Here and Then

Here and Then

3.5 2
by George Ella Lyon

View All Available Formats & Editions

Editorial Reviews

Publishers Weekly - Publisher's Weekly
Joining her history-buff parents for a weekend reenactment of the Civil War at Camp Robinson, Ky., seventh-grader Abby ``gets into character'' by keeping a journal for Eliza, the 40-year-old nurse she is to portray. The past intertwines with the present when Abby realizes her writing is being guided by the restless spirit of her character-dead nearly 80 years-who sends an urgent message to bring more supplies forthe wounded soldiers. With the help of a skeptical but loyal friend, Abby collects blankets, bandages and medicine, and transports them back in time. While much of the book, particularly the girls' door-to-door solicitation of money for their cause, is infused with tongue-in-cheek humor, Abby's journey to another century proves to be poignant as well as eerie. Compelling if not altogether meaty, Lyon's (Red Rover, Red Rover; Borrowed Children) slim novel about ghostly encounters and transfigurations quite literally brings history to life. Ages 10-12. (Oct.)
School Library Journal - School Library Journal
Gr 5-7-In a first-person narrative, 12-year-old Abby tells what she knows to be true-that 40-year-old Eliza Hoskins, the ``Angel of Camp Robinson,'' has requested supplies from her to treat her sick and wounded Civil War soliders. Abby and her parents are part of a group of modern-day ``reenactors'' who have just spent a weekend at the camp near Lexington, Kentucky. When Abby, playing the part of Eliza, begins a journal, she realizes that the voice is not her own but rather it is Eliza's, asking for help. After convincing her practical friend Harper of the truth of what has happened, the girls work out ways to raise money and buy supplies. With Eliza's intervention, Abby is able to deliver them to 1861. Lyon's evocative style convinces Harper and readers that extraordinary times lead to extraordinary events. The theme of ``war is hell'' is movingly conveyed by a tightly woven plot and a strong sense of place.-Amy Kellman, The Carnegie Library of Pittsburgh
Janice Del Negro
Seventh-grader Abby is pleasing her parents by joining in a Civil War reenactment, playing the part of Eliza Hoskins, a woman who nursed the wounded from both North and South. But Abby is doing more than playing the part. She and Eliza have somehow connected across time. Abby "becomes" Eliza, hearing her thoughts in her head, writing Eliza's words in her journal, even going back in time to experience Eliza's life firsthand. With the help of her tolerant best friend Harper, Abby delivers supplies from the present to help Eliza save lives in the past. The story is slight but is well paced and does have the occasional powerful moment as Abby reacts to the horrors of war as seen through Eliza's eyes. This may act as a springboard for more defined time-travel stories.

Product Details

Scholastic, Inc.
Publication date:
Product dimensions:
5.71(w) x 8.51(h) x 0.65(d)
Age Range:
9 - 12 Years

Customer Reviews

Average Review:

Write a Review

and post it to your social network


Most Helpful Customer Reviews

See all customer reviews >

Here and Then 3.5 out of 5 based on 0 ratings. 2 reviews.
Guest More than 1 year ago
The book was good but a little complacated Because Abby had a lot of dreams about Eliza.Also it was good because it hade a lot of good detal and perscraption.The type of book it would be is mostly a mistery because abby and harper didn't know all about Eliza so they did rescherch on her since abby was in a reinactment group with her parents. So in all it was a pretty good book and i advise u all to try to read it some time.
Guest More than 1 year ago
This book doesn't really give information about the civil war or tell a story about the civil war but it's an o.k. book. It's about a girl whose parents are Civil war reenactors and she meets a ghost while staying somewhere with her parents where they did a reenactment. She ends up helping the ghost and it's a neat story but it's not that great of a book but it is very short and takes no time to read so if you want just a short enjoyable book with a nice story then I reccommend this book.