Uh-oh, it looks like your Internet Explorer is out of date.

For a better shopping experience, please upgrade now.

Hush Money: A Mystery

Hush Money: A Mystery

4.5 4
by Chuck Greaves

See All Formats & Editions

A Finalist for Private Eye Writers of America's Shamus Award for Best First P.I. Novel
A Finalist for Left Coast Crime's 2013 Rocky Award
When Hush Puppy, Pasadena socialite Sydney Everett's champion show horse, dies under suspicious circumstances, junior lawyer Jack MacTaggart is assigned to handle the insurance claim. But the case soon


A Finalist for Private Eye Writers of America's Shamus Award for Best First P.I. Novel
A Finalist for Left Coast Crime's 2013 Rocky Award
When Hush Puppy, Pasadena socialite Sydney Everett's champion show horse, dies under suspicious circumstances, junior lawyer Jack MacTaggart is assigned to handle the insurance claim. But the case soon takes an unexpected turn, thrusting Jack into a spiraling web of blackmail and murder in which he finds himself both the prime suspect and the next likely victim.

In this acclaimed debut novel, the first in a series, former Los Angeles trial lawyer Chuck Greaves takes readers into the high-stakes worlds of big-firm litigation and professional equestrian show-jumping, where no one can be trusted, and where nothing is quite what it seems.

Editorial Reviews

Publishers Weekly
Near the outset of Greaves’s stellar first novel, Hush Puppy, a healthy champion show horse, suddenly drops dead. Hush Puppy’s vet suspects the horse was poisoned and the animal’s owner, Pasadena socialite Sydney Everett, faces charges of fraud. Attorney Jack McTaggert agrees to defend Everett, but his doubts about his client’s innocence increase after he learns that another of her animals died five years earlier, netting Everett a million insurance payout. Meanwhile, the lawyer must deal with a civil case involving a blue-collar worker suffering from terminal leukemia unable to get coverage for a new procedure. The insurance fraud case soon turns deadly for humans as well, placing McTaggert directly in the crosshairs both of the police and the criminal behind the plot. Greaves makes the most of his 25 years as a trial attorney in relating courtroom tactics. The combination of confident writing and a determined and ethical protagonist add up to a winner. Agent: Antonella Iannarino, the David Black Literary Agency. (May)
From the Publisher

Hush Money is a fast-paced, funny mystery and Jack MacTaggart is a delightful, wise-cracking hero. I hope we see more of him.” —Phillip Margolin, author of Capitol Murder

“Superbly written and paced, this sensational legal thriller reads like a polished jewel. Set in the Mercedes and Rolex horse show world, Greaves sports a smoking new voice in crime fiction, reminiscent of John Hart. Hush Money's riveting characters and snappy dialogue round out a smashingly memorable first effort. Chuck Greaves has major writing chops.” —Julia Spencer-Fleming, New York Times bestselling author of One Was a Soldier

“Take John D. MacDonald’s Travis McGee, Jonathan Kellerman’s Alex Delaware, and the best of John Grisham’s protagonists, shake and serve, and you’ll have the hero of Hush Money. Chuck Greaves has written a confident, cool and totally engrossing legal thriller with the pop and sizzle of some of the greats of the genre. It’s a hell of a debut.” —Chelsea Cain, New York Times bestselling author

“One heck of a debut, and a welcome addition to the genre. Jack MacTaggart is a joy to root for, and there are enough twists and turns to keep you up way past bedtime. A thoroughly enjoyable mystery.” —Ira Berkowitz, author of 2010 Shamus Award-winning Sinners’ Ball

“Chuck Greaves writes with style and an insider's knowledge of the courtroom and the lawyer's life. Hush Money is smart, entertaining and funny. And in Jack MacTaggart he has created a likeable, wise-cracking lawyer-detective” —Jim Rockford with a law degree. A great read."

