youth with a large bundle on his back.

"As salaam-o-alaikum, may peace be upon you," she offered politely.

He strode past without acknowledging her, but the youth behind him paused. He stared into her face with startlingly beautiful eyes, his heart-shaped face intent. Before she had time to nod, the older man looked over his shoulder. His mouth twisting, he reached for his knife. The boy dropped his gaze and hurried after the man.

There had been something odd about the boy.

"What are you doing, child?" Aunt Claire inquired, putting her head out for a second time between her palanquin curtains. "Surely you were not speaking to the natives!"

The British cantonment and its neighboring residence compound for government staff stood on the Kohistan Road, a mile north of the Bala Hissar, where the new British-approved puppet king had been installed. A walled parallelogram built to accommodate the British army and its twelve thousand camp followers, the cantonment was surrounded prettily by irrigated orchards and overlooked by the nearby Bibi Mahro and Sia Sang hills.

Mariana's old interest in military matters quickened as the cantonment's long ramparts became visible through the trees. She studied its fortifications, remembering the books she and her father had read together, imagining the questions he would ask in his next letter.

A large bazaar had been built outside one of the fort's heavy corner towers. Through several openings in its mud brick outer wall, Mariana glimpsed narrow, busy streets filled with small shops displaying colorful wares. Peopled by the artisans and shopkeepers who had accompanied the British army, the bazaar looked like any Indian town; indeed, it was larger than many towns, for it housed several thousand souls. As the procession passed by it, the air that had been perfumed with the scent of poplar balsam took on the added tang of wood smoke, sewage, and spices.

After the procession had halted, and the Macnaghtens and Charles Mott had been ushered ceremoniously away to their grand house in the Residence compound, Mariana frowned.

"I had thought the walls would be higher, Uncle Adrian," she said thoughtfully. "After all, we are invaders here. And I wonder why the surrounding ditch is so narrow. It seems to me--"

"You and the Would-Be-General must wait for that information," her uncle replied. "Once we are settled, you will have plenty of time to pepper everyone with your military questions. As for me, I shall barely have the time to fulfill my own duties. I understand that only a few of our people here are able to speak Farsi, and hardly anyone knows a word of Pushto."

"Poor Uncle Adrian." Mariana dropped her voice. "I don't suppose Charles Mott is any use, either."

Her uncle spread his hands. "Charles Mott holds Lady Macnaghten's elbow, that is all."

The polyglot population of Afghanistan had two principal languages. Of these, Farsi, or Persian, would always do as a court language, but Pushto was spoken by all the tribesmen who lived near the border with India--the same area the British army had passed through on its triumphant march to Kabul.

"How will you be able to communicate with people and gather information?" she asked.

Her uncle shrugged. "We can use Farsi," he replied, as they followed a young officer to their assigned bungalow in the Residence compound. "But if we cannot understand the subtleties of a man's own language, we will never know what he is thinking."


"I understand," Mariana's aunt Claire declared two mornings later, as she, her husband, and Mariana sat on mismatched chairs in their dining room, "that Kabul is becoming quite a gay station. It is no wonder that our officers are now sending for their wives and children. They are playing cricket and putting on theatricals. They are even arranging picnics to lovely places within reach of the city."

She sighed happily as an elderly manservant poured her a cup of coffee. "I shall be delighted to stretch my legs, now that we are away from that stifling Indian heat."

"There is to be a race meeting tomorrow," Uncle Adrian put in. "I understand that Afghan horsemen will participate."

"A race meeting?" Aunt Claire sniffed. "I have no intention of attending a third-class horse race with a lot of Afghans. Besides," she waved toward a heap of bundles on the drawing room floor, "we haven't even had the carpets unrolled, and that hunched-over servant of Mariana's pretends not to understand a word I say. How will I have the pictures hung if you're gone all afternoon?"

Uncle Adrian signaled for more toast. "Shah Shuja, our new Amir," he said, "is expected to be present with his court. All our senior officers will be in attendance on the king, but there will be a separate tent for the other officers and all the ladies. Both Lady Sale and Lady Macnaghten are expected."

His wife sat straight in her chair. "Why did you not say so?" she cried. "Of course I shall be delighted to--"

"Now, Mariana," he went on, "you must be very careful at the race meeting. Do not speak to the Afghans, or meet their eyes. In Central Asia it is considered extremely bad manners for a woman to look openly at a strange man."

