The Civil War: A Film by Ken Burns

Great Historical Perspective!

As research material I found it especially useful, and I would highly recommend it as a learning tool for young students and adults. It's also just good movie-making, and it keeps you wanting to watch more!

2 out of 2 people found this review helpful.

Well worth the time

The film from start to finish tells the whole story of the war from both sides, warts and all.

2 out of 3 people found this review helpful.

Wonderful Use of Period Pictures to Tell This Story

Ken Burns has a gift for telling stories through period pictures and music. You will not find great detail in the battle plans that a book might use help you to understand why each was won or lost, but there are wonderful pictures of this time blended with stirring music to help express the emotion of this period in time. It also will not provide many reasons for why these men decided to fight; particularlly those in the south. However, it is a great collection well worth watching over and over again.

2 out of 2 people found this review helpful.

Phenomenal and vivid view of the Civil War

Wonderful storytelling, directly from personal accounts of a wide variety of fascinating characters of the era. A great addition to anyone's video library.

1 out of 1 people found this review helpful.

A Timeless, Valuable History Lesson (Part Two)

The series gets a lot of input from historian Shelby Foote, a Southern who has many interesting anecdotes. He remembers talking to the family of General Nathan Bedford Forrest (who later joined and left the Ku Klux Klan) and telling them The Civil War produced two great men: Forrest and Abraham Lincoln. Forrest's relatives coolly told Foote "we don't talk much about Mr. Lincoln in this house". Of course, Burns does devote much time to the key battles of the war, including spending an entire episode on the battle of Gettysburgh, Pennsylvania. We learn, among other things, that The Civil War was where the term "shell shock" was invented; these days, it's called Post Traumatic Stress Disorder. It was also the battle where submarines were first used, as in the story of The Monitor and The Merrimac. The most disturbing stories of the war come from POW camps, particularly from the brutal Andersonville, Georgia camp where Union prisoners weren't allowed to have tents, so they lived in holes in the ground. After the war ended, the commander of Andersonville was found guilty of war crimes and sentenced to death. As he was about to be hanged, he claimed he was just following orders. This---along with the horrific pictures of these prisoners---is eerily reminsicent of the Holocaust during World War II. The war brings about the best in some people and the worst in others. The best, as in President Lincoln's ability to keep the country united towards victory, until his 1865 assassination. The worst, as in the fact that Lincoln's killer, John Wilkes Booth, spent more time as an actor during the war than a soldier. Worse still, one of the people hanged for the Lincoln conspiracy was Mary Surrat, the mother of Booth's conspiracy partner, whose only mistake was unknowingly sheltering Booth and his comrades. "The Civil War" is one of those programs that sticks in your mind and your conscience long after its over, not just for its horrific images (and they are a lot of those) but also its truly moving ones. For me, the most moving was a picture of a young black slave with torn clothes and dirty hair. The next picture shows him dressed as a Union soldier playing a drum. It was as if he was completely transformed. The war itself transformed the country, for better and worse. Better because we became a truly free society. Worse because, sadly, misconceptions and hatreds from that time still exist.

A Priceless, Timeless History Lesson

Where do you begin with this series? It is still regarded as one of the greatest television shows ever made, certainly the greatest PBS show ever made. As a history lesson, it is invaluable. It even works on an entertaining level because it brings America's most threatening crisis to a personal view that everyone can comprehend. Ken Burns' "The Civil War" works on both levels. But even as a technical achievement, it is magnificent. Using still photographs from that period, with traditional roots music and actors as figures from that time, "The Civil War" allows us to use our imaginations and to realize how close this country came from becoming two seperate nations. And yes, it makes clear to all of us that slavery was the Number One issue of that war. Narrated by historian David McCulloch, the 11-hour series starts with the years before the war, how the issue slavery in the 1850's was pitting states against each other. It was an issue that many politicans, including President James Buchanan, refused to deal with. By 1860, the election of President Abraham Lincoln, known for his anti-slavery sympathies, sent shock waves through the South that their way of life was now threatened. Then came the firing at Fort Sumter, which according to the series resulted in no deaths. That's another thing about "The Civil War": it reveals facts that most of us probably never knew. Among the other facts the show reveals are that most of the 500,000 people who died during the war died from sickness or disease rather than battle wounds. It also shows how women played a major role in helping and supporting their men, including Mary Chestnutt and Red Cross nurse Clara Barton. As the series progresses, it becomes clear that the North probably could've won the war earlier and easier, since they had the manpower. Problem was, they didn't have the military leaders with the will to actually carry it out. The Union Army went through about ten different commanders before settling on Ulysses S. Grant, a failed businessman, whose persistance made Northern victories possible. The series also spends a lot of time on Robert E. Lee, the leader of the Confederate Army. It mentions, among other things, that he hated slavery but he fought for the South because Virginia was his home and he wanted to defend it. For the first two years of the war, Lee demonstrated that the former Top Ten West Point cadet was one of the shrewdest, keenest and most respected military leaders America ever produced. When the war finally ended, Lee's mansion in Arlington, Virginia became The Arlington National Cemetary, America's most sacred ground, so that Lee and the Confederacy would never use it. "The Civil War" features many prominent actors as the voices of figures like Abe Lincoln (Sam Waterston), Ulysses S. Grant (Jason Robards), Mary Chestnutt (Julie Harris) and so on. However, the voice that seems so prominent in this series is Garrison Keillor, the host of "A Prairie Home Companion"; his Midwestern drawl makes him perfect doing a myriad of voices, mostly of Union soldiers. But Keillor's narration of Walt Whitman, whose experience of working in the hospital tending to the wounded soldiers, are the most memorable and heartbreaking. To Be Continued....