“Greaves' debut mystery, Hush Money, sparks with snappy dialog, rich imagery, and sarcasm sharp as a razor. Early in the book, the line, ‘…above the blooms, like a spider at the center of her web, floated the head and shoulders of a smallish woman, her darting eyes alert to the activity around her," told this reader she'd stumbled upon darn good writing.” —Sasscer Hill, author of Agatha and Macavity Best First Mystery nominee, Full Mortality

“Greaves makes the most of his 25 years as a trial attorney in relating courtroom tactics. The combination of confident writing and a determined and ethical protagonist add up to a winner.” —Publishers Weekly (starred review)

“Cleverly intermingles equestrian show jumping, insurance claims, and high-tech science in this sunny California thriller. Great readalikes for tone would be Jack Fredrickson and Spencer Quinn.” —Library Journal (starred review)

“An auspicious debut. Jack [MacTaggart] would be welcome back in the winner's circle any time.” —Kirkus Reviews

“With its whoa, boy!" central character, sharp dialogue, and hit-the-spot Southern California venues, this is a series with plenty of potential.” —Yahoo! Shine

“If you combine the horse-centered suspenses of Dick Francis with the legal thrillers of John Grisham you'll have Chuck Greaves and his first novel, Hush Money.” —The Chronicle of the Horse

“This is a first novel that promises much pleasure to come for a long time; the very likable lawyer central character will surely be the basis of a series.” —Sullivan County Democrat

“A great debut novel.” —Algona Upper Des Moines

“A sexy, funny, rollicking good show from start to finish.” —Winnipeg Free Press

“Fast-paced and inspired, written with an insider's knowledge of the legal world, it's a terrific addition to the genre, and one hopes there will be more Jack stories.” —RT Book Reviews

“Like a nicely-executed jumper ride. The rhythm flowed from the steadiness of a well-paced triple combination to the accurately frantic fun of a jump off. And let's just say that Hush Money had a clean round with no time faults. … An intelligent murder mystery played by actors unique and strong in character. Whatever the story that Greaves shares next, Jack will be welcome.” —The Equestrian News

Library Journal
When Sydney Everett's Olympic-caliber jumping horse, Hush Puppy, dies suddenly, her law firm jumps into action, sending out young Pasadena, CA, attorney Jack MacTaggart. Sydney is worth watching because another horse she owned died under suspicious circumstances just a few years earlier. Jack follows a circuitous paper trail and learns that Sydney was guilty of insurance fraud that first time, and someone within the club has been blackmailing her ever since. Jack knows he's hot on the trail when the next death turns out to be that of his mentor at the law firm. Stable manager Tara Flynn clues in Jack to the riding club's dirt and also provides romantic interest and an investigative assistant he can trust. Meanwhile, Jack's other case, about medical insurance, gives him the break he needs. VERDICT Winner of the SouthWest Writers (SWW) grand-prize Storyteller Award for 2010, trial lawyer Greaves's delightful debut, which the SWW also named Best Mystery of 2010, cleverly intermingles equestrian show jumping, insurance claims, and high-tech science in this sunny California thriller. Great readalikes for tone would be Jack Fredrickson and Spencer Quinn. [Greaves's second book, Hard Twisted, was named best historical novel of 2010 by the SouthWest Writers and will be published by Bloomsbury USA this fall.—Ed.]
Kirkus Reviews
Greaves' ebullient first novel asks who killed a beloved horse and how—and shows some interest in human casualties as well. Because Jared Henley, the founder's grandson who usually carries water for horsey Pasadena dowager Sydney Everett, is off on vacation somewhere, Henley & Hargrove's director of litigation, Russell Dinsmoor, persuades Jack MacTaggart, who's Of Counsel to the firm, to step in when Hush Puppy, Sydney's Holsteiner stallion, dies suddenly and the pencil-pushers of Metropolitan Livestock Insurance decline to pay her claim. And no wonder, since Sydney made a tidy profit from the conveniently timed death of her injured horse Creole some years back, and veterinarian George Wells tells Jack that Hush Puppy's death looks equally squirrelly. Jack tears himself away from the lawsuit he's filed against the even less sympathetic insurer Hartford Allied on behalf of leukemia-stricken trash collector Victor Tazerian long enough to involve himself with Tara Flynn, stable manager at the Fieldstone Riding Club, and unearth an unholy paper trail leading right back to Henley & Hargrove. He can only wonder what Russ Dinsmoor would say about the whole mess, since Dinsmoor is as dead as Hush Puppy, brained by someone who evidently thought he knew too much about a densely layered scam involving blackmail, off-the-books medical research and serial equine murder. Don't let all the legal shenanigans put you off: Jack, a highly unselective wiseacre, has a lighthearted anecdote for every occasion, including attacks on his own august person. An auspicious debut. Jack would be welcome back in the winner's circle any time.

