"Holding a Tender Heart is of course a love story, but what was so impressive (and frankly, a welcome relief) was that there were many unexpected turns in the book. This book had more substance than just boy meets girl, they fall in love, and everyone lives happily ever after. I definitely enjoyed this book, and look forward to many months of happy reading with Jerry Eicher's books at my side."
"I found this book to be charming, and well written (of course due to Mr. Eicher's talent). The characters are real and became very endearing to me. I look forward to reading the rest of this series."
"Jerry Eicher's books on Amish life are unique in that he was raised Amish, which give them an authenticity missing in many of the other books in this genre. Holding a Tender Heart is no exception. Jerry gives us characters who always sound real and that we can relate to easily."
"This story has much excitement and adventure."
"Another wonderful story by Jerry."
—Wendy Newcomb, wrensthoughts.blogspot.com
"There are interesting subplots along the way to keep your mind alert throughout the book. The author uses wit as well as compassion to keep the reader engrossed in the story."
—Karla Hanns, karla-hanns-karla.blogspot.com
"Whether it is the superb writing or the wonderful plot, you will find the book nearly impossible to put down. From the first word, the story will draw you in and you may even find yourself praying at 4am that everything will, somehow, turn out right for the characters."
"Are you ready for a reading adventure? This is what you will get in this great read by Jerry S. Eicher. This author's books just keep getting better and better. I am certain that I have not read another Amish fiction book like this one."
"I love Jerry Eicher's books; he is a very talented writer. And this book was another one of his greats."
"I couldn't put this book down once I started reading it. I can't wait for book two to see if Debbie really converts to the Amish faith."