One of the BEST Love Stories Ever Written!!!
What a privilege it's been to read Eternal on the Water.
I just finished the book last night/this morning;it took me waaaay longer to finish this book than it should have simply because I did not want to separate Cobb and Mary. Their love story was so overwhelmingly real that I could hardly bear to face the end, which of course makes no sense as I already had when I began the book.
But emotions, and especially love don't always make sense do they?
As for reading the end first (the book begins with Mary's death), I have to say that doing that was the most brilliant thing done technically in this novel. It made it real from the beginning, no false hope about "maybe she gets saved at the end", and it let me as a reader focus on what mattered. I got to focus on their story together, and not be distracted that "this is fiction" and so therefore think that a miracle was in store. Instead I focused on spending as much time with Mary as I could, alongside Cobb.
A friend asked me to describe the book without giving away any spoilers yesterday after I had been raving about it. What's funny is I said "it's very real life in that surreal kind of way", lol.
I had just read the part that talks about the movie "All That Heaven Allows" and the window scene, and was explaining how it reminded me of "Sleepless in Seattle" in that way, but that it was much more as a book than just that little moment.
Reading Eternal on the Water was seriously like just listening to a new friend tell you his life story (thus far) because you've come to that point in the friendship where you really get to know each other; where you both begin to share that intimacy of real friendship by sharing real stories about the deeper points in your life, not just the so-called powerpoint version. So, reading this book was not like most books I read where I feel as though I'm the main character and I'm experiencing things as if they're happening to me. It's more like this conversation where I was listening to this man Cobb's amazing life story. And it's that intimacy that's so inherent in this book that made me care, and respond as if Cobb were truly my real friend. Because of this, I understand exactly what the author means when he says Cobb & Mary "whispered" their story to him instead of feeling as though he was seeing it or shown visually the story as it came to him.
On another note, I also found it really meant something that a guy ( Cobb tells the story) was telling this story. As a woman, I don't often hear men open up so much about love stories, etc, the way women do. So all the while I felt that Cobb was telling me his story, I knew it really meant something because a guy is telling it, and so you (as a reader) feel honored to share it.
Bottom Line:
I LOVED this book. Thank you Joseph Monninger for writing it, and Thank you B&N for bringing us this book! It's beautiful and without a doubt one of the best love stories I've ever heard/read.
2 out of 3 people found this review helpful.
Was this review helpful? Yes NoThank you for your feedback.
Report this reviewThank you, this review has been flagged.