Constitutional Law, Fourth Edition

Constitutional Law, Fourth Edition

by Geoffrey R. Stone, Mark Tushnet, Cass R. Sunstein, Louis M. Seidman
     
 

This widely adopted constitutional law casebook earned its leading position in the field through broad coverage of the law and careful integration of a rich variety of social and critical perspectives. Streamlined and strengthened for its Fourth Edition, CONSTITUTIONAL LAW continues to provide a comprehensive examination of doctrine and practice, ideally suited to

See more details below

Overview

This widely adopted constitutional law casebook earned its leading position in the field through broad coverage of the law and careful integration of a rich variety of social and critical perspectives. Streamlined and strengthened for its Fourth Edition, CONSTITUTIONAL LAW continues to provide a comprehensive examination of doctrine and practice, ideally suited to a two-semester course. The expert author team preserves the distinctive features of their casebook:

  • multi-disciplinary approach incorporates political theory, philosophy, sociology, ethics, and economics to illuminate wide-ranging social and critical perspectives
  • takes a contemporary look at Constitutional Law within a traditional doctrinal structure
  • extensive textual material summarizes the state of the law and its development
  • logical two-part organization begins with the balance of powers among the Supreme Court and local, state, and federal governments, then considers the rights and powers of individuals
  • comprehensive coverage of all the standard course topics
  • annual supplementation separates First Amendment materials for ease of research
  • outstandingly clear and concise coverage of First Amendment law, of particular value to instructors whose schools do not have a separate course in the area Changes to the Fourth Edition include:
  • pruning the note material, the book has been reduced by 200 pages for greater manageability
  • extensive material on the Clinton impeachment
  • treatment of the constitutionality of majority-minority voting districts
  • coverage of the Eleventh Amendment includes a synopsis of new cases

