"Haunting beauty masks your ill intent"--"Angel of Light" by Dark Lay Still, which was running through my head while I read this book.
Bear with me, this will be long. Note: this review is being written by someone who is a Christian. Despite that I share the beliefs of the author, I was offended. The message I got from this book was: be a good Christian, go to church every Sunday, and if you're different in any way, you can't express it; you're evil if you do so. You much suppress the interests God gave you for His own reasons, or you're going to Hell. Here are the finer points that warrant the one star rating. 1. Beth should have fallen. I cannot believe that God would be okay with a human falling in love with an angel, and the angel returning his feelings. Beth put Xav before God and her mission. She should have fallen. Lucifer fell because he put himself before God. Beth is doing the same thing. 2. I did not find Xavier romantic at all. Rather, I found him to be so flawless that it was sickening. Maybe it's because I'm not the target age group, but I find a character with flaws to be more compelling. In fact, it none one had flaws of any type. 3. Beth had no personality at all. She was incredibly weak, especially for an angel. The number of times she had to be rescued only showed this. "A shadowy figure with blurred features was approaching. At first my heart leapt with the possibility that it might be Xavier come to rescue me...." You're having a nightmare about falling from grace, yet this boy is the first thing on your mind, even at such a horrible moment? I did not find Beth to be a good Christian example. She treats people in other cultures horribly (see my comment about Goths.) She only does good things when she happens to be there, she does not seek opportunities to do good. She ignores people who might need her help, putting the "ache in her chest" before everything else. 4. The angels found modern technology to be "a corrupting influence, promoting anti-social behavior and detracting from family values." I'm legally blind, and if we didn't have modern technology, I might not be going to college this fall. Technology can be used to help people. 5. Why were the angels even in this town? Oh yeah, they were waiting for Jake Thorn... 6. He wears all black, rides a motorcycle, and has a tattoo of a snake. He's eeeevil. He's also the worst villain I've ever read. All of his followers are Goths. I met some Goths at a festival, I found them to be very nice people and I enjoyed their company. I was offended by how people in this subculture were treated in this book. They're basically treated like they're sided with the devil. 7. Mythology mistakes. I saw basic things that were wrong. 1. The angel Gabriel was a MESSENGER not a warrior. 2. The fall of Soddom and Gomorrah happened THOUSANDS of years ago, not hundreds. 3. Satan is NOT the king of Hell. Hell is a place of punishment, not a reward. 4. Demons were angels who sided with Lucifer and fell with him. 5. Lucifer was a SERAPH not an archangel. I could go on, but I don't want to. I was deeply offended by the message I picked up, and will not be reading any more of this author. Yes, this book is clean (sex before marriage is portrayed in a very negative light, an if-you-do-this-you'll-go-to-Hell sort of light) and there's very little violence. Teens will love it "because it has a HOT GUY in it!!!" but because of what's beneath the surface, I would skip this one.
2 out of 2 people found this review helpful.
Was this review helpful? Yes NoThank you for your feedback.
Report this reviewThank you, this review has been flagged.