Hamlet's Choice: Religion and Resistance in Shakespeare's Revenge Tragedies

by Peter Lake

Overview

An illuminating account of how Shakespeare worked through the tensions of Queen Elizabeth’s England in two canon-defining plays

Conspiracies and revolts simmered beneath the surface of Queen Elizabeth’s reign. England was riven with tensions created by religious conflict and the prospect of dynastic crisis and regime change.
 
In this rich, incisive account, Peter Lake reveals how in Titus Andronicus and Hamlet Shakespeare worked through a range of Tudor anxieties, including concerns about the nature of justice, resistance, and salvation. In both Hamlet and Titus the princes are faced with successions forged under questionable circumstances and they each have a choice: whether or not to resort to political violence. The unfolding action, Lake argues, is best understood in terms of contemporary debates about the legitimacy of resistance and the relation between religion and politics. Relating the plays to their broader political and polemical contexts, Lake sheds light on the nature of revenge, resistance, and religion in post-Reformation England.

Product Details

ISBN-13:	9780300256703
Publisher:	Yale University Press
Publication date:	07/21/2020
Sold by:	Barnes & Noble
Format:	eBook
Pages:	224
File size:	8 MB

About the Author

Peter Lake is University Distinguished Professor of History and Martha Rivers Ingram Chair of History at Vanderbilt University. He is the author of How Shakespeare Put Politics on the Stage, Bad Queen Bess?,and The Antichrist's Lewd Hat.

Table of Contents

List of Plates vi

Acknowledgements viii

Introduction 1

Part I Titus Andronicus

Chapter 1 Succession and confessional politics combined 17

Chapter 2 Tyranny delineated 35

Chapter 3 Beyond paganism and politics 53

Part II Hamlet

Chapter 4 Hamlet with the confessional and succession politics left in 73

Chapter 5 The generic matrix: revenge tragedy, history play, murder pamphlet and conversion narrative 98

Chapter 6 The (providential) purposes of playing 110

Chapter 7 The politics of conscience 120

Chapter 8 Contemporary resonances 164

Conclusion Pagan/Catholic/Protestant/Christian 179

Notes 192

Further reading 209

Index 211

Editorial Reviews

Lake’s conclusions are striking, unexpected, and even revelatory. . . . In its openness, Lake’s performance here shows that accounts of history may be approached like plays as well as plays approached for history.”—William N. West, Studies in English Literature 1500–1900

“Taking Hamlet’s Choice together with How Shakespeare Put Politics on Stage, Peter Lake has established himself as one of the principal voices of the historical contextualization of Shakespeare.”—Stephen Greenblatt

“Compelling. . . . A strikingly fresh and rich account of what religion and resistance meant in Elizabethan England, Hamlet’s Choice is required reading for historians, theologians and Shakespeareans.”—Tiffany Stern, general editor of the fourth series of Arden Shakespeare

“The depth of Peter Lake’s historical research shows just how these plays’ urgent questions kept the audience on the edges of their seats.”—David Norbrook, author of Poetry and Politics in the English Renaissance

“With great deftness, Lake startlingly and compellingly connects the worlds of stage revenge, religious conversion and political allegiance. To read Hamlet’s Choice is as clarifying and cathartic as a great performance of a revenge play itself.”—Nigel Smith, author of Andrew Marvell: The Chameleon

From the Publisher