"Adrian, I am shocked!" The edging on Aunt Claire's lace cap quivered with indignation. "Surely an innocent Englishwoman may look at whomever she pleases!"

"Furthermore," he persisted, "the good opinion of our own officers is vital to your future, Mariana. You must do your utmost to behave correctly. Your reputation has suffered considerably in the past two years. And you must on no account reveal that you are technically married to an Indian native."

Mariana laid down her fork. "Uncle Adrian, there is no need to remind me--"

"You are the only eligible Englishwoman in Afghanistan, and since young Lieutenant Fitzgerald may be coming tomorrow--"

"Fitzgerald?" Aunt Claire's pudgy face turned radiant. "If there is the slightest chance Lieutenant Fitzgerald will be at the horse race tomorrow," she announced, "then I would not miss it for all the world."

"I am looking forward to my first public appearance," Lady Macnaghten confided as she and Mariana perched together on a sofa in the Residence's sitting room. "I shall wear my blue watered-silk, and a few feathers. As my husband is to be seated in the royal enclosure with the Shah," she added with a little sigh, "I shall have to manage without him."

Mariana smiled politely. What time was it? How long would she have to listen to Lady Macnaghten talk about herself?

As if she had heard Mariana's thoughts, Lady Macnaghten leaned toward her, close enough to reveal a few faint lines around her eyes. "Lieutenant Fitzgerald has returned from Kandahar," she whispered meaningfully. "I have told him that he must on no account miss the race meeting. You must therefore look your very best. I am sending Vijaya to you this afternoon."

Fitzgerald. The person Mariana most dreaded seeing. If the lieutenant came tomorrow, her appearance would be the very least of her worries. "That is very kind of you, Lady Macnaghten," she demurred. "But I am sure I shall manage perfectly well."

"Perfectly well will not be good enough." Lady Macnaghten waved a manicured hand. "Your hair and skin are dry. You have let yourself go entirely since we left India. When Vijaya is done," she added confidently, "you will look as pretty as you did then. And after tomorrow, it will be only a matter of time before Fitzgerald proposes.

"And of course," she added, ignoring Mariana's stricken face, "I shall not mention this to a soul."

Mariana got hastily to her feet. "Thank you so much, Lady Macnaghten," she said firmly, "but I must leave. I fear my aunt is waiting for me."

Proposes. If Lady Macnaghten, or the British community, learned the truth about her marriage to Hassan, they would stop forcing her on Harry Fitzgerald.

If they knew, they would never speak to her again.

Two hours later, she sat at a makeshift dressing table in her bedroom, a towel about her shoulders while Lady Macnaghten's silent, sari-clad maid combed henna paste through her hair.

Only Lady Macnaghten, who herself made good use of Indian beauty tricks, had noticed Mariana's transformation after her visit to Lahore, from clumsy English girl to elegantly cared-for native wife. She alone had seen that transformation fade, then disappear, on the journey from Lahore.

Mariana did not need to look in her hand glass to know how much she had changed since her arrival in India three years earlier.

On that first day, twenty years old, pink-cheeked and clumsy, she had flung herself into Aunt Claire's arms, certain she would be married to a handsome English officer before a year had passed. Young, and optimistic, she had believed she had nothing to lose.

But she had lost, then lost again, and with each failure she had given up a little more of her innocence about herself.

Her face had thinned a little in that time, and her rosy cheeks had turned to ivory, but her skin already felt smooth from Vijaya's efforts, and after a tortuous session with a cat's-cradle of twisted string, her brows now formed graceful arches over her eyes. The henna would tame her curls, and make them shine.

By the time Vijaya left, Mariana would, ironically, look once again like Hassan's wife.

Of course, myopic Aunt Claire would be unlikely to notice any of these changes. Only yesterday, as she poked fretfully through her jewelry, she had listed the same tired complaints she always made concerning her niece's looks and deportment.

"I hope you will listen to me this time," she had warned. "As you are about to make an entirely undeserved new start in British society in Kabul, you must rein in your outspoken manner. Cultivate demureness. And for goodness sake do something about that huge, unfashionable smile of yours."

Mariana had sighed as her aunt swept from the room. The new start that Aunt Claire referred to was more than undeserved. It was a sham.

Three weeks after she had taken painful leave of the unconscious Hassan, his luminous little son and his fascinating family and joined Lady Macnaghten's traveling party, Mariana had gathered her courage and swept into her uncle's tent. Expecting no sympathy from her cholera-ridden uncle or his exhausted wife, she had gone straight to the point.

