James Bradley's classic work of American military history fully captures the story behind the most famous photograph taken during World War II: the raising of the flag at Iwo Jima. Bradley, the son of one of the flagraisers, exhaustively researched the lives of the six Easy Company soldiers who participated in the event and discovered that the adulation the heroes received on their return home was not always welcome.
The Barnes & Noble Review
Flags of Our Fathers
On February 23, 1945, six young men boys, really marched up Mount Suribachi on the island of Iwo Jima and raised an American flag in a gesture of freedom. Almost by accident, the moment was captured on film, becoming not only the most famous photograph taken during World War II but an image that continues to resonate throughout history.
In Flags of Our Fathers, James Bradley son of the last surviving flag raiser, John "Doc" Bradley tells the story of six very different men who came together in a moment that will live forever. In a small town in Wisconsin, James Bradley grew up knowing that his father was one of the men in the famous photo. But that was all he knew his father never spoke of the picture nor, for that matter, the war to his family. After the elder Bradley's death in 1994, his children discovered letters and photos that revealed much about their father's role in one of the grisliest battles of the Second World War, sparking a flurry of research that ultimately led to this book.
Who were these boys? Hailing from tiny pockets of small-town America, their origins mirrored the broad diversity of American life. They were from the hills of Appalachian Kentucky and the Arizona desert; from idyllic small-town Wisconsin and the iron smelters of Pennsylvania; from the mills of Manchester, New Hampshire, and the Rio Grande Valley of Texas. Caught in time, they are a snapshot of American boyhood in the 1930s. Boys who became men as they enlisted and trained for "the fightfordemocracy," eventually thrown together by fate and the U.S. Marine Corps on a tiny little island south of Tokyo. Bradley captures the explosive battle there in all its riveting, bloody detail.
On the fifth day of that battle, a photographer caught one jubilant, triumphant and spontaneous moment that would inspire incredible support for the war back home. But as Bradley discovered, that instant by no means marked an end to the fight or to the story that would unfold.
Indeed, perhaps most intriguing is what happened after the victory. Three of the six boys died only days later, amid the brutal fighting on Iwo Jima. The three survivors returned home, hailed as heroes, and lived as reluctant symbols. For two of them, the adulation that came with a photo beloved by the public was shattering. As for John Bradley, he never displayed the picture and only after his death did his family uncover the Navy Cross, the nation's second highest award for valor, that he had earned just two days before the flag raising.
Flags of Our Fathers is both a study of six men and the tale of a nation amid the horrors of war and its aftermath. Exploring such themes as patriotism, heroism, and integrity, it's a powerful story that no one will ever forget.
PW called this volume, adapted from a bestseller for adults, a "memorable work," as it focuses on one of the most famous of war photographs: the image of six Marines raising the flag on Iwo Jima. The author, son of one of those Marines, investigates the lives (and deaths) of the six. Ages 12-up. (May) Copyright 2003 Reed Business Information.
Publishers Weekly - Publisher's Weekly
Newly adapted from a bestseller for adults, Flags of Our Fathers: Heroes of Iwo Jima by James Bradley with Ron Powers, adapted by Michael French, focuses on one of the most famous of war photographs: the image of six marines raising the American flag on Iwo Jima. Bradley, son of one of those marines, investigates the lives (and deaths) of the six, closely examining their experiences to detail the brutal battle on the island, the contrast between the sense of victory projected by the photograph and the more ambiguous circumstances behind it, and the bond-raising value of the photo (and of its surviving subjects) to the Treasury Department. A photo insert adds to the immediacy of this memorable work. ( May) Copyright 2001 Cahners Business Information.
