Printed in 1906 in the "Münchner medizinische Wochenschrift" in München and originally titled "Die Hysterielehre Freuds. Eine Erwiderung auf die Aschaffenburgsche Kritik", this is an early detailed critique and discussion of Freud's theory on hysteria, specifically addressing Aschaffenburg's critique of this theory. This essay is not to be confused with a 1907 lecture (published 1908) titled "The Freudian Theory of Hysteria", which is a completely different manuscript.
In this seminal early work, Carl Gustav Jung, then an emerging voice in psychiatry, delivers a meticulous defence of Freud's pioneering theories of hysteria against the trenchant criticisms of Aschaffenburg. Jung navigates the contentious terrain of psychoanalytic theory with intellectual precision, setting the stage for his later divergences from Freud. The text delves into various aspects of Freud's ideas, including the role of sexuality in the development of psychoneuroses and the validity of Freud's psychological theories related to dreams, wit, and disturbances in everyday thinking. Jung's defense highlighted his deep engagement with Freud's ideas and his ability to articulate their significance in a broader psychological and cultural context. While supporting Freud, Jung also began to demonstrate his willingness to refine and expand psychoanalytic concepts. He pointed out the complexity of hysteria and suggested that it could not be fully understood by reductionist models, whether purely organic or narrowly psychoanalytic. This balanced approach not only strengthened the psychoanalytic position, but also hinted at Jung's emerging perspective on the psyche, which would later diverge significantly from Freud's sexual theory.
Aschaffenburg's critique rejected Freud's theory of hysteria, particularly the notion that repressed sexual trauma or unconscious sexual conflicts were central to the etiology of the disorder. Aschaffenburg argued for a more organic and behavioral explanation, in line with the dominant materialist and physiological approaches of the time. Jung's response sought to counter these claims by emphasizing the empirical and clinical basis of Freud's theories. He argued that Freud's emphasis on repression and the role of unconscious motives provided a more comprehensive understanding of hysteria than purely organic or environmental theories.
This updated edition features a modern, accessible translation designed to make Carl Jung's early scientific works—originally written for academic audiences—readable and engaging for contemporary readers. Complementing the translation is an illuminating Afterword by the translator, which delves into the philosophical foundations, historical context, and enduring relevance of Jung's ideas. The Afterword not only clarifies this particular work for today's audience but also situates it within the broader trajectory of Jung's intellectual and clinical development. Enhanced by a detailed timeline of Jung's life and works, along with other carefully curated supplementary materials, this edition provides rich context by embedding Jung's theories within his personal, cultural, and historical environment. By removing dense academic references and adopting clear, straightforward language, this translation invites both newcomers and seasoned scholars to explore the origins of Jungian psychology with fresh insight and accessibility.
1146357949
In this seminal early work, Carl Gustav Jung, then an emerging voice in psychiatry, delivers a meticulous defence of Freud's pioneering theories of hysteria against the trenchant criticisms of Aschaffenburg. Jung navigates the contentious terrain of psychoanalytic theory with intellectual precision, setting the stage for his later divergences from Freud. The text delves into various aspects of Freud's ideas, including the role of sexuality in the development of psychoneuroses and the validity of Freud's psychological theories related to dreams, wit, and disturbances in everyday thinking. Jung's defense highlighted his deep engagement with Freud's ideas and his ability to articulate their significance in a broader psychological and cultural context. While supporting Freud, Jung also began to demonstrate his willingness to refine and expand psychoanalytic concepts. He pointed out the complexity of hysteria and suggested that it could not be fully understood by reductionist models, whether purely organic or narrowly psychoanalytic. This balanced approach not only strengthened the psychoanalytic position, but also hinted at Jung's emerging perspective on the psyche, which would later diverge significantly from Freud's sexual theory.
Aschaffenburg's critique rejected Freud's theory of hysteria, particularly the notion that repressed sexual trauma or unconscious sexual conflicts were central to the etiology of the disorder. Aschaffenburg argued for a more organic and behavioral explanation, in line with the dominant materialist and physiological approaches of the time. Jung's response sought to counter these claims by emphasizing the empirical and clinical basis of Freud's theories. He argued that Freud's emphasis on repression and the role of unconscious motives provided a more comprehensive understanding of hysteria than purely organic or environmental theories.
This updated edition features a modern, accessible translation designed to make Carl Jung's early scientific works—originally written for academic audiences—readable and engaging for contemporary readers. Complementing the translation is an illuminating Afterword by the translator, which delves into the philosophical foundations, historical context, and enduring relevance of Jung's ideas. The Afterword not only clarifies this particular work for today's audience but also situates it within the broader trajectory of Jung's intellectual and clinical development. Enhanced by a detailed timeline of Jung's life and works, along with other carefully curated supplementary materials, this edition provides rich context by embedding Jung's theories within his personal, cultural, and historical environment. By removing dense academic references and adopting clear, straightforward language, this translation invites both newcomers and seasoned scholars to explore the origins of Jungian psychology with fresh insight and accessibility.
Freud's Theory of Hysteria: A reply to the Aschaffenburg critique
Printed in 1906 in the "Münchner medizinische Wochenschrift" in München and originally titled "Die Hysterielehre Freuds. Eine Erwiderung auf die Aschaffenburgsche Kritik", this is an early detailed critique and discussion of Freud's theory on hysteria, specifically addressing Aschaffenburg's critique of this theory. This essay is not to be confused with a 1907 lecture (published 1908) titled "The Freudian Theory of Hysteria", which is a completely different manuscript.
