Desiring Arabs / Edition 1

Hardcover (Print)
Used and New from Other Sellers
Used and New from Other Sellers
from $22.50
Usually ships in 1-2 business days
(Save 43%)
Other sellers (Hardcover)
  • All (7) from $22.50   
  • New (4) from $33.60   
  • Used (3) from $22.50   

Editorial Reviews

Financial Times
In Desiring Arabs, [Edward] Said’s disciple Joseph A. Massad corroborates his mentor’s thesis that orientalist writing was racist and dehumanizing. Said came up short, argues Massad, only in not recognizing how far that stereotype-laden discourse in the west also helped shape Arab intellectual writing itself, especially on Arab sexual identities. . . . Massad, a controversial professor at Columbia University, brilliantly goes on to trace the legacy of this racist, internalized, orientalist discourse up to the present.”

— John R. Bradley

Jordan Times
A modern Arab intellectual history, but with many a groundbreaking and provocative twist. In a sense, it takes up where Edward Said left off, expanding the analysis of Orientalism into new, uncharted and previously concealed territory to reveal its influence 'in shaping the Arabs' own perception of themselves and each other.—Sally Bland, Jordan Times

— Sally Bland

Middle East Report
A pioneering work on a very timely yet frustratingly neglected topic. . . . I know of no other study that can even begin to compare with the detail and scope of [this] work.—Khaled El-Rouayheb, Middle East Report

— Khaled El-Rouayheb

The Guide
Fascinating and controversial.

— Bill Andriette

Arab Studies Journal
Massad compels us to think creatively about alternatives to our narcissistic subsuming other people's sexual modes of being under ours. . . . This truly monumental book is a corrective to Michel Foucault’s History of Sexuality that inexplicably omitted the role played by the cultural effects of colonial systems on conceptions and constructions of sexuality. . . . Desiring Arabs is an epoch-making book.—Marnia Lazreg, Arab Studies Journal

— Marnia Lazreg

Journal of Gender Studies
An impressive project that ventures into uncharted territory and can be read as a complement to both Edward Said’s Orientalism and Michel Foucault’s work on sexuality. . . . An audacious intellectual journey. . . . A seminal contribution to a number of fields, including Middle East Studies, Sexuality and Queer Studies, Arab intellectual history, and Orientalist Studies.”

— Samia Mehrez

Journal of Arabic Literature
[The book] captivates the reader and not only because it deals with sexuality in Arab discourse in the last two centuries. It is a brilliant text with a breadth of knowledge and sophisticated analytical techniques. . . . Massad's interdisciplinary approach, dense prose, impeccable research, and above all the thought-provoking issues he raises make his book a scholarly landmark.”

— Ferial J. Ghazoul

Against the Current
Desiring Arabs is an important resource for serious students of sexualities in the Arab world. . . . Above all, the book does a service to scholarship comparable to what Kate Millett did in Sexual Politics or Dennis Altman in Homosexual Oppression and Liberation.

— Peter Drucker

Al-Ahram Weekly
Massad's frontal assault on the gay lib crusade aimed at the Muslim world is a defiant call to resist the Orientalist project.

— Eric Walberg

Talal Asad

“This is a remarkable book, at once a fascinating history of ideas and a brilliantly analyzed case study of cultural imperialism. There are many excellent studies of Western representations of Arab and Muslim peoples, but there is nothing comparable on the way the latter have responded to the former. With impressive learning and sharp wit Massad describes the internalization of European conceptions of the human among Arab intellectuals, both nationalist and Islamist, since the nineteenth century. His account of their concern to re-orient sexual and civilizational desires (both being closely intertwined in the European imagination) is quite stunning. Anyone interested in the modernization of Middle Eastern culture cannot afford to miss this book—nor, for that matter can scholars seriously engaged in postcolonial research or in lesbian and gay studies.”

Gayatri Chakravorty Spivak

“This compendious study of the discursive production of an Arab sexuality incorporates new readings of the modernity/tradition debates that go well beyond a specifically Arab context, and moves all the way from historical research into the history of literature and literary criticism. Even as it supplements Edward Said’s work by its consideration of Arab Orientalism, Desiring Arabs boldly looks forward to an unscripted future.”