One of the finest historical films ever produced

Ken Burns recently updated this classic, and I was fortunate enough to be able to watch it again. It is one of my finest works of cinematography devoted to a documentary. It is comprehensive, and keeps ones interest, (especially if you happen to love history as much as I do). There is no one film that could cover the entire scope and span of the Civil War, but this one comes closest to the possibility. It relies on still photography, documents and commentary from one of our most imminent Civil War historians, Shelby Foote. It is, simply put, a masterpiece. This is Ken Burns' best work, and that is saying quite a lot. It gives you a much deeper understanding of the events of this war, and a greater appreciation of what all of the people endured that were involved, from slave to soldier, from commander to President, no one was left unaltered. It is not only the facts that make the difference, it is how they are presented. And no one does a better job of that than Ken Burns.

Terrific

I can watch this over and over and over again

0 out of 1 people found this review helpful.

Civil War: A Film by Ken Burns

I bought this as a gift for my husband and he has enjoyed the DVDs.

0 out of 1 people found this review helpful.

The Civil War and its effects on Americans

This is the best DVD series Depicting what it was like to live through thr Civil War and on the way Americans view this conflict through the fog of time and legend.

Great as Expected!

Ken Burns is a wonderful storyteller. He employs numerous people to assist in the story telling and it keeps you very interested. This is a great set for those interested in the Civil War, or anyone doing research. It provides interesting and unusual points of view of the war.

Pure American History

This production was the most "pure American history" I've ever viewed. It brings the Civil War period of our history "back" to a reality. The progression of the true story of the War, along with the depth of the research and inclusion of the "story tellers", well presents the story of the American Civil War.

Still the best of Ken Burns' work!

At almost 20 years old, this is still an amazing accomplishment. If you have any interest in our country's history, get this documentary!

Doesn't get any better.

This is the best documentary ever made about anything. It's a must for history lovers. It's all you'll need to study the Civil War. I watch it every year.

The finest Civil War Documentary ever made

All I have to say is that this fine work should be mandatory viewing for all Americans, it will change your life and the way you think about America.

One of My Favorites

Having worn out my VHS copies, I thought it was time to move on to the DVD version. Treated myself for Christmas to this set. Pictures are crystal clear, sound is fine, enjoying the program all over again.

From the other side of the pond

They don't teach UK kids about the American Civil War but after seeing this wonderful piece of Television history as a 6th former (17-18yo), I have spent many years visiting the US whenever I can, travelling around civil war battlefields and places of historical importance and seeing the sites that I saw on film. I recall the first time I stood at Gettysburg and looked out across the fields and then shed a quiet tear as I contemplated the bravery and belief that led men to walk to their almost certain deaths to make a stand at what both sides felt was right. Well done Ken on this achievement and goodbye to Mr. Foote who made me smile every time he spoke with his gentle demeanour and rye smile. God Bless you all

The reason I love History

This series is the reason I love history and THE reason studying the American Civil War became my hobby. Ken Burns created a masterpiece when he made this film. It's also his fault that I spent all my birthday money on one thing the year this originally came out on DVD "haha!". Burns has gone on to make many more outstanding documentaries, but this The Civil War is his crowning achievement. Everyone should watch this film as a resource to show what this country has gone through.

EXTREMELY INTERESTING AND EDUCATIONAL

Thank you, Mr. Burns, for bringing the Civil War to life in such an awesome way as you did in this series. I must say that I learned so much more about the Civil War from watching your documentary than I ever did years ago in high school. I could watch the series 50 times in a row and never grow tired of it. I really wished I could have met Shelby Foote before he passed away. He was an extremely knowledgeable individual on the Civil War. May Shelby rest in peace, and may you be applauded on your magnificent work!

A reviewer, a concerned human being

'Concerned parent'- It seems exceedingly ironic that you, a person set upon bolstering our education system against outside 'denigration', would participate in the very act you so hope to abolish. Perhaps it is not the innocent typo of a history teacher but the arrogant and condescending attitudes of people like you that need improvement. If your goal was simply to reveal your over-inflated ego, you were successful. If your goal truly is to enhance the impoverished state of our nation's teacher, correcting typos probably is not the best place to start. Great film by the way.