The Difference: How Anyone Can Prosper in Even the Toughest Timesby Jean Chatzky
There are some people who seem to possess the innate ability to rise above negative circumstances and to effortlessly ascend financial, social, and corporate ladders. See more details below
There are some people who seem to possess the innate ability to rise above negative circumstances and to effortlessly ascend financial, social, and corporate ladders.
- Crown Publishing Group
- Publication date:
- Product dimensions:
- 6.40(w) x 9.40(h) x 1.20(d)
Read an Excerpt
Meet the Neighbors
The New Rich List
Back in the early 1990s, I was—for a short while—a reporter/ researcher for Forbes magazine. During my tenure there, I got a few plum assignments, including spending one weekend fact-checking the first interview Michael Milken had granted from prison and fact-checking another on the businessman who would eventually become New York’s mayor, Michael Bloomberg. I suppose I did well enough because I was soon tapped to do a little legwork on Forbes’s lists of billionaires and richest celebrities.
The preeminent Forbes rich list, of course, is the Forbes 400: the list of the country’s four hundred wealthiest Americans. It has been around since 1982, when just three families made up 13 percent of the list. There were eleven members of the Hunt family, fourteen Rockefellers, and twenty-eight du Ponts. In 2007, on the list’s twenty-fifth anniversary, these dynastic numbers had dwindled to almost nothing. There was one Rockefeller (David Rockefeller, Sr.), one Hunt (Ray Hunt), and no du Ponts. Fifty people fell off the list completely. Forty-five were newcomers—nearly half of whom had made their money in hedge funds and private equity (like Pete Peterson of Blackstone and David Rubenstein of the Carlyle Group); the others were a mixed bag, including Frank and Lorenzo Fertitta of the Ultimate Fighting Championship, a pay-per-view fight fest.
The point, notes Columbia University researcher Wojciech Kopczuk, is not just that wealth is less concentrated (the share of wealth in the hands of the top 1 percent of Americans has fallen by half over the last eighty years). The real point is that it has moved into a whole new set of hands. Over the past twenty-five years, as these families have lost their historical positions, a whole new set of people has gotten rich. Some are entrepreneurs that have made a splash. Others are high earners on Wall Street, in corporate America, at law firms or consulting companies. Still others bought the right stocks (or were handed the right stock options) at particularly opportune times.
This is an incredibly optimistic sign—and it’s not just coming from the pages of Forbes. According to the Harrison Group, a research firm in Connecticut, three-quarters of the wealthy families in this country—and nearly all of those who qualify as upper middle class—didn’t start out wealthy. Eighty-three percent came from the middle class. They’ve accumulated wealth over fifteen years on average, which means that some of them got there in significantly less time than that. And here’s a bonus: When you look at the wealth of the pentamillionaires (the folks with $5 million or more), only one-tenth of their money came from passive investments. They made the rest of it themselves. Survey after survey I pored over while researching this book shows that a shrinking percentage of today’s wealth came through a bequest. Research from the Spectrem Group, based in Chicago, found that only 2 to 4 percent of today’s millionaires became rich that most old-fashioned way. This means you no longer have to be born into wealth. Despite the hurdles presentd by the markets in 2008, the American dream is alive and thriving—and you have the ability to achieve it.
Where Are Women in This Mix?
The tide for women is turning a bit more slowly—but it is turning, nonetheless. Remember, there are two ways for people to become wealthy: They can inherit money or they can earn it. (Some people might argue that marriage is a third proven way to get wealthy. I don’t put it on the list because it can also take your financial life in the opposite direction. Nine percent of our survey respondents blamed divorce for a negative turn in their fortunes; 8 percent blamed marriage itself.)
Interestingly, the fact that the ranks of the wealthy are more dominated these days by earned wealth rather than inherited wealth works against women. How? Think about the wealthy American families of yesteryear, the Rockefellers, Vanderbilts, Hearsts, and so on. They had children and their children had children and—on average—those children were likely to be 50 percent male and 50 percent female. So as the money passed from generation to generation, it created as many female millionaires as male ones.
