Discrepant Solace: Contemporary Literature and the Work of Consolation

by David James

Overview

Consolation has always played an uncomfortable part in the literary history of loss. But in recent decades its affective meanings and ethical implications have been recast by narratives that appear at first sight to foil solace altogether. Illuminating this striking archive, Discrepant Solace considers writers who engage with consolation not as an aesthetic salve but as an enduring problematic, one that unravels at the centre of emotionally challenging works of late twentieth- and twenty-first-century fiction and life-writing. The book understands solace as a generative yet conflicted aspect of style, where microelements of diction, rhythm, and syntax capture consolation's alternating desirability and contestation. With a wide-angle lens on the contemporary scene, David James examines writers who are rarely considered in conversation, including Sonali Deraniyagala, Colson Whitehead, Cormac McCarthy, W.G. Sebald, Doris Lessing, Joan Didion, J. M. Coetzee, Marilynne Robinson, Julian Barnes, Helen Macdonald, Ian McEwan, Colm Toibin, Kazuo Ishiguro, Denise Riley, and David Grossman. These figures overturn critical suppositions about consolation's kinship with ideological complaisance, superficial mitigation, or dubious distraction, producing unsettling perceptions of solace that shape the formal and political contours of their writing.

Through intimate readings of novels and memoirs that explore seemingly indescribable experiences of grief, trauma, remorse, and dread, James demonstrates how they turn consolation into a condition of expressional possibility without ever promising us relief. He also supplies vital traction to current conversations about the stakes of thinking with contemporary writing to scrutinize affirmative structures of feeling, revealing unexpected common ground between the operations of literary consolation and the urgencies of cultural critique. Discrepant Solace makes the close reading of emotion crucial to understanding the work literature does in our precarious present.

Product Details

ISBN-13:	9780198789758
Publisher:	Oxford University Press
Publication date:	07/23/2019
Pages:	288
Product dimensions:	9.30(w) x 6.10(h) x 1.00(d)

About the Author

David James, Professorial Research Fellow, University of Birmingham

David James is a Professorial Research Fellow at the University of Birmingham, before which he was Reader in Modern and Contemporary Literature at Queen Mary, University of London. Author, most recently, of Modernist Futures (Cambridge University Press, 2012), his edited volumes include The Legacies of Modernism (Cambridge University Press, 2012), The Cambridge Companion to British Fiction since 1945 (Cambridge University Press, 2015), and Modernism and Close Reading (Oxford University Press, forthcoming). He is Associate Editor for the journal Contemporary Literature, and for Columbia University Press he co-edits the book series 'Literature Now'.

Table of Contents

Introduction: Consolation's Discrepant Forms1. Fetched from Oblivion2. Description as Redress3. Elegy Unrestored4. The Religion of Style5. Life-Righting and Magical Thinking6. Apprehensive Alleviation7. Walking with the UnconsoledEpilogue: Bribes of Aesthetic Pleasure?

Editorial Reviews

"In the face of illness, grief, trauma, catastrophe — why write? Can consolation be found in works that seem to be about inconsolability? These are the urgent questions that propel David James' remarkable study of twenty-first century narrative fiction and memoir. The answers that James provides do full justice to the emotional depth as well as the analytic complexity of a body of contemporary writing that ranges from Kazuo Ishiguro to J.M. Coetzee, from W.G. Sebald to Joan Didion, from Marilynne Robinson to David Grossman... This is a book that skillfully and rewardingly attends to the micro-effects of prosody, while forging a new direction for the critical understanding of elegy, grief writing, trauma studies and post-modern fiction." — Dorothy Hale, University of California, Berkeley

"David James challenges the association of aesthetic consolation with distraction and comfort, showing instead how contemporary literature provides solace through the detailed description of loss and devastation. Discrepant Solace not only analyzes this paradox but instantiates it. In addressing the ethics of representing bleak experience, James has written a work of criticism that is not only intellectually challenging but also beautiful and deeply moving." — Heather Love, University of Pennsylvania

"To console us is one of the oldest tasks of literature, but it is also, of late, one of the most neglected. Literature should challenge us, estrange us, beguile us, but very few make the case that it should make us feel better. David James' brilliantly subtle and poetically attentive book responds to this critical lacuna, by offering a new way of understanding how today's literature consoles. There is nothing sentimental about this book — James does not offer a cosy picture of the redemptive qualities of the literary imagination; rather he addresses some of the contemporary writers whose work is most difficult, most uncompromising. But in doing so, he produces a startlingly original way of thinking about how the beauty of style overcomes some of the deprivations it witnesses, an account of the reparations of literary form that will have a transformative effect on how we think about the contemporary novel." — Peter Boxall, University of Sussex

From the Publisher