Gods and GeneralsDirector: Ronald F. Maxwell, Robert Duvall, Stephen Lang, Jeff Daniels
- Editorial Reviews
- Product Details
- Special Features
- Related Subjects
- Cast & Crew
Director Ron Maxwell and producer Ted Turner return to the glory and tragedy of the Civil War in this historical drama, a prequel to Gettysburg, which examines the early days of the conflict through the experiences of three men. Col. Joshua Lawrence Chamberlain (Jeff Daniels) left behind a quiet life and a career as a college professor to become one of the Union's greatest military minds. Gen. Thomas "Stonewall" Jackson (Stephen Lang) was, like Chamberlain, a man of great religious faith who served in the defense of the Confederacy. And Gen. Robert E. Lee (Robert Duvall), who led the Confederate army, was a man who was forced to choose between his loyalty to the United States and his love of the Southern states where he was born and raised. As Chamberlain, Jackson, and Lee are followed through the declaration of war and the battles at Manassas, Antietam, Frederickburg, and Chancellorsville, the film also introduces us to the many supporting players in the epic tale of the war between the States, among them the women these men left behind, among them Fanny Chamberlain (Mira Sorvino) and Anna Jackson (Kali Rocha). Based on a novel by Jeff Shaara, Gods and Generals also features a new song written and performed by Bob Dylan.
- Release Date:
- Original Release:
- Warner Home Video
- [Wide Screen]
- [DTS 5.1-Channel Surround Sound, Dolby AC-3 Surround Sound]
- Sales rank:
Cast & Crew
|Robert Duvall||Gen. Robert E. Lee|
|Stephen Lang||Gen. Thomas 'Stonewall' Jackson|
|Jeff Daniels||Joshua Lawrence Chamberlain|
|Mira Sorvino||Fanny Chamberlain|
|Bruce Boxleitner||Lt. General James Longstreet|
|Kevin Conway||Sgt. Buster Kilrain|
|C. Thomas Howell||Tom Chamberlain|
|Frankie R. Faison||Jim Lewis|
|Matt Letscher||Col. Adelbert Ames|
|Jeremy London||Alexander "Sandie" Pendleton|
|William Sanderson||Gen. A. P. Hill|
|Kali Rocha||Anna Morrison Jackson|
|Brian Mallon||Brig. General Winfield Scott Hancock|
|Mia Dillon||Jane Beale|
|George Allen||Confederate Officer|
|Bo Brinkman||Major Walter H. Taylor|
|Robert Byrd||Confederate General|
|Bill Campbell||Gen. George Pickett|
|Ryan Cutrona||Gen. Marsena Patrick|
|Robert Easton||John Janney|
|Joseph Fuqua||Col. J.E.B. Stuart|
|Phil Gramm||Virginia Delegate|
|Lydia Jordan||Jane Corbin|
|Edward Markey||Irish Brigade Officer|
|Dana Rohrbacher||20th Maine Officer|
|R. E. Turner||Col. Tazewell Patton|
|Alex Hyde-White||Ambrose Burnside|
|Malachy McCourt||Francis P. Blair|
|Royce D. Applegate||Brig. General James L. Kemper|
|John Castle||Old Penn|
|David Foster||Captain Ricketts|
|Patrick Gorman||Brig. Gen. John Bell Hood|
|Rosemary Knower||Mary Lincoln|
|James Patrick Stuart||Col. E. Porter Alexander|
|Keith Allison||Capt. James J. White|
|Mac Butler||Gen. Joseph Hooker|
|Shane Callahan||Bowdoin Student|
|David Carpenter||Rev. Beverly Tucker Lacy|
|Jim Choate||Gen. Bernard Bee|
|Martin Clark||Dr. George Junkin|
|Chris Clawson||Charles Beale|
|Scott Allen Cooper||Lt. Joseph Morrison|
|Devon Cromwell||Caset Charlie Norris|
|Scott Davidson||Sam Beale|
|Justin Dray||George Jenkins|
|Miles Fisher||John Beale|
|Keith Flippen||Maj. Gilmore|
|Bourke Floyd||Longstreet's Courier|
|Dennis Frye||Griffin's Aide|
|James Garrett||Gen. John Curtis Caldwell|
|Karen Goberman||Lucy Beale|
|Alexander Gordon||Martha's Older Son|
|Bo Greigh||Pvt. Pogue|
|Fred Griffith||Gen. Robert Rodes|
|Karen Hochstetter||Roberta Corbin|
|James Horan||Col. Cummings|
|Sam Hulsey||Julian Beale|
|Les Kinsolving||Gen. William Barksdale|