Joan W. Scott

“Massad refuses both the essentialized oppositions between Arab and Western civilization and the all-embracing universalism offered in the name of human rights. Instead he insists that representations of Arab sexuality must be understood historically, as the varied and conflicting products of exchanges between Arab and Orientalist writers. This is an inspired and erudite intellectual history, complex, nuanced, critical, and deeply engaged.”

Anton Shammas

“Desiring Arabs is an elaborate, relentless, and unabashed critique of the way in which Arab culture has dealt with the tropes and constructs of sexual deviances since the emergence of the Arab Nahdah, or Renaissance, in the middle of the nineteenth century. It is bound to be received by readers as one of the most interesting and equally illuminating commentaries on modern Arab culture to be published in the past decade. “--Anton Shammas, author of Arabesques
 

Financial Times - John R. Bradley

“In Desiring Arabs, [Edward] Said’s disciple Joseph A. Massad corroborates his mentor’s thesis that orientalist writing was racist and dehumanizing. Said came up short, argues Massad, only in not recognizing how far that stereotype-laden discourse in the west also helped shape Arab intellectual writing itself, especially on Arab sexual identities. . . . Massad, a controversial professor at Columbia University, brilliantly goes on to trace the legacy of this racist, internalized, orientalist discourse up to the present.”

Jordan Times - Sally Bland

"A modern Arab intellectual history, but with many a groundbreaking and provocative twist. In a sense, it takes up where Edward Said left off, expanding the analysis of Orientalism into new, uncharted and previously concealed territory to reveal its influence 'in shaping the Arabs' own perception of themselves and each other.'"—Sally Bland, Jordan Times
Middle East Report - Khaled El-Rouayheb

"A pioneering work on a very timely yet frustratingly neglected topic. . . . I know of no other study that can even begin to compare with the detail and scope of [this] work."--Khaled El-Rouayheb, Middle East Report
The Guide - Bill Andriette

"Fascinating and controversial."
Arab Studies Journal - Marnia Lazreg

“Massad compels us to think creatively about alternatives to our narcissistic subsuming other people's sexual modes of being under ours. . . . This truly monumental book is a corrective to Michel Foucault’s History of Sexuality that inexplicably omitted the role played by the cultural effects of colonial systems on conceptions and constructions of sexuality. . . . Desiring Arabs is an epoch-making book.”--Marnia Lazreg, Arab Studies Journal
Journal of Gender Studies - Samia Mehrez

“An impressive project that ventures into uncharted territory and can be read as a complement to both Edward Said’s Orientalism and Michel Foucault’s work on sexuality. . . . An audacious intellectual journey. . . . A seminal contribution to a number of fields, including Middle East Studies, Sexuality and Queer Studies, Arab intellectual history, and Orientalist Studies.”
Journal of Arabic Literature - Ferial J. Ghazoul

“[The book] captivates the reader and not only because it deals with sexuality in Arab discourse in the last two centuries. It is a brilliant text with a breadth of knowledge and sophisticated analytical techniques. . . . Massad's interdisciplinary approach, dense prose, impeccable research, and above all the thought-provoking issues he raises make his book a scholarly landmark.”
Against the Current - Peter Drucker

"Desiring Arabs is an important resource for serious students of sexualities in the Arab world. . . . Above all, the book does a service to scholarship comparable to what Kate Millett did in Sexual Politics or Dennis Altman in Homosexual Oppression and Liberation."
Al-Ahram Weekly - Eric Walberg

"Massad's frontal assault on the gay lib crusade aimed at the Muslim world is a defiant call to resist the Orientalist project."
Read More Show Less

Product Details

  • ISBN-13: 9780226509587
  • Publisher: University of Chicago Press
  • Publication date: 6/15/2007
  • Edition description: New Edition
  • Edition number: 1
  • Pages: 472
  • Product dimensions: 6.00 (w) x 9.00 (h) x 1.20 (d)

Read an Excerpt

Desiring Arabs
By JOSEPH A. MASSAD
The University of Chicago Press Copyright © 2007 The University of Chicago
All right reserved.