Product Details

St. Martin's Press
Publication date:
A Jack MacTaggart Mystery , #1
Sold by:
Sales rank:
File size:
747 KB

Related Subjects

Read an Excerpt

Hush Money

By Chuck Greaves

St. Martin's Press

Copyright © 2012 Charles J. Greaves
All rights reserved.
ISBN: 978-1-4668-0248-3


It was a Thursday afternoon, almost five o'clock, and I was typing feverishly in the knowledge that by 5:01, Bernadette would be long gone. Reliability is a rare quality in a legal secretary, and when it came to quitting time, Bernie Catalano was a regular Old Faithful.

I was drafting a letter to the local claims manager of the Hartford Allied Insurance Company, which had issued a policy of health insurance to my client, Victor Tazerian. Victor was a fifty-four-year-old Armenian trash hauler whose leukemia was temporarily in remission. Hartford Allied, to the bewilderment of the Tazerian family, was refusing to pay for a new but promising medical procedure that involved harvesting and freezing Victor's own bone marrow while he was healthy, so that it later could be transplanted back into his body when the cancer made its inevitable return.

Hartford Allied reasoned that as long as the cancer was in remission, no surgery was warranted. In other words, they wouldn't pay for the procedure until Victor got sick again, and of course, once he got sick again, the procedure would be useless.

In the vernacular of my profession, this was called insurance bad faith — a state of affairs to which, in its many and varied forms, I was no stranger. As I'd tried to explain to Victor's sobbing wife Lina, the insurance industry operates in strict accordance with the three rules of American capitalism: invest someone else's money, make a profit, and try to keep both.

And so Victor Tazerian lay in a pre-op ward at the City of Hope National Medical Center awaiting a surgical procedure that costs more than he'll earn in a lifetime, while Hartford Allied's regional claims manager stood by his fax machine in Thousand Oaks waiting for a demand letter from me that we both knew he had no intention of honoring. Lina, meanwhile, sat by her telephone in Glendale wearing out her worry beads, while Bernadette, bless her heart, was eyeing the digital clock on her desk next to her car keys.

And that's the precise moment that Russ Dinsmoor chose to burst into my office and announce that Hush Puppy was dead.

I shot him a side glance and kept on typing.

"Shouldn't Buster Brown be notified?"

"Hush Puppy is a horse, you philistine. A very valuable horse belonging to Mrs. Everett, who, need I remind you, is a very valuable client of the firm."

None of which concerned me in the least, and so I ignored him, in the faint hope that he'd simply go away.

"I need you over at Fieldstone right away," he persisted. "Jared's out of town, and Sydney is beside herself with grief."

Sydney Everett, I knew by reputation, was one of the wealthiest old dowagers in Pasadena, a city positively freighted with women of a certain age who'd made their fortunes the old-fashioned way. Which is to say, by outliving their husbands. I also knew that a felicitously large percentage of these women happened to be clients of the city's oldest and snobbiest law firm, Henley & Hargrove, under whose yoke I presently toiled.

Jared would be Jared Henley, who, although not the brightest bulb in the Henley & Hargrove chandelier, was the only grandson of the firm's founder and, I surmised, the partner currently assigned to wipe when Mrs. Everett's nose started to run. Characteristically, however, Jared was vacationing in Cancún, or Bimini, or wherever it was that slow-witted grandchildren with trust funds went to mate with others of their kind.

"Why me?" I finally asked, glancing up from my screen. "I don't know a fetlock from a half nelson."

"Because there are two insurance adjusters out there as we speak, and we don't want there to be any trouble."

Deftly, painlessly, Russ Dinsmoor had sunk the hook.

"Trouble? Why would there be trouble?"

"I'll fill you in on the details later, Mac. For now, we must let slip the dogs of war!" He threw his hands skyward, then joined them together in prayer. "Please, big fella? For me?"

I caught a faint whiff of horse manure right there in my office, but I could see that Russ was genuinely concerned.

"All right already, I'm slipping. Just get out of here and let me finish this."

When I finally brought the letter out to Bernie, at exactly 4:59 P.M., she was sitting with her long legs crossed, filing her fingernails.