An abridged version of the adult best-seller, this is a recap of the famous World War II Pacific battle. It is also a kind of memoir, as Bradley explores the life not only of his own father, but also the lives of the other five young men memorialized by the famous Iwo Jima flag-planting image. Three of them were to die as the island battle continued. Two of the survivors were to have their lives destroyed through inability to cope with the subsequent publicity; only Bradley's father endured to live a normal life as a funeral director. The story is a compelling one in theory. In practice, it falls apart through a certain narrative tedium and overabundance of facts. Yes, these young men were heroes, but not for raising the flag. The photo image itself was a kind of after-the-fact reconstruction. The perils of creating such a symbol are suggested but never precisely addressed. Young readers will have a difficult time slogging through the background to get to the meat of the event and the issue. 2001, Delacorte, $15.95. Ages 10 to 14. Reviewer: Kathleen Karr
French has taken a large book and cut it down for young adults to slightly more than two hundred pages of text, just enough to meet most book report requirements. Teen readers, however, will not notice the deletions. Instead, they will find a fast-paced tale of the people behind the famous flag-raising photograph that came out of one of America's bloodiest and most decorated battles. There were six American soldiers who hoisted the United States flag on Iwo Jima in 1945 during World War II. The last survivor was John "Doc" Bradley, father of James Bradley, the author of this tale. John rarely spoke of the flag raising during his lifetime. When John died in 1994, his son decided to search for the details about what really happened to his father and the other men depicted in the familiar photograph and the Iwo Jima War Memorial near the nation's capital. His search produced a book that traces the six flag raisers with disparate backgrounds from birth to death, racing through their early years, lingering on their military training, and following them onto the beaches of Iwo Jima and up the mountain.. The book also analyzes the photograph, which by virtue of numerous accidents captivated a nation and made an ordinary task an act of heroism. Longer than the audio tape and shorter than the original adult-marketed book, which was published in 2000, French's abridgement loses none of the horror of battle or the impact of the famous photograph. This chronicle is recommended for libraries where interest in World War II history or fiction is significant. Index. Illus. Photos. Biblio. VOYA CODES: 4Q 3P M J S (Better than most, marred only by occasional lapses; Will appeal with pushing; MiddleSchool, defined as grades 6 to 8; Junior High, defined as grades 7 to 9; Senior High, defined as grades 10 to 12). 2001, Delacorte, 211p, $15.95. Ages 11 to 18. Reviewer: Beth Karpas
Everyone who has any passing interest in WW II has been affected by the famous Iwo Jima photograph. The image of five U.S. Marines and a Navy corpsman raising the flag atop Mt. Surabachi is one of the most potent images of the Pacific Campaign. The aftermath was tragic, for the most part. Three of the men were killed soon afterwards and another, Ira Hayes, became an alcoholic and died young. Now the gallant Navy corpsman's son, James Bradley, has emerged to tell his father's story and to recall the bloody battle from the infantryman's perspective. Bradley does a fine job, both for his father and for the rest of us. A book like this, which shows a military campaign through the eyes of a single platoon, makes a useful supplement to the more conventional military histories. The author does well in explaining the strategic importance of Iwo Jima and just why it was so necessary for the U.S. to occupy that desolate and overheated pile of volcanic ash, and why it was equally vital for Japan to defend it. Only two maps are presented; the bare minimum for a book of this nature; but both are detailed enough to orient the reader and make the action more understandable. One of the nicer features of this title is that an editorial assistant has adapted the text for younger readers. Michael French has succeeded in making the narrative comprehensible to about the 8th grade level; yet this has been done so skillfully that the average adult reader will scarcely notice. KLIATT Codes: JS; Recommended for junior and senior high school students. 2001, Random House, 211p. illus. bibliog. index., Puffer
This story stars the six soldiers who raised Old Glory over Mt. Suribachi during the bloody battle for Iwo Jima in World War II. Joe Rosenthal's powerful photo of their shouldering the flag became the symbol of U.S. triumph over the Japanese. The three surviving flag raisers, including Bradley's father, John, toured as wartime heroes, selling billions in bonds. But John Bradley, who had been badly wounded, insisted he was not a hero; only the men "who did not come back" were heroes. His son re-creates the backgrounds of the events as seen by his protagonists, such as amphibious assaults on fiercely defended islands; horrifying deaths and injuries to the troops; and grotesque episodes, like the torture and murder of a U.S. prisoner. These fragments of the Pacific war dramatize what the six achieved in spite of obstacles and frustrations; one, a Native American, succumbed to depression and alcohol, dying ten years after the war. Actor Barry Bostwick's resonant voice enunciates well, except for slighting an "r" in "February," a key month on Suribachi. Recommended for those who like tales of youths who fought and died for their country.--Gordon Blackwell, Eastchester, NY Copyright 2000 Cahners Business Information.\
School Library Journal
Gr 7-10-The American flag being hoisted over Iwo Jima during World War II is a ubiquitous image, and students are repeatedly told that it represents the struggle of war and the triumph of freedom. Reading this magnificent book will make those concepts tangible. A son of one of the "flag raisers," Bradley tells the story of six young men, from different backgrounds and varying experiences, who came together at one moment during "America's most heroic battle" to be spontaneously immortalized by an Associated Press photographer. Solidly adapted from the adult bestseller (Bantam, 2000), this work builds from introductions to the men and the war to a narration of the bloody conquering of the important island, concluding with the celebrity-encouraged by FDR-that followed the picture's worldwide publication. The dramatic fighting, heroic behavior, and patriotic celebrations in which these half-dozen humble individuals played a role are all captured. The author's authoritative sources include the elder Bradley's papers and rare familial recounts of the experience, hundreds of interviews, and a visit to the site of the action. And while justly proud of his father and his country, Bradley strives for fairness and historical accuracy, pointing out that this was the second flag raised that day, the first having been taken down as a souvenir for an officer. History is thus made personally authentic in these pages. A book that deserves a place on school reading lists and in every library.-Andrew Medlar, Chicago Public Library, IL Copyright 2001 Cahners Business Information.