ISBN: 978-0-226-50958-7



Chapter One Anxiety in Civilization

Since the Arab "renaissance" emerged in the mid- nineteenth century, thousands of medieval manuscripts dating back to the seventh through the fourteenth centuries have been published in the Arab world, in addition to scores of studies and analyses of that period of Arab history. European Orientalist scholarship, as discussed in the introduction, showed initial interest in these texts and began to publish them and comment on them in European languages. The emergent Arab intelligentsia in the nineteenth century took upon itself the revival and modernization of the Arabic language, which was seen to have also "degraded" under Ottoman repression. This intellectual trend combined with (some would say, produced) a nascent Arab nationalism opposed to Ottoman rule that appeared during the last decades of the century and took upon itself the task of uncovering the cultural heritage of the Arabs of yesteryear as a foundation for the Arabs of the present.

This revival ranged from studies in the literary production of the past, to theological and jurisprudential studies, to historical, scientific, and sociological treatises. The emergent intelligentsia sought the past of the Arabs as a basis for their modern future by repudiating the more recent traditions that developed under Ottoman rule, seen through the eyes of the emergent nationalism as foreign and "degraded" in character. It was by repudiating the more recent past and by reviving the ancient past that the Arabs of the present could chart their project for modern life. These intellectual trends are reminiscent of European modernity, which sought to adopt "its" ancient Greco-Roman heritage and repudiate its Christian Middle Ages. The "revival" of this ancient past is evident in treatises written on politics, economics, and religion, as it is in treatises written on women's liberation and society at large. To the casual observer, with few notable exceptions, there was little in these voluminous accounts dedicated to the sexual life of the ancient Arabs or to the place of sex in what increasingly came to be known as a coherent category called "Islam." In fact, important debates on sex and desire did exist, but rarely on their own. They were mostly embedded in discussions of literature and turath more generally. There seems to be little familiarity in the Arabic or English secondary literature of these debates, much less any examination of them.

While predominant Orientalist representations of the modern Arab world and Islam portray them as constituted by a repressive sexual ideology and an even more repressive sexual culture that revels in the oppression of women and bans any discussion of sex, this chapter and the next will discuss a century-long rich Arab intellectual debate about sex in the past of the Arabs and its implications for the present. The debate has many nuances and ideological turns, is rich in argument and material, and has engaged some of the important intellectual minds of the modern Arab world. The aim of these chapters is both to retrieve from scholarly obscurity an archive of modern writings on the classical history of the Arabs that made use of medieval documents to paint a picture of the life of the ancients, their cultural production, desires, and sexual practices, and also to explore the way that these writings were deployed in the creation of a viable tradition for Arab modernity.

Intellectuals writing about the sexual life of the medieval Arab world, as we will see, would come from different disciplines, different parts of the Arab world, and different ideological backgrounds. They found medieval documents useful for many different political and intellectual projects within which they would deploy their discussions of sex and desire. Whether liberal educators, historians committed to sexual liberation, Arab nationalists, radical secularists, psychoanalytic literary critics, Marxists, feminists, or Islamists, they would all believe that there were lessons to be learned from the sexual history of the Arabs of the past. Common to all of them is a commitment to a civilizational inheritance whose content must be uncovered. Much of the analysis employed in the debate is fully informed by late nineteenth-century European notions of civilization and culture and subsidiary concepts like progress, regression, evolution, degeneration, decadence, renaissance, ascent, decline, as well as the statistical language of norms and deviations. In the debates that follow, we will see how these notions are introduced as a hermeneutical grid to interpret and produce turath, which functions as both a repository of civilizational documents and a moral code. For some of our authors, these two aspects of turath may be separable while to others they may not be. The question that arises for many of them, however, is whether Arab civilization itself can survive the rupture between the two meanings of turath in the modern period.