|Damon Kirsche||Harry McCarthy|
|Lew Knopp||Jackson's Courier|
|James Thomas Lawler||Another Looter|
|Matt Lindquist||Johann Heros Von Borcke|
|Doug Lory||2nd Irishman|
|Daniel J. Jesus Manning||Maj. John Harman|
|Tom Mason||Old Man in Fredericksburg|
|Jonathan Maxwell||Capt. Ellis Spear|
|Andrew McOmber||Young Corporal|
|Marquis Moody||Martha's Younger Son|
|Peter Neofotis||Wounded Maine Man|
|Mark Nichols||Surgeon in Fredericksburg|
|Carsten Norgaard||Gen. Darius Nash Couch|
|Tim O'Hare||Lt. Col. Clair Mulholland|
|Sean Pratt||Dr. Hunter Holmes McGuire|
|Jasmyn Proctor||Martha's Daughter|
|John Prosky||Gen. Lewis Armistead|
|Kyle Prue||Wounded Maine Soldier|
|W. Joseph Quam||1st Irishman|
|Ted Rebich||Looter #3|
|Tim Ruddy||Pvt. McMillan|
|Noel Schwab||Colston's Officer|
|Morgan Sheppard||Gen. Isaac Trimble|
|Christie Lynn Smith||Catherine Corbin|
|Michael Sorvino||Federal Soldier|
|Stephen Spacek||Capt. James Power Smith|
|Dana Stackpole||Lottie Estelle|
|Matthew Staley||Lieutenant Boswell|
|David Stifel||Rev. David S. Jenkins|
|Stephen Leonard Sullivan||Federal Soldier|
|Buck Taylor||Gen. Maxcy Gregg|
|Chris Conner||John Wilkes Booth|
|Tyler Trumbo||Young Wellford|
|Christopher Crutchfield Walker||Looter|
|Scott Watkins||Gen. Raleigh Colston|
|Ronald F. Maxwell||Director,Producer,Screenwriter|
|Suzanne Arden||Associate Producer|
|Gregory W.M. Bolton||Art Director|
|Donald P.H. Eaton||Asst. Director|
|Randy Edelman||Score Composer|
|Moctesuma Esparza||Executive Producer|
|David Franco||Musical Direction/Supervision|
|John Frizzell||Score Composer|
|Dennis Frye||Associate Producer|
|Stephen Halbert||Sound/Sound Designer|
|Casey Hallenbeck||Set Decoration/Design|
|Michael Z. Hanan||Production Designer|
|Martin G. Hubbard||Set Decoration/Design|
|Robert Katz||Executive Producer|
|Patricia Klawonn||Set Decoration/Design|
|Richard La Motte||Costumes/Costume Designer|
|Mace Neufeld||Executive Producer|
|Kees Von Oostrum||Cinematographer|
|Robert G. Rehme||Executive Producer|
|Jeff Shaara||Associate Producer|
|Jonathan J. Short||Set Decoration/Design|
|Ronald G. Smith||Executive Producer|
|Stan Tropp||Set Decoration/Design|
|Ted Turner||Executive Producer|
|Kees Van Oostrum||Cinematographer|
|Robert J. Wussler||Executive Producer|
The Life of Thomas "Stonewall" Jackson
The Authenticities of the Film
Journey to the Past
Cross the Green Mountain - Music Video by Bob Dylan
Ron Maxwell's Invitation to take the Journey Through Hallowed Ground
Spoken Languages: English
Most Helpful Customer Reviews
See all customer reviews
Well, I saw Gettysburg in a cinema en 1995,in Mexico City, and I enjoyed the movie, I am no exactly an anti-gringo guy, and I know that thanks the Civil War was over, the American government ( Mr. Grant ) pushed the French Emperator Napoleon III and forced him to command French troops to evacuate my country in 1866, leaving alone Maximiximilian , the austrian Emperor, Now you can realize how the end of the Civil War affected Mexico in somehow. Some datys ago I bought Gods and Generals, it's a long long movie, I miss Tom Berenger by the way....I wander if the movie ' The last full measure' was already released, I tried to find it in the net, but so far I ain't find nothing at all, so I will looking for it
Finally, the motion picture industry has levelled the playing field by presenting the War for Southern Independence from the Southern perspective. If you have ever wondered why southerners can't ''forget'' the War, do yourself a favor and see this one! Its the most accurate history yet, especially if you have ever read the original source materials and not focused on the Harvard revisionists' view.