Flags of Our Fathers is one of the most
instructive and moving books on war and its aftermath that we are likely
to see, in part because it is instructive and moving in unexpected ways.
On one level, Mr. Bradley has composed a touching eulogy to his father,
one that honors him precisely for those qualities that did not earn him
fame and recognition on Iwo Jima. He has also forged an unforgettable
tableau of one of the most savage battlefields in history, a battlefield of
wholesale death, mutilation and waste. Beyond that he has produced an
arresting meditation on the nature of heroism, the public perception of it,
and the unbridgeable chasm between the two.
The New York Times
No battle of World War II was more brutally intense than the capture of Iwo Jima, and this book brilliantly capsules the inch-by-inch combat. At its heart is the iconic photo of the flag raising on that island. It traces the lives of the six men in the picture, their courage, their failings, and, in a way, their commonness. They weren't conscious heroes, just men doing an often ghastly, but necessary job. It gives us sober second thoughts about war and its supposed glory.
The Christian Science Monitor
Flags focuses on the lives of the six men who, quite by chance, found themselves hoisting the piece of Japanese plumbing that became a U.S. flagpole on Mount Suribachi. The authors take the men from their homes in varied corners of the country before the war, through extensive training, to their date with destiny... Seeing them as ordinary men makes their heroism all the more stunning.
Gregory Orfalea, National Review
From the Publisher
"The best battle book I ever read. These stories, from the time the six men who raised the flag at Iwo Jima enlisted, their training, and the landing and subsequent struggle, fill me with awe."—Stephen Ambrose
Read an Excerpt
The only thing new in the world is the history you don't know —Harry Truman
In the spring of 1998 six boys called to me from half a century ago on a distant mountain, and I went there. For a few days I set aside my comfortable life—my business concerns, my life in Rye, New York—and made a pilgrimage to the other side of the world, to a tiny Japanese island in the Pacific Ocean called Iwo Jima.
There, waiting for me, was the mountain the boys had climbed in the midst of a terrible battle half a century earlier. The Japanese called the mountain Suribachi, and on its battle-scarred summit the boys raised an American flag to symbolize our country's conquest of that volcanic island, even though the fighting would rage for another month.
One of those flag raisers was my father.
The fate of the late twentieth and twenty-first centuries was being forged in blood on the island of Iwo Jima and others like it in the Pacific, as well as in North Africa, parts of Asia, and virtually all of Europe. The global conflict known as World War II had mostly teenagers as its soldiers—kids who had come of age in cultures that resembled those of the nineteenth century.
My father and his five comrades—they were either teenagers or in their early twenties—typified these kids: tired, scared, determined, brave. Like hundreds of thousands of other young men from many countries, they were trying to do their patriotic duty and trying to survive.
But something unusual happened to these six: History turned all its focus, for 1/400th of a second, on them. It froze them in an elegant instant of one of the bloodiest battles of the twentieth century, if not in the history of warfare—froze them in a camera lens as they hoisted an American flag on a makeshift iron pole.
Their collective image became one of the most recognized and most reproduced in the history of photography. It gave them a kind of immortality—a faceless immortality. The flag raising on Iwo Jima became a symbol of the island, the mountain, the battle; of World War II; of the highest ideals of the nation; of valor itself. It became everything except the salvation of the boys who performed it.
For these six, history had a different, special destiny that no one could have predicted, least of all the flag raisers themselves.
My father, John Henry Bradley, returned home to small-town Wisconsin after the war. He shoved the mementos of his immortality into a few cardboard boxes and hid these in a closet. He married his childhood sweetheart. He opened a funeral home, fathered eight children, joined the PTA, the Lions, and the Elks—and shut out virtually any conversation on the topic of raising the flag on Iwo Jima.