"I must tell you," she had blurted out, without any softening preamble, "that I did not divorce Shaikh Waliullah's son while I was in Lahore. He may have divorced me since then, but I do not believe he has."

As she spoke, she had reached up and touched the bodice of her gown. Under the fabric, her searching fingers found the gold medallion the wounded Hassan had sent after her, carried by the courier Ghulam Ali.

A wavering note had accompanied his gift. For my wife, it had read.

Giddy with happiness, she had sent Hassan a passionate, gushing letter of thanks. In the five weeks since then, he had not replied.

"He might also," she had added, her voice dropping, "have died."

Uncle Adrian's face had changed color. "You never divorced that man, after all the trouble we went to?" he had croaked from his pillows.

"I tried, Uncle Adrian, I really did. There was fighting in the city and my husband was constantly--"

"Never mind 'fighting in the city,' " Aunt Claire cut in from her folding chair. "For the past weeks you have led us to believe that all was accomplished, that you were free to marry an Englishman once we reached Afghanistan. You have lied to us, Mariana."

"I merely avoided the truth. Uncle Adrian has been so ill. I did not wish to burden you with more than--"

"I should have insisted." Aunt Claire's chins wobbled with outrage. "I should have questioned you as soon as you returned from the city." Her eyes narrowed. "Mariana, I demand to know the truth. Did you ruin yourself while you were there? Did you allow your native husband to take liberties with you at his father's house?"

"Please, Claire. Adil is here." Uncle Adrian signaled to the elderly manservant who hovered, fascinated, near the doorway of the tent.

"I allowed nothing," Mariana snapped, as soon as the servant had gone. "With Lahore under attack, there simply was no time for a divorce. Besides, my husband was wounded during the battle at the Citadel."


Excerpted from Companions of Paradise by Thalassa Ali Copyright © 2007 by Thalassa Ali. Excerpted by permission.
All rights reserved. No part of this excerpt may be reproduced or reprinted without permission in writing from the publisher.
Excerpts are provided by Dial-A-Book Inc. solely for the personal use of visitors to this web site.

Meet the Author

Thalassa Ali is an American who married a Pakistani and lived in Lahore for many years, before returning to Boston to become a successful stockbroker. She is the author of two previous novels featuring Mariana Givens, A Singular Hostage and A Beggar at the Gate, both available from Bantam Books. She lives in Boston.

From the Trade Paperback edition.

Customer Reviews

Average Review:

Write a Review

and post it to your social network


Most Helpful Customer Reviews

See all customer reviews >

Companions of Paradise 4.7 out of 5 based on 0 ratings. 7 reviews.
Anonymous More than 1 year ago
Anonymous More than 1 year ago
Anonymous More than 1 year ago
ADarling More than 1 year ago
it really is the best...wont put it down from start to finish..i cant wait for the 4th one!..there better be a 4th :)
Anonymous More than 1 year ago
Anonymous More than 1 year ago
harstan More than 1 year ago
In 1841 in Lahore, India, British expatriate Mariana Givens believes her husband Hassan Ali Khan, a Punjabi Muslim, plots to kill her Aunt Claire and Uncle Adrian, an Intel Officer. Outraged, she flees her new home demanding a divorce and travels to reside with her aunt and uncle behind the safe walls of the British fort near Kabul, Afghanistan.------------- However once there, she hides from her family and the British officials and their dependents that she remains married. Mariana rues her rash rush to judgment as she misses her beloved Hassan, his four-year-old son Saboor, and her fathering-law the renowned Sufi mystic. When Hassan fails to answer her pleading letters to forgive her, Mariana turns to a local soothsayer for advice. However, her biggest fear is the open hostilities between the British and the local supporters vs. the tribes who want the ousted king returned---------------- When the tale concentrates on the ¿first¿ Afghan war, COMPANIONS OF PARADISE is a superior period piece that brings to life the British mid nineteenth colonization of the country. However, when the plot focuses on Mariana¿s introspective of her personal issues through dreams and fortune tellers, it loses some of the momentum. Still this final tale of Victorian India and Afghanistan can stand alone though it is enhanced by first reading A BEGGAR AT THE GATE and SINGULAR HOSTAGE. This is a fascinating insightful look back with fascinating parallels to the modern day Afghan war.-------------- Harriet Klausner