This is one of the few movies about the Civil War that presents the Southern side from a Southern viewpoint. It's good to see this viewpoint amidst today's politically-correct revisionist view that the War between the States was fought over slavery. From the Southern viewpoint, the federal government didn't represent their interests anymore, so they decided to secede, the right of which is protected under the 9th and 10th amendments in our Bill of Rights. Remember, at one time, we were British subjects, and we seceded from England. Beyond all that, the movie is a very long 4+ hours. It's important to realize that this is a movie made more for historians and civil war reenactors than for the general public. The movie got terrible reviews by all the major critics, probably because there aren't boobs flashing or lots of swearing. If you can't sit for so long in a theater, then rent it and watch it at home.
In the film 'Gettysburg' Colonel Joshua Chamberlain (Jeff Daniels) utters 'there's nothing so much like a god on earth as a general on a battlefield.' Based on Jeff Shaara's novel of the same title 'Gods and Generals' is the prequel to 'Gettysburg,' which itself was based on the Pulitzer Prize winning novel, 'The Killer Angels,' written by Shaara's father, Michael. Directed and adapted for the screen by Ron Maxwell (as was its predecessor) 'Gods and Generals' presents the first two years of the American Civil War as the Army of the Potomac and the Army of Northern Virginia struggle against each other in the battles of First Bull Run, Fredricksburg and Chancelorsville. Much has been made of the film¿s historical accuracy but, little of the gore and carnage of war can been seen in its sanitized battle scenes filled with smoke, explosions, and men falling to the ground. Though the battle scenes themselves are expertly choreographed, hardly any thought seems to have gone into the cinematography of these scenes as they lack imagination in their framing and execution. Yet, I found the battle scenes alone worth the price of admission. I cannot say the same for Maxwell¿s bloated screenplay which is filled with flowery dialogue, long-winded speeches, and droning soliloquies. Yes, citizens of the nineteenth century spoke differently than we do today, but the dialogue is so jarring to the modern ear that it is nearly impossible for an audience to maintain a willingness to suspend its disbelief. The narrative in Mr. Shaara¿s novel is nearly equally split between four major characters: Colonel Joshua Chamberlain and General Winfield Scott Hancock on the side of the Union and Generals Robert E. Lee and Jonathan ¿Stonewall¿ Jackson on the Confederate side, while Mr. Maxwell¿s adaptation can nearly be considered as a Stonewall Jackson bio-pic with the other characters merely as supporting players. Shaara¿s book maintains a balance of viewpoints of both North and South but, Maxwell¿s film tilts the majority of screen time to the Confederate side. Stephen Lang does an admirable job as the highly religious Stonewall Jackson. Indeed, the film¿s shining glory is that Maxwell¿s screenplay and Lang¿s performance come closest to capturing the man that Jonathan Jackson was in reality as anything yet set forth on film. Though it is hard to separate Lang from his earlier portrayal of General George Picket in ¿Gettysburg.¿ Jeff Daniels competently reprises his role as Chamberlain, though he lacks screen time and is saddled with reciting Lucanus¿ ¿The Crossing of the Rubicon¿ as he watches elements the Union Army crossing the Rappahanock River into Fredericksburg, Virginia. The films greatest disappointment was Robert Duvall in his lackluster performance as General Robert E. Lee. Randy Edelman¿s sentimental score is adequate to the task at hand, and though pleasurable to listen to it does not rise to meet the challenge of the material presented. Mary Fahl¿s contribution, ¿Going Home,¿ played over the opening credits of windblown battle flags, in a movie which the director well knows is going to come in at 3 ½ hours, should have fallen to the cutting room floor, though I love every note of it. And Bob Dylan is as raspy as ever in his ¿Cross the Green Mountain¿ played over the end credits. Is ¿Gods and Generals¿ the greatest movie ever made about the American Civil War? No. Is it the most accurate movie about the Civil War? Quite possibly. But accuracy could not save this movie. Editing could. Edit the screenplay. Edit the dialogue and speeches. Edit the opening credits. Edit. Edit. Edit.