When he died, in January 1994, in the town of his birth, he might have believed he was taking the story of his part in the flag raising with him to the grave, where he apparently felt it belonged. He had trained us, as children, to deflect the phone-call requests for media interviews that never diminished over the years. We were to tell the caller that our father was on a fishing trip, usually in Canada. But John Bradley never fished. No copy of the famous photograph hung in our house. When we did manage to extract from him a remark about the incident, his responses were short and simple, and he quickly changed the subject.
And this is how we Bradley children grew up: happily enough, deeply connected to our peaceful, tree-shaded town, but always with a sense of an unsolved mystery somewhere at the edges of the picture.
A middle child among the eight, I found the mystery tantalizing. I knew from an early age that my father had been some sort of hero. My third-grade schoolteacher said so; everybody said so. I hungered to know the heroic part of my dad. But try as I might, I could almost never get him to tell me about it.
John Bradley might have succeeded in taking his story to his grave had we not stumbled upon the cardboard boxes a few days after his death.
My mother and brothers Mark and Patrick were searching for my father's will in the apartment he had maintained as his private office. In a dark closet they discovered three heavy cardboard boxes. In those boxes my father had saved the many photos and documents that came his way as a flag raiser. All of us were surprised that he had saved anything at all.
Later I rummaged through the boxes. One letter caught my eye. The cancellation indicated it was mailed from Iwo Jima on February 26, 1945, written by my father to his folks just three days after the flag raising: "I'd give my left arm for a good shower and a clean shave, I have a 6 day beard. Haven't had any soap or water since I hit the beach. I never knew I could go without food, water or sleep for three days but I know now, it can be done."
And then, almost as an aside, he wrote: "You know all about our battle out here. I was with the victorious [Company E,] who reached the top of Mt. Suribachi first. I had a little to do with raising the American flag and it was the happiest moment of my life."
The "happiest moment" of his life? What a shock! If it made him so happy, why didn't he ever talk about it? Did something happen either on Iwo Jima or in the intervening years to cause his silence?
Over the next few weeks I found myself staring at the photo on my office wall, daydreaming. Who were those boys with their hands on that pole? Were they like my father? Had they known one another before that moment or were they strangers united by a common duty? Was the flag raising the "happiest moment" of each of their lives?
The quest to answer those questions consumed four years of my life and ended, symbolically, with my own pilgrimage to Iwo Jima.
Iwo Jima is a very small place to have hosted such a savage battle. Only eight square miles, the tiny island barely crests the seemingly infinite Pacific. The value of capturing this speck of land for the Americans was its location and its two airfields. The island provided a place for American planes to stop and refuel on crucial bombing missions to and from Japan.
Not many Americans make it to Iwo Jima these days. It is a dry wasteland of black volcanic ash that reeks of sulfur (the name means "sulfur island"). A closed Japanese naval base, it is inaccessible to civilians except for rare government-sanctioned visits.
It was the commandant of the Marine Corps, General Charles Krulak, who made the trip possible for me, my seventy-four-year-old mother, three of my brothers—Steve, Mark, and Joe—and many military men and women. One of first things we did on the island was to walk across the beach closest to Mount Suribachi, on the black volcanic sands. On their invasion maps the Marines had dubbed it "Green Beach," and it was across this killing field that young John Bradley, a Navy corpsman, raced under heavy fire. I watched as my mother made her way across that same beach, sinking to her ankles in the soft volcanic sand with each step. "I don't know how anyone survived!" she exclaimed.
Then it was time for our family to ascend the 550-foot volcanic crater that was Mount Suribachi. My twenty-one-year-old father had made the climb on foot carrying bandages and medical supplies; our party was whisked up in vans. I stood at its summit in a whipping wind that helped dry my tears. This was exactly where that American flag was raised on a February afternoon fifty-three years before. The wind had whipped on that day as well.
From the edge of the extinct volcanic crater, we could view the entire two-mile beach where the armada had discharged its boatloads of Marines. In February 1945 the Japanese could see it with equal clarity from the tunnels just beneath us. They waited patiently until the beach was crowded with American boys. They had spent many months positioning their gun sights. When the time came, they simply opened fire, beginning one of the great military slaughters of all history.
An oddly out-of-place feeling seized me: I was so glad to be there! The vista below us, despite the gory history, was invigorating. The sun and the wind seemed to bring all of us alive. At Suribachi you feel on top of the world, surrounded by ocean.
And then I realized that my high spirits were not so out of place at all. I was reliving something. I recalled the line from the letter my father wrote three days after the flag raising: "It was the happiest moment of my life."
We Bradleys then began to take pictures. We posed in various spots, including near the X that marks the spot of the actual raising. We had brought with us a plaque to personally commemorate the flag raising and our father's role in it. Joe gently placed the plaque in the dry soil.