Early Beginnings

At the end of the nineteenth century and in the context of a declining Ottoman Empire and surging Turkish nationalism, the Arab Renaissance was in full swing, accompanied with the early stirrings of anti-Ottoman Arab nationalism. The new renaissance of Arab knowledge production involved an increased acquaintance with European Orientalist thought and the construction of the Arab within it. In the course of writing classical and medieval Arab history, these modern historians encountered an ancient Arab society with different sexual mores and practices that were difficult to assimilate into a modern Arab nationalist project informed by European notions of progress and modernization and a Victorian sexual ethic. Some of the important questions being theorized dealt with new concepts that did not exist before and that were being deployed in the excavation of history. In addition to tamaddun and hadarah (both words mean "civilization"; tamaddun was coined first but was later frequently replaced by hadarah) and turath (heritage), there were other related European concepts that informed these endeavors and that proliferated, including thaqafah (culture), inhilal (degeneration), inhitat (decadence or degradation), taqaddum (progress), ta'akhkhur (backwardness), jins (sex), and shudhudh (deviance), among others. What was at stake in this historical excavation was the safeguarding of the heritage of Arab civilization for future generations. The use of European notions on which to base these efforts at excavating Arab-Islamic national heritage did not seem contradictory or problematic to our authors. Rather, they were seen as neutral scientific tools and concepts that could be fully integrated into their modernist project.

The first modern comprehensive history of Arabic literature from the pre-Islamic period to the early twentieth century was written by the famed German Orientalist Carl Brockelmann (1868-1956). Brockelmann published the first volume of his Geschichte der arabischen Litteratur in 1898 (the second in 1902) and the last one in 1948. These volumes would be translated to Arabic in the early 1960s, with more volumes published in the 1970s. The entire collection would be reprinted and republished in 1993 in Cairo. Brockelmann's Herculean efforts, however, were supplemented by other Orientalist scholars who did not have his erudition, including the earlier work of F. F. Arbuthnot's Arabic Authors (1890), and later works like Clement Huart's Literature Arabe (1902), Italo Pizzi's Litteratura Araba (1903), or Reynold A. Nicholson's A Literary History of the Arabs (1907). Adam Mez's important study Die Renaissance des Islams found by his bedside upon his death in 1917 was only published posthumously in 1922. All of these books would rely on the already published volumes by Brockelmann. In fact Brockelmann himself would republish his books updated with appendices and citing works by Orientalist and Arab scholars published in the interim.

In these important surveys, Orientalist scholars addressed not only the literary writings of the Arabs but also described their sexual desires and the way these were expressed in poetry and prose, as well as the national origins of such desires and practices. In his entry on the poet Abu Nuwas, for example, Brockelmann wrote of the poet's "bawdy" (mujun) poetry but did not specify the love of boys. Nicholson commented that "the scenes of luxurious dissipation and refined debauchery which [the bawdy poets] describe show us, indeed, that Persian culture was not an unalloyed blessing to the Arabs any more than the arts of Greece to the Romans." Mez would dedicate a chapter to the "Manners and Morals" of the medieval Arabs, addressing the "pervasive" nature of pederasty among poets from the fourth to the tenth century A.H. (tenth to sixteenth century A.D.), as well as in "circles high and low." H. A. R. Gibb, whose book on Arabic literature appeared in 1926, would liken the Abbasid poet Abu Nuwas to Heine: "He is at his happiest in his wine songs, but his elegies, love poems, and satires, though often containing much both in subject and sentiment that offends our taste, are little inferior."

In this vein, a number of classical and medieval political and literary figures and events were to cause as much anxiety to modern Arabs as they had to European Orientalists before them. Upon encountering historical material about the sexual life of the Abbasid period, the question of civilization and turath became immediately intertwined with sexual morality. Thus any and all attempts to recover the Abbasid period, generally considered the golden age of Arab-Islamic civilization and knowledge production, had to confront the sexual question, read under the sign of morality. The Abbasid poet Abu Nuwas became particularly a focus, if not a cause, of such anxiety, on account of his explicit poetry that detailed sexual desires and practices deemed immoral. The gaze of Arab historians was squarely fixed on European judgment of their civilization, as that modern European concept was always posited in a comparative framework. European thinkers imagined the non-European world either in developmentalist terms, as representing an earlier stage of Europe, the childhood of Europe itself, which European colonialism would shepherd to adult maturity, thus duplicating if not replicating and reproducing Europe on a global scale, or as representing a radical alterity that can only be bridged, if at all, by a comprehensive overhauling of these "civilizations" by, or their utter subjugation to, European supremacy. Arab thinkers, like anticolonial thinkers elsewhere, overcome by a narcissistic injury inflicted by either of these judgments, and intent on building a new national project, begged to differ.