Though the perspective is dominated as from the south, it is more a Virginian's perspective and one from its military men. Stonewall Jackson and Lee are both represented with due respect. The movie lays out the mistakes of the North, showing that not all Generals were fit to lead, while others were followed because of their leadership abilities. The character of Jackson was well-developed and portayed as a man that honored his position. It is difficult for me to know the reliability or accuracy of this portrayal, but it was well presented. This movie does not insult either side, but goes about presenting situations and the human perspective. It does not judge, but makes the veiwer realize that there were various reasons for the war. It does place in perspective the issue of slavery and how it was not the only reason the war was fought, as many people today believe. I will find Gettysburg and watch it next, but I hope it is available in something other than wide screen format.
Save yourself the three hours plus that it takes to watch this movie and use the time to study the civil war from an unbiased viewpoint. The fact that the movie was three hours long did not bother me; I have enjoyed many wonderful three hour movies (Lord of the Rings, Pearl Harbor, Gladiator). The problem was that the producers took what should have been an hour and a half long movie and crammed it into three long dreadful hours. Adding to the dullness was a slew of bad acting and an obvious southern bias. I don't personally care who won the war between south and north, being from the west coast myself. However, the movie was clearly slanted to glorify the south and make the north appear to be a bunch of heartless bullies. I do have to admit that a few of the battle scenes were well contructed, but not comparable to other modern war movies. Perhaps if you are one of those people who think that the south won the war you will appreciate this movie. Otherwise, save youself the time.
I loved the movie Gettysburg and found it very educational and movie about a troubling time in American history. That being said I was very disappointed in Gods and Generals. It seemed overly fanatic with its religious overtones, and while some people have commented that these religious depictions are rather accurate, that doesn't mean we had to listed to rapturous monologues spoken toward heaven during the entire movie. The progression was slow and while I don't expect a lot of flash in movies that historical stories to tell, I do expect them to keep me engaged. I gave the movie one star for those people who want to see how the world does things in the name of religion. If so, this film is for you. Otherwise keep your money in your pocket.
The movie Gods & Generals is based on a novel by some person (can't remember). The movie follows the life and beliefs of Gen Jackson, Gen Lee, and Colonel Chamberlain through the battles of the Bull Run, Fredicksburg, and Chancellorville. Wait, wasn't the novel really about Fredicksburg? Anyways, through the movie you hear a lot of long pointless speeches, awkard acting, and what about the personal beliefs. Then you will probably say "when will the fighting start." Just wait and you will get what you want. The movie also shows the errors generals have made. For the battle re-an-acted the director does a great job on it. You first see the battle of the Bull Run which only last about ten minutes. I know that the real fight was longer. The fight does get intense though you might already know who wins if you got an A on a Civil War test. Then you more talking, speeches, the life of the generals, and the movie skips Antietam and goes straight to Fredicksburg. This is when it gets really good. Gen Lee makes Jackson and Longstreet to set up the army on the hill. Meanwhile, 2 of Gen Burnsides officers requested that they and their troops go cross the river to take over Fredicksburg. Thanks to recon, they discover that the city is barely defended. Their plan was to go and secure the city so a big Union army can go in the city without a fight, but it is denied. Burnside's plan was to get the big army to join them and on morning engineers will use pontoons (whatever they are) to help the army cross. Then the big army will go to Fredicksburg for frontal assault on the hill. Though Burnside doesn't know that gives the Confederates enough time to go in the city, set up a defense, and put sharpshooters to the defend the city. After the fight Gen Lee and Gen Jackson find out that Gen "Fighting Joe" Hooker is leading a huge army to destroy them. So Lee and Jackson decide to attack them by morning. Who will win the battle? Can Burnside be able to crush Lee? Can Jackson defeat Fighting Joe's bigger army? The answers are in the books and in the movie, because you will suprised.
After having read the excellant book 'Gods and Generals', I eagerly anticipated the release of this movie. To my great discontent, I found the movie utterly disapointing. Instead of portraying the four main characters equally, the movie concentrated on General Jackson and his personal quarkiness. The story barely touched on the other characters. Had I not read the book first, I may have liked the movie better. I also read the 'Killer Angels' and thought the movie 'Gettysburg' was much trurer to Shaara's version. Although I am a great admirer of General Jackson, I was looking forward to a more in depth portrayal of Generals Lee and Hancock and LtCol Chamberlain. To me it was not a matter of favoring one side or the other's version of the war, it was a matter of sticking to the version the author wrote. In that the movie was sorely lacking.
