Global Warming

Global Warming

by Debra A. Miller
     
 

View All Available Formats & Editions


The Current Controversies series examines today's most important social and political issues; each volume presents a diverse selection of primary and secondary sources representing all sides of the debate in question.; Title explores issues related to global warming, including whether it is a scientifically proven phenomenon, whether global warming skeptics are… See more details below

Overview


The Current Controversies series examines today's most important social and political issues; each volume presents a diverse selection of primary and secondary sources representing all sides of the debate in question.; Title explores issues related to global warming, including whether it is a scientifically proven phenomenon, whether global warming skeptics are motivated by science, the predicted impacts of global warming, and what actions should be taken to address glo; Each anthology is composed of a wide spectrum of sources written by many of the foremost authorities in their respective fields. This unique approach provides students with a concise view of divergent opinions on each topic. Extensive book and periodical

Editorial Reviews

School Library Journal

Gr 8 Up

Complex factors are involved in any discussion of climate change, and although it is considered the most threatening of all concerns involving our planet, the variety of opinions and studies available to students can be confusing. This work attempts to provide information on the possible causes of global warming, the current and future effects, and solutions, and considers ways to prepare for the inevitable. Although the author repeatedly affirms that the vast majority of scientists and studies confirm ongoing warming, she does give many opportunities for deniers to voice their opinions. General information regarding solar, wind, and geothermal energy is included, as is the usual list of personal-habit changes that may, if followed worldwide, alleviate or defer the problem. The text seems somewhat dated in the discussions of Bush administration ideas being current policy and has no discussion of the effects of agribusiness and methane on global warming. The annotated bibliography is up-to-date to 2007.-Eva Elisabeth VonAncken, Trinity-Pawling School, Pawling, NY

VOYA - Lauri J. Vaughan
The four Current Controversy titles reviewed here feature between twenty and thirty-two brief opinion essays previously published elsewhere. The essays are evenly sorted among chapters that focus on specific questions. The table of contents includes a helpful abstract of each opinion. The first page of each article features a brief identification of the author—whether an individual or a foundation—and a footnote indicating its original publication. Every title includes an unauthored introduction and each chapter is briefly prefaced. Titles conclude with bibliographies and indices. As a whole, the books are attractive and readily accessible to teens. The absence of images is not a drawback as the pages are made subtly attractive with their italicized and colorful pull quotes, section headings, and rule lines. The liberal use of white space and a medium size font keep the content easy on the eyes. The weaknesses of the series, unfortunately, are plenty. The expertise of the authors is uneven and the explanations about them suspect. One wonders who wrote the text identifying TendersInfo News, the author of "E-book Pricing Should Be Decided by E-book Publishers." The explanation describes TendersInfo as a "leading business opportunity platform and information services company, providing the latest up-to-date information." Not only does this tag line sound like it came straight from a press release, the author line "TendersInfo News" is misleading. TendersInfo is a company, not a publication. Other identifiers are equally weak. Hassan Javid, author of "Although Weak, Some Secular Groups in Pakistan Are Fighting Religious Extremism," is identified as "a reporter who writes about Pakistan." Other weaknesses include unnecessarily outdated elements such as the introduction of Global Warming which predicts the "Kyoto Protocol is set to expire at the end of 2012." More problematic is the categorization of essays. To balance out the negative stance of the chapter entitled "Is Pakistan's Nuclear Arsenal Secure?" is an article about the country's energy crisis. Related? Yes. On topic? No. Beginning researchers doing superficial work will be satisfied, although they will do better if these sources are served up with an information literacy lesson on self-publishing, authority, audience and context. Serious debaters will see the flaws and look elsewhere. Subscribers to Gale's Opposing Viewpoints database will want to pass completely. (Current Controversies) Reviewer: Lauri J. Vaughan

Read More

Product Details

ISBN-13:
9780737740714
Publisher:
Cengage Gale
Publication date:
05/09/2008
Series:
Current Controversies Series
Pages:
189
Product dimensions:
6.00(w) x 9.00(h) x (d)
Age Range:
15 - 17 Years

Customer Reviews

Average Review:

Write a Review

and post it to your social network

     

Most Helpful Customer Reviews

See all customer reviews >