Their efforts coincided with the fledgling European colonial presence in the Arab world-the French had colonized Algeria in 1830 and the British occupied Egypt in 1882. It was with this background that the following exchange between two writers, one Arab (Egyptian), one French, offers a useful introduction into the complex deployment of sexuality in negotiations around questions of religious and, increasingly, national and cultural identity-in short, about civilizational stature. In 1894, an unknown Qasim Amin wrote his first book Les Égyptiens, in French, in response to an Orientalist account written by one M. Le Duc D'Harcourt about Egypt and Islam. Amin was scandalized by D'Harcourt's claim that

Islam encourages pleasures and enjoyment of all that we harbor in our hearts of emotions and yearnings, except for gluttony and voraciousness. He [D'Harcourt] spoke aplenty of lust, obscenity, and degeneration without ever telling us where he saw such things. While we know that an Oriental who visits Europe for the first time returns from it, undoubtedly enchanted by the different types of beauty that such a mighty civilization diffuses across its lands, such admiration, however, is always mixed with a sense of repulsion that the conditions of degenerating morals, degeneration, and perdition are widespread everywhere-just as when a European visits a Muslim country, often complains of a lack in entertainment venues.

If this were not enough to convince his French readers, a horrified Amin unequivocally asserted to his European audience that "what is incredible is that [a Muslim man] does not see in sexual pleasure but a silly satisfaction of one of the bodily needs, so much so that all the tricks of love that ingenious [European] lovers innovated and of which Occidentals are enamored, have no effect on the souls of chaste Muslims. As I have reached this critical point, I should complete the picture by stating that even the most debauched Muslim man would never surrender to obscenity completely; he rather maintains an amount of bashfulness that always saves him from sinking to the bottom." This is to be contrasted with men in Europe, as "there is a large number of men who have no concerns but the enjoyment of everything in all manners. Indeed, some of them boast about how much they have seen and done, so much so that there is no longer anything that can excite their emotions. In addition to these bored men, there are those who are pleasure-mad who do not get satiated, in addition to the depraved and the debauched as well as those women who no longer desire to continue to perform the task of bearing children and prefer to shine in society." Amin's defensive posture against Orientalist representations of Arab and Muslim sexual desires is not unlike that of many European women writers from Mary Wollstonecraft onward, who took up defensive postures against the claims that women had larger sexual appetites than men and reversed the charge in an attempt to fend off sexist attacks.

Amin moved on to publish the first major treatise in Arabic calling for women's liberation in 1899. Reversing Orientalist generalizations and applying them to Europeans, however, would become one of the most effective weapons used by Arab and Muslim writers in response to continuing Orientalist accounts throughout the twentieth century. But unlike Amin's discussion of the sexual desires and conduct of contemporary Arabs and Muslims, the next century would witness a debate not necessarily about the sexual life of contemporary Arabs (although occasionally it would), but mainly about the sexual life of the ancient Arabs. Clearly, the discussion of the past had many implications for the present of which our writers were conscious. Still, while d'Harcourt failed to incite discourse about the sexual life of modern Arabs, Amin's response in French notwithstanding, a century would pass before a new incitement would interrupt the flow of debates about the sexual life of the ancient Arabs and shift it to a discussion of the sexual life of moderns. The new inciters, as we will see in chapter 3, would be a group of Western missionaries and their local followers attempting to disseminate their message of sexual identities, and a surging Islamism intent on constricting social and sexual life.

