- Shopping Bag ( 0 items )
An unsubtle and old-fashioned exploration of homophobia.
The football team is grossed out when Alan, flamboyantly effeminate, transfers to their high school (cue a relentless stream of homophobic jokes). The novel's narrator, varsity player Adonis, battling a negative body image from chubbier days, is no exception. His homophobia is nurtured by his firefighter dad and frowned on by his teacher mom and sister Jeannie, the school's Fashion Club VP and Alan's friend. That Alan, the club's sole male, is its president goes unnoticed; gender bias is beyond the one-issue scope. Alan's dad is an Army colonel and clueless bigot. Manliness here equals homophobia; the one tolerant male adult is Adonis' hippie, ponytailed English teacher. Adonis' dilemma propels the action. (Oddly, he's never teased about his name). Melody, the girl he's pursuing, believes, approvingly, that Adonis belongs to the pro-Alan faction. Adonis' football-team peers will reject him unless he treats Alan with ridicule and contempt. Chief among these one-dimensional stereotypes is Alan—kind, noble and the dullest drag queen ever to wear dresses and lipstick. Is he gay, transsexual, cross-dressing or questioning? We're never told. Nuanced distinctions of character don't exist in this curiously retro world in which no one watches Glee and gays in the military aren't on anyone's radar.
Weighed down by earnest good intentions, this tale of high-school homophobia falls flat. (Fiction. 12 & up)
Posted July 13, 2011
Before I start writing this review, I should add that I am a girl that grew up with a gay uncle and an anti-gay step father so I have seen both "sides" of the gay "issue". I think that this is a story every teenage boy should read because not only is a well written story but a lesson that all boys should learn if not understand. Now, I know that in a perfect world this book would become famous and all boys would read it and suddenly a generation of accepting people would emerge from this. But lets be realistic for a moment, thats not going to happen. All that I can hope that you (most likely a boy I hope) take from this is that they are not inferior to you in anyway. Or any other thing like that. Please, read this book for yourself if not anyone else, you will be a more accepting, advanced man versus all of you brainless jock friends.
3 out of 3 people found this review helpful.Was this review helpful? Yes NoThank you for your feedback. Report this reviewThank you, this review has been flagged.
Posted September 23, 2011
Adonis is a popular football player with an attractive girlfriend. That's what he considers normal - until he meets Alan. Alan is the new kid, and it is obvious from the start that he is different. It turns out that Alan is popular with the girls but in a different way. He has a keen interest in fashion and all things feminine. When Adonis's sister and all of her friends create an official high school Fashion Club, Alan becomes a loyal member. The girls accept him with open arms, and with their encouragement, Alan feels comfortable enough to reveal his true self. Alan has been the victim of taunts and teasing since the day he arrived, but the harassment escalates when he shows up one morning wearing bright, red lipstick. Adonis is shocked and confused that Alan would be so bold. He observes from a distance as his fellow football players make life miserable for Alan. Life becomes a delicate balancing act for Adonis as he tries to let his guy friends think he despises Alan as much as they do, while at the same time attempting to please his girlfriend and his sister, who are staunch defenders of Alan's right to display his transgender lifestyle. The day Alan appears at school wearing a dress, the administration makes contact with his father. Finding no support at home, Alan moves out and the girls step up to offer him a place to stay along with their continued support. Although Adonis tries to remain on neutral ground about the whole situation, he finds his feelings changing. When he learns about a plan to humiliate Alan, Adonis fears he will need to take a stand on one side or the other. Paul Volponi's novels are always a success with my students, and CROSSING LINES is sure to be popular, too. Bullying, especially when it involves gay and transgender topics, is an increasing problem with teens today. CROSSING LINES will help those struggling with their own sexual identity and how it frequently changes relationships. The story will also help teens struggling with how to interact with fellow students whose lifestyles differ from their own. I'm very excited to have this one in my classroom collection.
1 out of 1 people found this review helpful.Was this review helpful? Yes NoThank you for your feedback. Report this reviewThank you, this review has been flagged.
Posted December 9, 2013
This was an excellent book that I read for a project in English. It is about a boy named Adonis who is a high school jock football player with everything going right. He has a pretty girlfriend, he is popular with the guys and is starting for his second year on the football team, except for one thing. There is a guy named Alan who is a homosexual and is constantly expressing it, whether it be his choice in color of lipstick, the dresses and blouses he wears, his interest in the fashion club or his long, feminine blonde hair. Adonis' teammates and friends are constantly teasing Alan and giving him a hard time, while Adonis' sister and girlfriend Melody and other members of the fashion club are open and supportive to Alan and his cause. Adonis is constantly having to balance on both sides between receiving his girlfriend's approval, and having to match his friends and teammates hate towards Alan. Throughout the story, Adonis tries to remain neutral about the whole situation until he finds out that his teammates are planning to publicly humiliate Alan in front of hundreds of people. Will Adonis do what is right and defend much hated Alan, or follow the crowd? Read the book to find out!Was this review helpful? Yes NoThank you for your feedback. Report this reviewThank you, this review has been flagged.
Posted June 23, 2011
A superb ant-bullying book. The narrator (Adonis), a macho high school football player is forced to be around Alan (the only boy in the high school fashion club who eventually dons a dress and lipstick)because he is a close friend of Adonis' sister. Adonis must keep the nastiness coming towards Alan for the sake of his football friends' approval. But when things go to far, will Adonis cross the line and come to Alan's rescue? Simply, Paul Volponi's best YA novel yet.Was this review helpful? Yes NoThank you for your feedback. Report this reviewThank you, this review has been flagged.