Yeah, well ...
This book is a mixed bag of memories, and we must remember that they are the memories of a late teenager, transposed, if you will, by the ripened soul of his elder self in modern times. There are many reasons for those of us who did not serve in WWII or WWI to hold in high honor every single person who was a part of those efforts (including the wives and good souls at home, doing their part), but I've become a bit more cautious lately about pinning the "Golden Generation" laurels on each and every person with a war story. I say this because my father-in-law, a man I love dearly, was in Patton's army, just south of this author's group, and he saw just about the toughest time any one of us could imagine. And his sense of dignity, honor and humanity remained several degrees more intact than our author of "Foot Soldier". When you read this book, try not to start off with any assumption that the author is one of our grand old heroes whose saintly sacrifice renders his every word and deed honorable and excusable. Sit back and observe exactly what he is saying, what he admits to doing. Reflect, too, on how much utter sequential detail he is able to remember. Draw your own conclusions. One thing must be said, the author makes no attempt to gloss-over his weaknesses and failings, and only once does he try to justify certain behavior (looting). So I give credit where it is due that he is not making an exaggerated attempt to sound heroic or flawless, and I respect that. This book left me with lots of questions for my 85 year-old father-in-law. I asked: "Did you take personal posessions from bombed-out homes in France, Belgium and Germany." "No. That would be highly dishonorable." I asked: "Did you take the effects, guns, clothes or anything else from dead German soldiers?" "No. That would be a disgrace to them and to myself and my unit." I asked: "Did you take clothes or other effects from your dead allied comrades?" "In our unit, that might get you killed or ostracized from the group such that you might not receive support in critical battle circumstances." My jaw was on the floor. This book had made these activities seem routine -- almost justified in the sense of being "part of battle" or, in the case of clothes-stripping allied dead, "practical". I asked: "Did you have trouble marching from Normandy to Belgium?" (Our author tells of unbearable toil and several collapses on the road.) "Most everyone had trouble, but most of us set ourselves to do it, and did it. Most evenings when I removed my boots, dried blood tore and scratched from my ankles and feet inside the boot. The pain was so bad that you just rose above it and moved forward." I asked: "If you had wanted to, could you have collected scores of personal belongings from homes and dead soldiers and sent them to the US for "keepsakes"? "What man would do that?" I was asked. "What man could weasel-up to another dead soldier and go to work stripping his belongings from him -- stealing from him?" "And even if I wanted to do that, my unit would not have tolerated it. Every man on the battlefield was a soldier fighting for his country, and his effects were his alive, and his family's when dead." "No one in our unit had the TIME or the opportunity to carry on such "commerce" and collection, anyway. We lost most all of our belongings several times over in Eastern Belgium. I'd say if a man had time for detailed notes and looting and collecting during the war, his unit was not doing much fighting." So there I had it. Not necessarily any sort of higher-than-thou "truth", but quite clearly A DIFFERENT TAKE ALTOGETHER ON DIGNITY AND HEROISM, DUTY AND HUMANITY. My father in law was found in a ditch in Bastogne, asleep and freezing, having eaten only bits of his chocolate bar for four days. He had two men left, with him, in a unit of 85 men. He weighed 125 lbs. instead of his normal 190 lbs., and was sent
0 out of 1 people found this review helpful.
Was this review helpful? Yes NoThank you for your feedback.
Report this reviewThank you, this review has been flagged.
Overview
Roscoe C. Blunt's narrative of service with the 84th Infantry Division in World War II is one of the most remarkable that has come down to us. Blunt had nearly every type of combat experience and recorded his experiences in unforgettable, often chilling, prose.
What People Are Saying