In this seminal early work, Carl Gustav Jung, then an emerging voice in psychiatry, delivers a meticulous defence of Freud's pioneering theories of hysteria against the trenchant criticisms of Aschaffenburg. Jung navigates the contentious terrain of psychoanalytic theory with intellectual precision, setting the stage for his later divergences from Freud. The text delves into various aspects of Freud's ideas, including the role of sexuality in the development of psychoneuroses and the validity of Freud's psychological theories related to dreams, wit, and disturbances in everyday thinking. Jung's defense highlighted his deep engagement with Freud's ideas and his ability to articulate their significance in a broader psychological and cultural context. While supporting Freud, Jung also began to demonstrate his willingness to refine and expand psychoanalytic concepts. He pointed out the complexity of hysteria and suggested that it could not be fully understood by reductionist models, whether purely organic or narrowly psychoanalytic. This balanced approach not only strengthened the psychoanalytic position, but also hinted at Jung's emerging perspective on the psyche, which would later diverge significantly from Freud's sexual theory.
Aschaffenburg's critique rejected Freud's theory of hysteria, particularly the notion that repressed sexual trauma or unconscious sexual conflicts were central to the etiology of the disorder. Aschaffenburg argued for a more organic and behavioral explanation, in line with the dominant materialist and physiological approaches of the time. Jung's response sought to counter these claims by emphasizing the empirical and clinical basis of Freud's theories. He argued that Freud's emphasis on repression and the role of unconscious motives provided a more comprehensive understanding of hysteria than purely organic or environmental theories.
This updated edition features a modern, accessible translation designed to make Carl Jung's early scientific works—originally written for academic audiences—readable and engaging for contemporary readers. Complementing the translation is an illuminating Afterword by the translator, which delves into the philosophical foundations, historical context, and enduring relevance of Jung's ideas. The Afterword not only clarifies this particular work for today's audience but also situates it within the broader trajectory of Jung's intellectual and clinical development. Enhanced by a detailed timeline of Jung's life and works, along with other carefully curated supplementary materials, this edition provides rich context by embedding Jung's theories within his personal, cultural, and historical environment. By removing dense academic references and adopting clear, straightforward language, this translation invites both newcomers and seasoned scholars to explore the origins of Jungian psychology with fresh insight and accessibility.
In this seminal early work, Carl Gustav Jung, then an emerging voice in psychiatry, delivers a meticulous defence of Freud's pioneering theories of hysteria against the trenchant criticisms of Aschaffenburg. Jung navigates the contentious terrain of psychoanalytic theory with intellectual precision, setting the stage for his later divergences from Freud. The text delves into various aspects of Freud's ideas, including the role of sexuality in the development of psychoneuroses and the validity of Freud's psychological theories related to dreams, wit, and disturbances in everyday thinking. Jung's defense highlighted his deep engagement with Freud's ideas and his ability to articulate their significance in a broader psychological and cultural context. While supporting Freud, Jung also began to demonstrate his willingness to refine and expand psychoanalytic concepts. He pointed out the complexity of hysteria and suggested that it could not be fully understood by reductionist models, whether purely organic or narrowly psychoanalytic. This balanced approach not only strengthened the psychoanalytic position, but also hinted at Jung's emerging perspective on the psyche, which would later diverge significantly from Freud's sexual theory.
Aschaffenburg's critique rejected Freud's theory of hysteria, particularly the notion that repressed sexual trauma or unconscious sexual conflicts were central to the etiology of the disorder. Aschaffenburg argued for a more organic and behavioral explanation, in line with the dominant materialist and physiological approaches of the time. Jung's response sought to counter these claims by emphasizing the empirical and clinical basis of Freud's theories. He argued that Freud's emphasis on repression and the role of unconscious motives provided a more comprehensive understanding of hysteria than purely organic or environmental theories.
This updated edition features a modern, accessible translation designed to make Carl Jung's early scientific works—originally written for academic audiences—readable and engaging for contemporary readers. Complementing the translation is an illuminating Afterword by the translator, which delves into the philosophical foundations, historical context, and enduring relevance of Jung's ideas. The Afterword not only clarifies this particular work for today's audience but also situates it within the broader trajectory of Jung's intellectual and clinical development. Enhanced by a detailed timeline of Jung's life and works, along with other carefully curated supplementary materials, this edition provides rich context by embedding Jung's theories within his personal, cultural, and historical environment. By removing dense academic references and adopting clear, straightforward language, this translation invites both newcomers and seasoned scholars to explore the origins of Jungian psychology with fresh insight and accessibility.
1.99
In Stock
5
1
Freud's Theory of Hysteria: A reply to the Aschaffenburg critique
Freud's Theory of Hysteria: A reply to the Aschaffenburg critique
Related collections and offers
1.99
In Stock
Product Details
| BN ID: | 2940185944783 |
|---|---|
| Publisher: | Minerva Heritage |
| Publication date: | 09/30/2024 |
| Sold by: | Barnes & Noble |
| Format: | eBook |
| File size: | 270 KB |
From the B&N Reads Blog