    Read More

  • Editorial Reviews

    David Barnum
    CONSTITUTIONAL LAW is a relatively new entry into the notoriously crowded and competitive market of law school casebooks. It has reportedly done very well, however, and its success is not difficult to understand. The book is well organized, comprehensive, superbly written, and clearly more au courant or hip (in the context, that is, of the staid world of legal scholarship) than competing casebooks with which I am familiar (for example, Lockhart, 1991; Gunther, 1991). The book is a full-fledged constitutional law casebook. The only area which is not covered -- the rights of criminal defendants -- is one which is now routinely omitted from law school casebooks (even those devoted exclusively to civil liberties). The non-civil liberties material in CONSTITUTIONAL LAW is presented in chapters on "The Powers of Congress," "Judicial Efforts to Protect the Expansion of the Market against Assertions of Local Power," "The Distribution of National Powers," and "Economic Liberties and the Constitution: The Contracts and Takings Clauses." Three chapters are devoted to the standard areas of civil liberties: "Equality and the Constitution," "Freedom of Expression," and "The Constitution and Religion." Finally, there are three chapters which represent a departure from the format of at least some other casebooks. A first chapter focuses on "The Role of the Supreme Court in the Constitutional Scheme," a final chapter focuses on "The Constitution and the Problem of Private Power," and a chapter in the middle of the book is devoted to "Implied Fundamental Rights," that is, the debate over original intent, the incorporation controversy, substantive due process (old and new), and substantive equal protection. Each of the chapters begins with an introductory and/or historical section which is extremely useful and in fact downright essential if the book is to be used to teach constitutional law to undergraduates. The "Equality" chapter, for instance, begins with a section entitled "Race and the Constitution" in which the editors discuss and reprint historical scholarship on slavery and the Constitution, reprint an excerpt from DRED SCOTT (a fairly unusual choice, in my experience), discuss (in essay form with generous excerpts from cases and historical scholarship) the subject of "Reconstruction and Retreat," reprint PLESSY V. FERGUSON, and then move into the background of the school cases and eventually to BROWN and SWANN and to cases and other materials relevant to the problem of northern school segregation. The material is dense and challenging for anyone encountering issues of race and law for the first time. However, the choices the editors have made about what to reprint and in what order ensure that a conscientious student will learn as much as is humanly possible within a few pages about the social origins of the Court's decisions on race, about how and why the law has developed in certain ways, and about what the law is today. Obviously the Supreme Court's decisions and their content exert a strong influence on the organization of CONSTITUTIONAL LAW. At the same time, one of the strengths of the book is the fact that cases play a much smaller role than in other casebooks in dictating both the organization of the book and the topics which are addressed. The book is not a collection of Supreme Court decisions embellished with commentary. It is a book about American constitutional law in which cases and other materials are deftly woven into an ongoing narrative in order to illustrate and substantiate various carefully chosen themes. The case excerpts themselves are comparable to those which appear in other casebooks. Major cases may occupy six to eight pages, minor cases may be reprinted in half a page or so. The book also includes more non-case excerpts than most casebooks. There are lengthy passages from the "Federalist Papers" and from leading works on constitutional history and constitutional theory. These passages are very effectively integrated into a narrative written by one or another of the editors. The result is a set of purposeful, accessible, and well documented essays on each of the key areas of constitutional law. I would also highlight the editors' effective use of "questions." The questions themselves are fairly typical law school inquiries, but CONSTITUTIONAL LAW does a better job than other casebooks of transforming questions into constructive stepping stones to deeper understanding. Typically, questions are posed as part of an ongoing discussion, rather than appearing at the end of the chapter with little apparent purpose other than to leave the average student perplexed and perhaps alienated. Almost always, questions are followed by additional discussion or additional reprinted material which allows the reader to begin to formulate an answer or opinion. Of course, questions beget answers which beget new questions. At the same time, CONSTITUTIONAL LAW avoids conveying any sense that the whole process is a meaningless game. It takes its own questions seriously and in doing so succeeds in engaging the reader in the challenging process of uncovering the implicit assumptions in legal arguments, articulating attainable normative goals, marshalling relevant factual data, and crafting defensible policy solutions to constitutional problems. Finally, I would commend the simple but important decision that someone made to present the text of the book in type which is large enough to read without a magnifying glass. One response to the explosive growth of cases and other primary materials has been to publish new editions of existing casebooks with thinner pages, smaller type, more lines per inch, more reliance on footnotes, or some combination of the above. Many casebooks have become unpleasant to read in a purely physical sense. CONSTITUTIONAL LAW is every bit as rigorous and substantive as the best of the existing casebooks, but, unlike many of them, it is also inviting to open and read. The print is relatively large, the titles of cases and other headings stand out clearly, and apart from necessary footnotes (that is, those reprinted from the cases themselves), footnotes are avoided and the types of material that may be relegated to footnotes in other casebooks are integrated into the main text. Speaking as someone who is rather fond of footnotes, I found it most relaxing to be able to follow the main narrative without undue interruption. My guess is that decisions about type size and format have contributed in no small measure to the popularity of the book. In sum, CONSTITUTIONAL LAW is an excellent casebook. From the perspective of those who teach undergraduate constitutional law, it does have two possible drawbacks. First, it is a LAW SCHOOL casebook, that is, it is designed to educate and socialize those who will enter the legal profession, and in this sense it may be more narrowly focused on the development of analytical skills than some instructors would prefer. Second, at 1700-plus pages, it is a long book and certainly includes far more material than could possibly be covered in a year-long course, let alone one restricted to a single quarter or semester. Today, however, most other law school casebooks -- and even many undergraduate casebooks -- are of comparable length. CONSTITUTIONAL LAW is a superb example of its genre and merits a look by anyone who teaches a constitutional law course. References Gunther, Gerald. INDIVIDUAL RIGHTS IN CONSTITUTIONAL LAW, 5th Ed. Westbury, NY: Foundation Press, 1991. Lockhart, William B., Yale Kamisar, Jesse H. Choper, and Steven H. Shiffrin. CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHTS AND LIBERTIES, 7th Ed. St. Paul, MN: West Publishing, 1991.

    Read More

    Product Details

    ISBN-13:
    9780735520165
    Publisher:
    Wolters Kluwer Law & Business
    Publication date:
    03/28/2001
    Edition description:
    Older Edition
    Pages:
    1619
    Product dimensions:
    7.40(w) x 10.18(h) x 2.46(d)

    Customer Reviews

    Average Review:

    Write a Review

    and post it to your social network

         

    Most Helpful Customer Reviews

    See all customer reviews >