When it comes to earning money, however, men still hold the advantage. Women are making strides. Some 30 to 40 percent of women outearn their spouses. More women than men are entering college and graduate-degree programs. Some researchers predict that the average woman will outearn the average man by the year 2030. But for now, women still lag. In 2007, the number of cents a woman earned for each dollar a man earned jumped from 77—where it had been stuck for as long as I can remember—to 81. Progress, yes, but still not an even playing field.
In terms of wealth and who has it, the number of women inheritors falling out of the ranks of the über-wealthy is—for now—greater than the number of women earners climbing into them. As Columbia’s Kopczuk puts it: “Old wealth is split equally. New wealth is not. But as time goes on, we expect to see a more equal split in wealth as well as in income. The tremendous strides women have made in income already indicates we will.”
How Do You Get There?
This all brings up the questions that are at the heart of this book: Where do you fit in now? And how do you rise to the top?
I suppose that’s fitting, as this entire book unfolded as the result of asking—and attempting to answer—one very large question: Why do some people seem to move relatively easily from a paycheck-to- paycheck existence into comfort or wealth, while others get stuck or—worse—fall back?
I set out to answer that question by reading volumes of research—academic and otherwise—on the subject. Or I should say subjects: wealth, education, success, entrepreneurship, risk taking, and the bigger worlds of behavioral finance and positive psychology, which danced in, out, and around the question I was trying to frame. Many professors walked me through their work, explaining their theories and answering my questions.
In the end, though, it wasn’t enough. I wanted specifics of which behaviors, attitudes, goals, and personality traits mattered most. I needed to know how these elements combined to make The Difference. How many of these behaviors, attitudes, goals, and traits did you need to boost you from one category to another? What, if anything, held you back?
That was when I joined forces with Merrill Lynch and Harris Interactive to develop our own survey instrument that would look—specifically—at these questions. For months, a team of eight to ten of us met regularly. We used the preexisting research as the foundation for our a twenty-minute questionnaire. Then we rewrote those questions, and rewrote them again. Finally, several months later, we administered the poll to more than five thousand individuals.
The study, formally known as the 2008 Merrill Lynch New Retirement Study, delved specifically into four loosely constructed categories: nonfinancial behaviors, financial attitudes and behaviors, goals (both financial and life), and personality. We asked hundreds of questions about topics including—but not limited to—the following:
financial attitudes and behaviors: Are you where you want to be financially? Why or why not? What has been the most important factor in reaching your financial status? Under what circumstances were you able to establish financial comfort? How do you handle your credit cards? Do you or do you not budget? Do you look up to people with more money than you have? Have you worked with a financial adviser? How do you feel about stocks? Bonds? Do you feel entitled to a good standard of living?
goals: What financial goals have been absolutely essential for you as an adult? Save more? Reduce debt? Which goals have you been able to accomplish as an adult? Can you envision a day where you won’t have to work to meet your financial needs? Do you envision a retirement where you will work part-time? Start your own business?
personality: Are you satisfied with your family life? Religious life? Sex life? Financial life? Are you driven to make a lot of money? Are you hardworking? A multitasker? Grateful? Confident? Happy? Optimistic? Stubborn? Creative? Street smart? Outgoing? Competitive? A leader? Ambitious? Popular? A risk taker? Do you have the ability to overcome a bad situation? Are you passionate about your work? Do you finish what you start? Can you easily read other people? Do you feel it is okay to break some rules? Have you compromised your personal principles to succeed professionally?
nonfinancial behaviors: How many times have you changed occupations as an adult? Do you work more than others? From home? On vacation? How often do you vote? How much television do you watch? How much time do you spend online? How often do you exercise? How often do you read books? Newspapers? Do you participate in extreme sports? Or meditate? How much sleep do you need? How often do you socialize and with whom—friends, family, neighbors, colleagues? People you enjoy? People who could advance your career? Have you made personal sacrifices to climb the ladder of success? Do you give back to your community? Often? As often as you can?
It was a huge undertaking. And that was not all. We asked about political affiliation, left and right handedness, birth order, and whether participants were the children of parents who read to them at night. If we had an inkling that something might be important, we tried to find some way to add it to the soup. And as you’d expect, some of the issues raised by these questions turned out to matter a lot, others not so much, some not at all.