Why would you recast Stephan Lang as Stonewall Jackson, is one of my first questions. He is just terrible as Jackson, and the performance of Duvall as Lee is marred with so many inconsisties, I can't vouch for him this time. It was pathetic. Chamberlain was great, but the others could have stayed home.
Great for family viewing. It shows the Godly character of the Confederate generals. Normal battle scenes.
While the film does have some Southern leanings, they did not offend me at all. I personally have always been more impressed with the Confederates anyway. The Union won because they were bigger and stronger and because they had greater resources. The South lost because they didn't have the resources, manpower, and because of the Union navy. They did, however, make an amazing attempt with what they had available to them, and if they had had the resources they would have simply out-generaled the Yankees even without the manpower. Both sides fought heroically, but I can see why the makers focused on the South. They have the romantisim and heriosm of one of the last great Lost Causes. The Union had many bright lights, including Generals Hancock, Reynolds, and Chamberlain, as well as the common heroic infantryman. The commanding generals were pathetic; however, and that should have lost the war. I've lived my whole life in Pennsylvania. I welcome any debate on this subject in the form of email.
Great insite on the generals and important ppl of the civil war...see this before gettysburg
After the stunning triumph that was ''Gettysburg,'' it took them a decade to mount a production of ''Gods and Generals,'' based on Jeff Shaara's prequel to his father Michael's award-winning novel. While Jeff's novel wasn't much of a worthy successor to his father's work, it was certainly better than this travesty. None of the things that made ''Gettysburg'' great were in evidence here. The film seems so wrapped up in its own self-importance that it forgets to be entertaining. While Martin Sheen was a bit of flawed casting as Lee in ''Gettysburg,'' he's still a far sight better than Robert Duvall, whose performance can at best be described as somnambulant. The scenes with Jackson and the little girl are ridiculous, and even the big speeches, which were so riveting in ''Gettysburg,'' fall apart here. Do yourself a favor and just don't bother.
This movie and the book on which it is based offers an insight into the difference in civil war leaders. Some are great soldiers and leaders. The rest are Political appointments and pretenders. When faced with great deciaions, many are indecisive and even cowardly. Offers lessons about military leaders from every era.
I just wanted to add on to the review John Hardin did. The movie IS historically accurate and for every one movie that is 'biased' toward the South, there are 50 movies that rework the facts in favor of the North. I too had ancestors who fought and didn't own slaves and I had one who was killed on his way home after the war by a band of Yankee soldiers. With that aside, I'm am finally elated to hear someone's opinion and finally a movie about the South that is actually close to the way true Southerners really are.
Combining historical facts with heatfelt acting, Gods and Generals poignantly depicts the first few years of the Civil War. A must have for any history buff.
Though the movie is very slow and the plot on the book was about Fredicksburg, the movie is still good. The movie has some good actors including Robert Duvall (Apocalypse Now Redux) and Jeff Daniels, but the acting is awkard. The movie is very slow and boring, but the battles are intense and amazing. If it's one thing anyone should give credit to the movie is the battles.
Finally a Civil War Film that is historically correct.In the B&N review it was stated that the film is Southern Biased and may offend some people. I'm from the South and had many ancestors who fought and died defending their homes and most of them were poor dirt farmers who never owned slaves or had enough money to even consider owning them. It is refreshing to see a film that shows the Southern people as something other than ignorant,cruel and hard hearted.
I think this and gettysburg is the best civil war movies ever made .. This movie is well worth buying it is a little long and mainly based on jackson check it out
There is only one thing worse than a four-hour movie---that is a four-hour movie that is bad!
Gods and Generals is a refreshing departure from the flashy, IQ challenged war movies so many studios like to release these days. Rather than giving us close-ups of flying body parts and slow-motion shots of bodies riddled with hundreds of bullets, Gods and Generals chooses to focus on the men who fought and their reasons for doing so. Men brought to vivid life by unanimously excellent preformences. It is definately worth noting that the Confederates are not portrayed as the traitors to the union that school textbooks would have our children believe they were. It is said that history is written by the victors, but thanks to Jeff Sharra and Ron Maxwell, people will finally begin to understand what truly happened during the most tragic American war, not the politically correct myth that has been spoon fed to us for so long.