Forms of Justice: Critical Perspectives on David Miller's Political Philosophy

by Daniel A. Bell (Editor), Avner de-Shalit (Editor), Daniel Attas (Contribution by), Erica Benner (Contribution by), Simon Caney (Contribution by)

Overview

What is justice? Great political philosophers from Plato to Rawls have traditionally argued that there is a single, principled answer to this question. Challenging this conventional wisdom, David Miller theorized that justice can take many different forms. In Forms of Justice, a distinguished group of political philosophers takes Miller's theory as a starting point and debates whether justice takes one form or many. Drawing real world implications from theories of justice and examining in depth social justice, national justice, and global justice, this book falls on the cutting edge of the latest developments in political theory. Sure to generate debate among political theorists and social scientists, Forms of Justice is indispensable reading for anyone attentive to the intersection between philosophy and politics.

Product Details

ISBN-13:	9780742521797
Publisher:	Rowman & Littlefield Publishers, Inc.
Publication date:	10/23/2002
Edition description:	2003
Pages:	400
Product dimensions:	6.00(w) x 8.88(h) x 0.88(d)

About the Author

Daniel A. Bell is associate professor in the Department of Public and Social Administration at the City University of Hong Kong. Avner de-Shalit teaches in the Department of Political Science at The Hebrew University of Jerusalem and is an associate fellow at the Oxford Centre for Environment, Ethics, and Society, Mansfield College, Oxford.

Table of Contents

Chapter 1 Introduction Part 2 Social Justice Chapter 3 Social Justice: Why Does It Matter What the People Think? Chapter 4 The Political Conditions of Social Justice Chapter 5 Meritocracy, Desert and the Moral Force of Intuitions Chapter 6 Desert and Luck Chapter 7 Markets and Desert Part 8 National Justice Chapter 9 Social Justice and the Nation State: A Modest Attack Chapter 10 What Rights for Illiberal Communities? Chapter 11 Deliberative Democracy: Guarantee for Justice or Preventing Injustice? Chapter 12 Minority Participation and Civic Education in Deliberative Democracies Chapter 13 Territorial Resolutions in Divided Societies Chapter 14 The Liberal Limits of Republican Nationality Chapter 15 Is Republican Citizenship Appropriate for the Modern World? Part 16 Global Justice Chapter 17 Republicanism, Patriotism, and Global Justice Chapter 18 Miller on Distributive Justice Chapter 19 Entitlements, Obligations, and Distributive Justice: The Global Level Chapter 20 Global Egalitarianism: An Undefensible Theory of Justice? Chapter 21 Nonbasic Environmental Goods and Social Justice Part 22 Forms of Justice Chapter 23 A Response

Editorial Reviews

...Forms of Justice should prove a first class resource for students of political philsosphy, especially, perhaps, for those who already know their way about. Overall, Forms of Justice is a thoughtful contribution to the philosophical analysis of justice.

Philosophical Books

Over the last three decades David Miller has established a reputation as one of the most important and controversial contributors to debates about the nature and limits of social justice and the boundaries of citizenship and national identity. Daniel A. Bell and Avner de-Shalit have brought together an international cast of political philosophers to criticise, explore and develop aspects of Miller's work. The book covers issues such as the nature and limits of desert, the justice of markets, the claims of nationality, the rights and obligations of citizenship and the extent of global justice, and concludes with a reply by Miller to his critics. The breadth and quality of contributions makes this book essential reading for all students of contemporary political philosophy. This is political philosophy at its best and fitting recognition of the continuing significance of Miller's work.

London School of Economics and Political Science

Rich, rewarding and refreshingly non-doctrinaire.. .. Paying tribute to David Miller's contextualized approach to issues of social and national justice, the contributors to this volume bring out the necessity of finding a balance between principles andpluralism in any responsible discourse on justice which would be of use in a perplexing and ever-changing world. This volume also shows how in their quest for justice, political philosophers need to go beyond a veil of ignorance by showing respect topeople's belief system and historical values in all their sometimes confusing variety

Shlomo Avineri

Over the last three decades David Miller has established a reputation as one of the most important and controversial contributors to debates about the nature and limits of social justice and the boundaries of citizenship and national identity. Daniel A. Bell and Avner de-Shalit have brought together an international cast of political philosophers to criticise, explore and develop aspects of Miller's work. The book covers issues such as the nature and limits of desert, the justice of markets, the claims of nationality, the rights and obligations of citizenship and the extent of global justice, and concludes with a reply by Miller to his critics. The breadth and quality of contributions makes this book essential reading for all students of contemporary political philosophy. This is political philosophy at its best and fitting recognition of the continuing significance of Miller's work.

London School of Economics and Political Science

An impressive collection of contributions that address a range of Miller's recent ideas. The editors have done a fabulous job in creating a discursive feel to the book, where the authors refer to one another and Miller responds eloquently. A great overview of contemporary issues in justice theory; perfect for graduate courses.

David Schlosberg

This collection of interesting and engaging papers serves not only as an introduction to his ideas and arguments, but also to contemporary political philosophy in general. The editors are to be applauded not only for assembling a good variety of contributors but also for organizing the papers into three neat parts.

The Philosophical Quarterly

Much more than a fitting tribute to Miller's political philosophy by a very impressive lineup, this collection is a fine critical exploration of social justice in all its forms.

John S. Dryzek

Over the last three decades David Miller has established a reputation as one of the most important and controversial contributors to debates about the nature and limits of social justice and the boundaries of citizenship and national identity. Daniel A. Bell and Avner de-Shalit have brought together an international cast of political philosophers to criticise, explore and develop aspects of Miller's work. The book covers issues such as the nature and limits of desert, the justice of markets, the claims of nationality, the rights and obligations of citizenship and the extent of global justice, and concludes with a reply by Miller to his critics. The breadth and quality of contributions makes this book essential reading for all students of contemporary political philosophy. This is political philosophy at its best and fitting recognition of the continuing significance of Miller's work.

Paul Kelly

Rich, rewarding and refreshingly non-doctrinaire. . . . Paying tribute to David Miller's contextualized approach to issues of social and national justice, the contributors to this volume bring out the necessity of finding a balance between principles and pluralism in any responsible discourse on justice which would be of use in a perplexing and ever-changing world.

This volume also shows how in their quest for justice, political philosophers need to go beyond a veil of ignorance by showing respect to people's belief system and historical values in all their sometimes confusing variety… Hebrew University of Jerusalem

From the Publisher

Much more than a fitting tribute to Miller's political philosophy by a very impressive lineup, this collection is a fine critical exploration of social justice in all its forms.

John Dryzek