Criticism and Truth: On Method in Literary Studies

by Jonathan Kramnick

Overview

A defense and celebration of the discipline of literary studies and its most distinctive practice—close reading.

Does literary criticism offer truths about the world? In Criticism and Truth, Jonathan Kramnick offers a new and surprising account of criticism’s power by zeroing in on its singular method: close reading. Long recognized as the distinctive technique of literary studies, close reading is the critic’s way of pursuing arguments and advancing knowledge, as well as the primary skill taught in the English major. But it is also more than that—a creative, immersive, and transformative writing practice that fosters a unique kind of engagement with the world. Drawing on the rich and varied landscape of contemporary criticism, Kramnick changes how we think about the basic tools of literary analysis, including the art of in-text quotation, summary, and other reading methods, helping us to see them as an invaluable form of humanistic expertise. Criticism and Truth is a call to arms, making a powerful case for the necessity of both literature and criticism within a multidisciplinary university.

As the humanities fight for survival in contemporary higher education, the study of literature doesn’t need more plans for reform. Rather, it needs a defense of the work already being done and an account of why it should flourish. This is what Criticism and Truth offers, in vivid and portable form.

Product Details

ISBN-13:	9780226830537
Publisher:	University of Chicago Press
Publication date:	12/04/2023
Series:	Thinking Literature
Edition description:	First Edition
Pages:	144
Product dimensions:	5.50(w) x 8.50(h) x 0.50(d)

About the Author

Jonathan Kramnick is the Maynard Mack Professor of English and director of the Lewis Walpole Library at Yale University. He is the author of Making the English Canon, Actions and Objects from Hobbes to Richardson, and Paper Minds, the latter also published by the University of Chicago Press.

Table of Contents

Preface

Introduction: Craft Knowledge

Chapter 1: Method Talk

Chapter 2: Close Reading

Chapter 3: Skilled Practice

Chapter 4: Interpretation and Creativity

Chapter 5: Verification

Coda: Public Criticism for a Public Humanities

Acknowledgments

Notes

Index

Editorial Reviews

"An erudite, closely argued and engaging essay, even something of a tract for the times."

PN Review

Criticism and Truth doesn’t just declare a truce in the method wars: it shows that our squabbling has obscured the deeper truth of a shared disciplinary craft. Lavishing his own considerable analytic gifts on the unfairly unloved genre of contemporary criticism, Kramnick beautifully describes—for what feels like the first time—what literary scholars do, and why their everyday virtuosity matters.

Rutgers University David Kurnick

"Kramnick’s central claim in Criticism and Truth is that close reading, the signature method of literary criticism, is not a form of reading but a form of writing. Unlike other contributions to state-of-the-field debates, he focuses not on methods of reading or classroom practice, but on the method of academic scholarship. It is the published research, he says, that is the true lifeblood of the discipline."

The Point magazine

Here is the study of literary critical method we needed—a slim volume capable of displacing shelves of manifestos on the future of the discipline. What do literary critics know, and how do they know it? Criticism and Truth grounds our distinctive epistemology in everyday practices—how we quote and paraphrase our objects of study, share the medium of language with them, and build plot summaries. It captures the brilliance of literary critics everywhere, yet only Jonathan Kramnick could have written this gemlike book.

coauthor of "The Teaching Archive" Rachel Sagner Buurma

Animated by ardency and urgency, written in pellucid prose, argued with finesse and flair, Criticism and Truth is both beautiful and true. It persuades even as it galvanizes. Kramnick’s taut, elegant book should be read widely, its moral passion a beacon for all of us who care about the fate of literature and the humanities.

author of "The Anti-Romantic Child" and "The Criti Priscilla Gilman

"Within that field of inquiry, Kramnick’s is a vital book indeed, in the senses of both lively and necessary. . . . The book’s most vital respondents will ultimately be those emergent and future scholars for whose sake, principally, it aims to describe and celebrate and defend what we do as scholars of literature. But Criticism and Truth is also a clarion call to senior scholars to join in that work."