Pedagogy of the Repressed

Qasim Amin's reaction did not dictate subsequent discussions of sex in modern Arab intellectual history. The ensuing debates centered on a number of themes, paramount among which were the pedagogical role that the past would play in the present, the role of the aesthetic versus the role of religious and social morality, and the nature of audiences and readerships of belles lettres. The debate would encompass questions about what aspects of the past should be emulated and what lessons learned. Just as important, the debate would address questions about what aspects of the past should be condemned or discussed at all and which aspects never to be emulated. The implication of these questions was civilizational in scale, as what was included in the archive of Arab heritage would reflect immediately on the stature of Arab civilization. The initiation of the Arabic reading public to these debates would begin through the pathbreaking books of the important Lebanese writer and publisher Jurji Zaydan. Zaydan (1861-1914), a central figure of the Arab Renaissance (he belonged to the second generation of Nahdah thinkers), not only wrote literary history but also many popular novels that were fictionalized yet well-researched accounts about life in the classical epoch. Zaydan had started his university education in 1881 as a medical student at the Syrian Protestant College in Beirut, which was founded by New York State in 1866. The college was rechartered in 1920 as the American University of Beirut. In 1882, Zaydan was dismissed from the college for leading a student strike protesting the dismissal of one of his professors, one Professor Edwin Lewis, for referring to the works of Charles Darwin in a commencement speech (delivered on 19 July 1882), which was seen as contradicting the goals of the Protestant mission to which the American administrators of the college, in Beirut and in the United States, were committed. Darwinism, or at least its social interpretation, would have a deep impact on Zaydan's thought and work.

(Continues...)



Excerpted from Desiring Arabs by JOSEPH A. MASSAD Copyright © 2007 by The University of Chicago. Excerpted by permission.
All rights reserved. No part of this excerpt may be reproduced or reprinted without permission in writing from the publisher.
Excerpts are provided by Dial-A-Book Inc. solely for the personal use of visitors to this web site.
Read More Show Less

Table of Contents

Contents Acknowledgments....................ix
Introduction....................1
1 Anxiety in Civilization....................51
2 Remembrances of Desires Past....................99
3 Re-Orienting Desire: The Gay International and the Arab World....................160
4 Sin, Crimes, and Disease: Taxonomies of Desires Present....................191
5 Deviant Fictions....................269
6 The Truth of Fictional Desires....................335
Conclusion....................415
Works Cited....................419
Name Index....................443
Subject Index....................449
Read More Show Less

Customer Reviews

Be the first to write a review
( 0 )
Rating Distribution

5 Star

(0)

4 Star

(0)

3 Star

(0)

2 Star

(0)

1 Star

(0)

Your Rating:

Your Name: Create a Pen Name or

Barnes & Noble.com Review Rules

Our reader reviews allow you to share your comments on titles you liked, or didn't, with others. By submitting an online review, you are representing to Barnes & Noble.com that all information contained in your review is original and accurate in all respects, and that the submission of such content by you and the posting of such content by Barnes & Noble.com does not and will not violate the rights of any third party. Please follow the rules below to help ensure that your review can be posted.

Reviews by Our Customers Under the Age of 13

We highly value and respect everyone's opinion concerning the titles we offer. However, we cannot allow persons under the age of 13 to have accounts at BN.com or to post customer reviews. Please see our Terms of Use for more details.

What to exclude from your review:

Please do not write about reviews, commentary, or information posted on the product page. If you see any errors in the information on the product page, please send us an email.

Reviews should not contain any of the following:

  • - HTML tags, profanity, obscenities, vulgarities, or comments that defame anyone
  • - Time-sensitive information such as tour dates, signings, lectures, etc.
  • - Single-word reviews. Other people will read your review to discover why you liked or didn't like the title. Be descriptive.
  • - Comments focusing on the author or that may ruin the ending for others
  • - Phone numbers, addresses, URLs
  • - Pricing and availability information or alternative ordering information
  • - Advertisements or commercial solicitation

Reminder:

  • - By submitting a review, you grant to Barnes & Noble.com and its sublicensees the royalty-free, perpetual, irrevocable right and license to use the review in accordance with the Barnes & Noble.com Terms of Use.
  • - Barnes & Noble.com reserves the right not to post any review -- particularly those that do not follow the terms and conditions of these Rules. Barnes & Noble.com also reserves the right to remove any review at any time without notice.
  • - See Terms of Use for other conditions and disclaimers.
Search for Products You'd Like to Recommend

Recommend other products that relate to your review. Just search for them below and share!

Create a Pen Name

Your Pen Name is your unique identity on BN.com. It will appear on the reviews you write and other website activities. Your Pen Name cannot be edited, changed or deleted once submitted.

 
Your Pen Name can be any combination of alphanumeric characters (plus - and _), and must be at least two characters long.

Continue Anonymously

    If you find inappropriate content, please report it to Barnes & Noble
    Why is this product inappropriate?
    Comments (optional)