We got the results back in early 2008. But anyone who has ever conducted a large-scale survey knows that the initial data run was just the beginning. For the next half year, the data was processed, cut, interpreted, and reinterpreted. I continued to ask questions. Harris continued to look for the answers. Along the way, David Robinson, associate professor of finance at Duke University—an expert in the field of behavioral finance—volunteered to weigh in. He was insight- ful and tireless, and with his help, the story in the data revealed itself even more.
The Top Twenty
As noted in the introduction, the research revealed four distinct groups of people: the wealthy, the financially comfortable, the paycheck-to-paychecks, and the further-in-debtors. Unfortunately, the breakdown below reveals that most Americans are still struggling.
The Difference In America
Percentage of Population
The wealthy (W):3 percent
The financially comfortable (FC):27 percent
The paycheck-to-paychecks (PTPs):54 percent
The further-in-debtors (FIDs):15 percent
What Makes The Difference?
The individuals that fall into these groups vary, of course, in terms of their income and their assets. But these discrepancies in income and assets aren’t driving the bus. They’re not leading the charge. The individuals in these groups are fundamentally different.
As I said, we tested for hundreds of factors. Yet in the end there were twenty factors that rose to the top as key elements. These twenty—literally—make The Difference. Those who “have it” share the following:
Financial Attitudes and Behaviors
•They feel stocks are worth the risk.
•They devote money to personal savings or a 401(k) each month.
•They save regularly for emergencies.
•They have invested for retirement.
•They have reduced outstanding debt.
•They want to be financially comfortable during their working years.
•They aim to retire comfortably.
•They always knew what they wanted to do (for a career).
•They made it a goal to accumulate $1 million.
•They want to own a home.
•They are confident.
•They are happy.
•They are optimistic.
•They are competitive.
•They are leaders.
•They have a college degree.
•They socialize with friends at least once a week.
•They exercise at least two to three times a week.
•They read newspapers regularly.
•They are married.
The good news is that you don’t need to have all of these factors. The Ws have more of these factors than the FC, who have more than the PTPs, who have more than the FIDs. It’s a continuum. But you do need, on average, ten factors (your choice) to make your way into financial comfort—and twelve to make your way to wealth. In contrast, only half of the PTPs and FIDs have more than three of these factors.
Finally, working with Duke’s David Robinson, I analyzed the data in another way.
Of the five thousand individuals in the sample, there was a signi- ficant group who were at one time falling deeper into debt but who have since climbed up into the top two categories. I call these 620 individuals the “movers.”
From this analysis, we were able to confirm the importance of the Top Twenty. For example, we saw that individuals who said the word “confident” described them at least “slightly” were significantly more likely to move into comfort or wealth than those who said it did not describe them at all. But we also saw, using this analysis, the emergence of several other important characteristics: gratitude, popularity (connectedness), and the willingness to work hard and take appropriate risks.
We also—quite importantly—learned that several things can hold you back. You won’t be surprised to hear that stubbornness is on this list. But how about creativity? Robinson and I spent many hours mulling that one and came away believing it’s a particular type of creativity that is the problem. It is not conceiving ideas and following through. People who can do that are likely to have said the word “creative” described them “slightly” or “well,” and you’ll see it helps rather than hurts them. But believing oneself too creative to play in the world of the mundane—these are the people likely to have said “creative” describes them “very well” or “completely”—that is problematic. “If your stubbornness or creativity consumes you,” Robinson noted, “those traits become a detriment.” Which leads me to a word on moderation.
As you read through these facts and figures, you will no doubt notice that whether we’re talking about being happy, hardworking, grateful, or creative, their presence in your makeup is beneficial . . . to a point. If they describe you “slightly,” you get a small bump. “Well,” a bigger bump. “Very well,” the biggest bump. But “completely”? You fall back a bit.
In moderation, all of these attributes are positive and lead to wealth. In full, perhaps not so much. Consider happiness. You’ll read more about this in chapter 5, but research has shown that the most blissful individuals don’t have enough drive to go for the big job, the big paycheck, the brass ring. They’re too satiated, too complacent. That same pattern is mirrored throughout.
As you read through The Difference, in particular the profiles of individuals who embody The Difference traits, you’ll see that they are—by and large—a balanced group. They are not consumed by one attribute or another but pay attention to many aspects of their lives. They are happy. They are socially connected. They vote. They exercise. They are glowing examples of moderation. I enjoyed spending time with them—and hope you will as well.
