Didn't like it.
I'm really, really sad to have to give Carrie Ryan a two on one of her books because I just loved THE FOREST OF HANDS AND TEETH, but I found myself struggling to get through the companion. For many of reasons I did not like this book, one, being that Gabry was a character I felt any hope towards. Who doesn't love the strong heroin? and it seemed that all Gabry could say or think was how she messed everything up, everything's her fault, ect. Major pity party... I never was able to feel the emotions of the character and she seemed quite ditsy to be honest. Secondly, I didn't like the potential romances. At first glance, I wanted to punch Catcher for bringing Gabry into trouble and then kissing her, after he's known her for his whole life. He seemed like a major jerk right off the bat. As for Elias, he was okay, I did like him more than Catcher. But he was a little too touchy-feely and grabby for just meeting Gabry, a stranger. Third, the adventure was boring! I was so tired of reading this book, I was skimming over the last 20 pages, so I really don't know how it ended. I'm trying to find it online somewhere.... no luck so far. Anyway, the adventure was also a little boring in THE FOREST OF HANDS AND TEETH, but the companion was about 3 times worse. There was nothing to be excited about. I had no idea why they were on this mission in the first place. Four, It was very sad to see Mary as an old lady and how she never found anyone. I also found it odd that she never mention Travis to her "daughter" but told her about everything else. I was waiting for when it would come up, but never did. Five, Ryan's writing style got very old to me by the time I had read about 700 pages of her writing (both books put together). She always had the same, "I wanted to...." and you know she's going to say next what she did instead and how she felt about it. This is an entire paragraph in itself. I was so tired of hearing about how everyone's life in the Forest was due to dooms day and depression and the Unconsecrated. What's the point of writing a set of three companion books when there is no light at the end? Every page of the book is talking about how to question life and what's next, ect. Not much fun for a teen like me. She also had the exact same plot technique of 1) layout 2) start of story 3) boring nothingness...filler of space 4) falling of character, giving up hope 5) something good happens to character, fills her with hope and energy 6) tragedy occurs, climax, testing of strength! 7) falling actions, everyone dies/ leaves her 8) main character left all alone. All that's gained is wisdom, strength, and knowledge. So it was very similar to F.O.H.A.T. Now, for the positives (!): I do like Ryan's descriptions, they're very nice and like you're living out the story. I was also about to connect a little more with Gabry since she seemed more like the typical teenager than Mary (besides the annoying, "I ruin everything, I can't do this, I'm not strong enough" talk). Since I extremely loved FOREST OF HANDS AND TEETH, I would recommend to just sticking with that, don't read this, so you don't lose what you first loved about FOREST.
1 out of 2 people found this review helpful.
Was this review helpful? Yes NoThank you for your feedback.
Report this reviewThank you, this review has been flagged.