Yale Review - Paul Saint-Amour

"The authorʼs meticulous analysis offers an eye-opening take on literary criticism as a creative process . . . English scholars will want to take a look."

Publishers Weekly

"[A] significant new entrant in the ongoing effort to characterize and defend the value of literary study . . . Kramnick offers a newfound respect for the everyday practices of criticism."

Genre

"[Kramnick] expresses alarm at the prospects of academic literary criticism’s continued existence as a recognized field of study within the contemporary university. . . . Articulating the place of literature in 'collective human flourishing'—or specifying what distinguishes literature from other kinds of written language, for that matter— falls outside Kramnick’s project at hand. Bracketing such questions. . . gives the book its quality of extreme concentration and lucidity in the pursuit of the common element in thriving academic literary criticism: the element that must be preserved, lest the whole discipline disappear. . . . [Criticism and Truth] merits attention beyond its field."
 

Inside Higher Education - Scott McLemee

In a highly skilled performance of his own, Kramnick discloses the artistry and creativity embedded in routine acts of close reading. Such methodological reflection is long overdue and marks an important step toward making literary critics' tacit values and abilities intelligible to themselves.

University of Minnesota Elaine Auyoung

"Criticism and Truth comes out swinging. . . . asserting in its final pages that 'the study of literature … keeps alive values of truth, justice, and beauty that support collective flourishing'. A reader couldn’t ask for a clearer defence. . . . Kramnick explains how close reading. . . is different from other disciplines, and how such close attention - not to what a reader hopes or believes a work says, but to what it is actually saying - breeds rigour and objectivity."

Times Literary Supplement

"[Kramnick] expresses alarm at the prospects of academic literary criticism's continued existence as a recognized field of study within the contemporary university. . . . Articulating the place of literature in 'collective human flourishing'--or specifying what distinguishes literature from other kinds of written language, for that matter-- falls outside Kramnick's project at hand. Bracketing such questions. . . gives the book its quality of extreme concentration and lucidity in the pursuit of the common element in thriving academic literary criticism: the element that must be preserved, lest the whole discipline disappear. . . . [Criticism and Truth] merits attention beyond its field."
--Scott McLemee "Inside Higher Education"

"The authorʼs meticulous analysis offers an eye-opening take on literary criticism as a creative process . . . English scholars will want to take a look."-- "Publishers Weekly"

"Criticism and Truth doesn't just declare a truce in the method wars: it shows that our squabbling has obscured the deeper truth of a shared disciplinary craft. Lavishing his own considerable analytic gifts on the unfairly unloved genre of contemporary criticism, Kramnick beautifully describes--for what feels like the first time--what literary scholars do, and why their everyday virtuosity matters."-- "David Kurnick, Rutgers University"

"Animated by ardency and urgency, written in pellucid prose, argued with finesse and flair, Criticism and Truth is both beautiful and true. It persuades even as it galvanizes. Kramnick's taut, elegant book should be read widely, its moral passion a beacon for all of us who care about the fate of literature and the humanities."-- "Priscilla Gilman, author of "The Anti-Romantic Child" and "The Critic's Daughter""

"Here is the study of literary critical method we needed--a slim volume capable of displacing shelves of manifestos on the future of the discipline. What do literary critics know, and how do they know it? Criticism and Truth grounds our distinctive epistemology in everyday practices--how we quote and paraphrase our objects of study, share the medium of language with them, and build plot summaries. It captures the brilliance of literary critics everywhere, yet only Jonathan Kramnick could have written this gemlike book."-- "Rachel Sagner Buurma, coauthor of "The Teaching Archive""

"In a highly skilled performance of his own, Kramnick discloses the artistry and creativity embedded in routine acts of close reading. Such methodological reflection is long overdue and marks an important step toward making literary critics' tacit values and abilities intelligible to themselves."-- "Elaine Auyoung, University of Minnesota"

From the Publisher