From the Hardcover edition.
and post it to your social network
Most Helpful Customer Reviews
See all customer reviews >
I was able to read an advance copy and I couldn't put it down! As always, Jean's calm and direct style is both informative and entertaining. I'm thinking about everything differently since I finished the book -- especially the financial headlines and how the economy does AND DOESN'T impact me. Best of all, I've realized that there are things I can do to get me back on the wealth track right away. I can't wait to buy the workbook. Congrats Jean, you've done it again.
I have been pretty good with saving my money but I know that I can always improve. In light of the economy in the past year and since I will be retiring in about 12-14 years, I decided to buy this book. I have seen Jean on Oprah several times and I like her approach to saving $. This book helps you determine what kind of saver you are and also highlights interviews with people that have been successful. I see some areas that I can "tweak" to maximize my savings. I would recommend this book if you are seriously interested in improving your money management.
Love it!! That was awesome!! &hearts Bella
Thats amazing i loved it &hearts Jade
"Hi, Mrs. Hemmings!" I smile as I see my homeschool teacher walk through the door to the study. "Hello, Grace. You know how I have a son?" Mrs. Hemmings asks me. "Yes. His name is Luke Hemmings, right?" I look at my hands for a second then I look back up at my teacher. "Correct. Well, he's on holiday and my husband couldn't watch him so I decided to take him to work today. Is that alright?" Mrs. Hemmings looks directly into my blue eyes. I swallow a little. A boy besides my father? I've never seen another male before, let alone talked to one. "Yes. That is completely fine." I answer, despite my worries. They are only worries, after all, right? "Come in, Luke." Mrs. Hemmings waves in her son. "Mom. I don't want to go in there." I hear a male whisper. Wow. How polite of him. "Nonsense! Grace is a sweet girl! Now come in here." Mrs. Hemmings whispers back then looks at me and smiles. Seconds later, a tall boy with blonde hair and lip piercing walks into the study. His blue eyes meet mine for a second then I look down at my feet. "Grace, this is Luke, my son. Luke, this is Grace, my student." Mrs. Hemmings introduces us. I slowly walk toward my desk and Luke sits next to me. "He-hello." I stutter. What a beautiful way to present myself. I'm wearing a red plaid skirt, black long sleeved shirt, white tights and boots that reach mid-shin. I have no make up on and my hair is in a ponytail. "Hey." Luke says and I look up at him in amazement. Did he just say 'hey' as a greeting? I've never heard anyone do that before. It was always 'hello' or 'hi'. Never once was it ever 'hey'. "Grace. Pay attention. Just because Luke is here, it doesn't mean that there is no school." Mrs. Hemmings scolds. "I am very sincerly sorry, Mrs. Hemmings. It won't happen again." I say as I sneak one last look at Luke. *LUNCH* "You guys can go out to the backyard." Mrs. Hemmings smiles as she sees that I'm staring out the back window. I smile at Mrs. Hemmings, greatfully, and stand up. I start to walk tpward the back door then stop and turn around. "Would you like to go out back with me, Luke?" I ask politely. "Uhm... sure." Luke smiles a little and I smile back. We walk tpward the back door together and I open the door for Luke. Luke takes the door and let's me go outside first. As Luke closes the door, I sit down in the grass. "I know that my backyard isn't all to big, unless ypu count a 150 centimeter by 390 centimeter backyard relitively big." I say. "Okay." Luke gives me a look that makes me feel like I'm some kind of crazy person. I blush and look down. I hear Luke laugh. "I'm confused. What's so funny?" I cock my head to the right. "You are. You're pretty enough where people would think that you're dumb but then you turn out to be some kind of nerd." Luke smiles. "Oh... uhm... I don't understand. What's a nerd?" I crinkle my nose. "A nerd is a smart person. Like, an extremly smart person." Luke explains. "Oh. So, based upon my looks, people automatically think that I am un-intelligent but I turn out to be rather the opposite, meaning that I am extremly intelligent." I explain to myself. Luke starts to laugh and I join in after I realized what I said.************* Wassup? I hope ypu guys like it! ♥ A
Compelling. I really like the positive "Secret" spin.