IN MEMORY OF
JOHN H. BRADLEY
FROM HIS FAMILY
I began to speak to the Marines who had gathered in front of our memorial.
I spoke first of the battle. It ground on over thirty-six days. It claimed 25,851 U.S. casualties, including nearly 7,000 dead. Most of the 22,000 defenders fought to their deaths.
It was America's most heroic battle. Two out of every three Americans who fought on this island were either killed or wounded. More medals for valor were awarded for action on Iwo Jima than in any battle in the history of the United States. To put that into perspective: The Marines were awarded eighty-four Medals of Honor in World War II. Over four years, that was twenty-two a year, about two a month. But in just one month of fighting on this island, they were awarded twenty-seven Medals of Honor, one-third of their accumulated total.
Next I showed the Marines the famous flag-raising photograph. I remarked that nearly everyone in the world recognizes it, but no one knows the boys.
I pointed to the figure in the middle of the image: solid, anchoring, with both hands clamped firmly on the rising pole. That's my father, I said. John Bradley was known to the other Marines in his company as "Doc" because he was a medical corpsman. He is the most identifiable of the six figures, the only one whose profile is visible.
I pointed next to a figure on the far side of John Bradley. Rene Gagnon, the handsome mill hand from New Hampshire, stood shoulder to shoulder with my dad in the photo, but he is mostly obscured by my father.
I gestured to the figure on the far right of the image, the leaning, thrusting soldier jamming the base of the pole into the hard Suribachi ground. His right shoulder is nearly level with his knee. His buttocks strain against his fatigues. This was Harlon Block, the athletic, independent-minded Texan. A star football player, he enlisted in the Marines along with all the seniors on his high school football team.
I pointed to the figure directly in back of my father: the boyish, freckle-faced Franklin Sousley, from Hilltop, Kentucky. He was fatherless at the age of nine and sailed for the Pacific on his nineteenth birthday.
Look closely at Franklin's hands, I asked the silent crowd in front of me. Do you see his right hand? Can you tell that the man in back of him has grasped Franklin's right hand and is helping Franklin push the heavy pole? The most boyish of the flag raisers, I said, is getting help from the most mature, Sergeant Mike Strank.
I pointed now to what can be seen of Mike. He is on the far side of Franklin. You can hardly see him. But his helping young Franklin was typical of him. He was respected as a great leader, a Marine's Marine. Finally I singled out the figure at the far left of the image—the figure stretching upward, his fingertips not quite reaching the pole. The Pima Indian from Arizona. Ira Hayes, I said. His hands couldn't quite grasp the pole.
Six boys. They form a representative picture of America in the thirties and forties: a mill worker from New England, a Kentucky tobacco farmer, a Pennsylvania coal miner's son, a Texan from the oil fields, a boy from Wisconsin's dairy land, and an Indian living on an Arizona reservation.
Only two of them walked off this island. A third was carried on a stretcher with shrapnel embedded in his side. Three were buried here.
Holy Land. Sacred ground.
All wars are boyish, and are fought by boys —Herman Melville
I'm not a professional researcher, but I figured that if I could somehow dig deep enough, I might be able to learn something about these six boys, and especially about my silent father. I could not do this task alone. I would need other people, relatives and comrades of these six figures, to help me.
I began my research by buying a book about Iwo Jima and reading it. Then another. And another. I have since lost count.
I found names in those books—the names of the boys shoving that flagpole aloft.
Back in my office, I started to trace them. I phoned city halls and sheriff's offices in the towns where the flag raisers were born and asked for leads that would put me in touch with their relatives. I dialed the numbers, then waited through the rings for that first "Hello?" from a widow, sister, or brother of one of the boys whose hands had gripped the iron pole on Suribachi.
I widened my phone searches to include living veterans of Iwo Jima. I wanted their memories, too. Eventually I began to travel to the places where these people lived.
I wanted to know them as Marines, as fighting men who were also comrades. But I also wanted to know them as boys, ordinary kids before they became warriors.
What I found was that these six boys were very different from one another: the whooping young Texas cowboy; the watchful Indian; the happy-go-lucky Kentucky hillbilly; the serious Wisconsin small-towner; the handsome New Hampshire mill worker; the sturdy Czech immigrant.
And yet so similar.
They were nearly all poor. The Great Depression was a thread that ran through their lives. But then so did football, and religious faith, and strong mothers. So did younger siblings, and the responsibility of caring for them. And nearly all were described again and again as quiet, shy boys, yet boys whom people cared about.
From the Hardcover edition.