Groupthink Versus High-Quality Decision Making in International Relations

Groupthink Versus High-Quality Decision Making in International Relations

3.5 2
by Mark Schafer, Scott Crichlow
     
 

View All Available Formats & Editions

ISBN-10: 0231148895

ISBN-13: 9780231148894

Pub. Date: 04/22/2010

Publisher: Columbia University Press

Are good and bad outcomes significantly affected by the decision-making process itself? Indeed they are, in that certain decision-making techniques and practices limit the ability of policymakers to achieve their goals and advance the national interest.

The success of policy often turns on the quality of the decision-making process. Mark Schafer and Scott

Overview

Are good and bad outcomes significantly affected by the decision-making process itself? Indeed they are, in that certain decision-making techniques and practices limit the ability of policymakers to achieve their goals and advance the national interest.

The success of policy often turns on the quality of the decision-making process. Mark Schafer and Scott Crichlow identify the factors that contribute to good and bad policymaking, such as the personalities of political leaders, the structure of decision-making groups, and the nature of the exchange between participating individuals. Analyzing thirty-nine foreign-policy cases across nine administrations and incorporating both statistical analyses and case studies, including a detailed examination of the decision to invade Iraq in 2003, the authors pinpoint the factors that are likely to lead to successful or failed decision making, and they suggest ways to improve the process. Schafer and Crichlow show how the staffing of key offices and the structure of central decision-making bodies determine the path of an administration even before topics are introduced. Additionally, they link the psychological characteristics of leaders to the quality of their decision processing. There is no greater work available on understanding and improving the dynamics of contemporary decision making.

Product Details

ISBN-13:
9780231148894
Publisher:
Columbia University Press
Publication date:
04/22/2010
Edition description:
New Edition
Pages:
304
Product dimensions:
5.90(w) x 8.90(h) x 0.60(d)
Age Range:
18 Years

Table of Contents

List of Tables and Figures ix

Acknowledgments xi

Part I Groupthink and the Quality of the Foreign-Policy Decision-Making Process

1 Introduction 5

2 The Group and the Individual in Foreign-Policy Decision Making 18

3 The Decision-Making Model: The Interplay of Group Processes and Psychological Characteristics 53

Part II Case Studies in American Foreign-Policy Decision Making

4 Case Studies in Low-Quality Decision Making 81

The Garter Administration and the Shah 82

Reagan Funding the Contras, 1981 92

Reagan's Strategic Defense Initiative 103

George W. Bush and the 2002 Steel Tariffs 113

5 Case Studies in High-Quality Decision Making 123

The Carter Administration and the Ogaden Crisis 123

The Reagan Administration and Easing Ferdinand Marcos out of Power 132

The Clinton Administration and South Asia: Nuclear Capabilities and Another War Over Kashmir 143

Part III Statistical Analyses

6 The Effect of Groupthink Versus High-Quality Decision Making on Outcomes 157

7 Individual-Level Factors Affecting the Quality of Decision Making 188

Part IV Conclusions

8 The 2003 War in Iraq: How Flawed Decision Making Led to Critical Failures 211

9 Groupthink Versus High-Quality Decision Making: Lessons and Prescriptions 237

Appendix A Cases Included in the Analysis 251

Appendix B Operational Definitions of Situational-Context Variables 255

Appendix C Operational Definitions of Group-Structural Variables 257

Appendix D Operational Definitions of Decision-Processing Variables 259

Notes 261

References 265

Index 279

Customer Reviews

Average Review:

Write a Review

and post it to your social network

     

Most Helpful Customer Reviews

See all customer reviews >

Groupthink Versus High-Quality Decision Making in International Relations 4 out of 5 based on 0 ratings. 1 reviews.
Anonymous More than 1 year ago
`Main Shops` :: <br> `Metal` [ Jewelry ] <br> `Hot Box Systems` [ Clothing ] <br> `Storm Signal Technologies` [ Parts ] <p> `Restaurants` :: <br> `Fusion Historia` <p> ~~~ <p> `Outside` :: Appears to be designed like an old manor. Tall towers spiral from the copper-shingled rooftop, now green with age. Only accessable by airship or tram. <p> `Inside` :: Spacious with tile floor and a grand fountain in the inside courtyard. Plush victorian loveseats line the halls, along with ornate lamps and mahogony and oak side tables. Heavy velvet drapes frame the windows and a glass dome filters noon-day light through the high-vaulted ceiling. Tropical trees fill the corner and English ivy hangs from ceramic vases placed on shelves high above the walkways.