"Isn't that a little cliché?" I asked.

"No," she said, frowning at the clock. "It's a friggin' emery board."

* * *

It was a ten-minute drive from Pasadena to the nearby suburb of Flintridge, a bucolic burg best known, where known at all, as the home of the NASA Jet Propulsion Laboratory. That's where they design and build all nature of moon rockets, Mars probes, and other esoteric space projects whose only societal benefit, as near as I could tell, was to keep Caltech graduates from defaulting on their student loans.

A quiet enclave of broad lawns and stately mansions, Flintridge had a reputation as one of the more affluent cities in the sprawling megalopolis of Southern California, a part of the world in which affluence, like Kardashians, seemed to be everywhere.

It was almost five thirty when I rolled the Wrangler up to the gatehouse of the Fieldstone Riding Club, and was there greeted by a wizened old codger with a clipboard. He wore what looked like the Gilbert and Sullivan interpretation of a military dress uniform, and I stifled an impulse to salute.

"Jack MacTaggart," I announced, "to see Sydney Everett."

He cast a dubious eye on the Jeep as he flipped through his list of authorized guests.

"Look, I'm probably not on there, but I'm Mrs. Everett's lawyer. From Henley and Hargrove."

I must have spoken the magic words, because he nodded and waved me through, pointing me past an emphatic MEMBERS ONLY sign and up a macadam driveway where the air seemed cooler somehow, laden as it was with the vaguely menthol scent of eucalyptus. The sun was low, the shadows were long, and the light filtering through the treetops was a glass-blown kind of opalescent amber.

I parked in an otherwise empty lot beside what looked like a sprawling hacienda, its walls of whitewashed plaster quaintly moldering under a mission tile roof. The clubhouse, like the rolling grounds it commanded, looked eerily deserted. I cut the engine, surveyed the surroundings, and did some quick arithmetic.

Even in a down real estate market, I figured that an unimproved half-acre lot in Flintridge, if you could find such a thing, went for a million bucks or so, depending on the location. This place looked to be over a hundred acres, and it sat in one of the tonier neighborhoods, bordered on the east by JPL and the parklands of the Arroyo Seco, and on the north by the lilac-colored foothills of the Angeles National Forest.

I didn't know how many members they had here, or the buy-in cost of a membership, but the breakup value of this place had to be enough to launch a couple of those satellites from across the road.

I shrugged into my suit jacket and set off on foot, following a dirt path that wended northward toward the hills. Songbirds were trilling in the massive oaks, and a red-tail hawk hung silently overhead. Not a bad place, I told myself, to spend your idle hours chasing foxes, or Democrats, or whatever they did around here for sport.

And then, as if a soundtrack to that reverie, I heard the rhythmic drum of hoofbeats, and I turned to see a young woman astride a gleaming black horse that grew in its approach to the approximate size of a mastodon. I stepped to one side, but she halted the thundering beast on a dime without so much as a tug on the reins. It was a pretty neat trick.

"You look lost," she informed me, flashing a smile from on high.

"Were the wing tips a giveaway?"

"They're not very practical around here, I'm afraid."

She had the wholesome good looks of a J.Crew catalog model, all dark eyebrows and high cheekbones. She wore a dirty polo shirt and khaki riding breeches that disappeared, just at the knee, into tall black boots. She was slender and tanned, and her hair spilled like a gusher of sweet crude from the back of a faded baseball cap.

I edged closer and reached up a hand.

"I'm Jack MacTaggart."

"Faith and begorra!" she laughed in a comic brogue as she leaned over to shake. "I'm Tara Flynn. And this" — she patted the big horse on its neck — "is Escalator."

I stepped back to regard the horse, which was ignoring us both and cropping at a strip of grass by the path. It was the largest living thing I'd seen outside of a zoo.

"Let me guess. Shetland pony?"

She smiled again.

"He's a Hanoverian, actually. But sweet like a pony."

"That's good," I said, "because if he ever gets testy, we'll have to call out the National Guard."

"Oh, he can be plenty testy. But a carrot usually does the trick."

The horse raised its head long enough to deposit some greenish slime on my pant leg. I scratched him lightly between the ears.

"I don't suppose you've seen a couple of beady-eyed weasels in business suits skulking about the place, have you?"

Her smile faded.

"Are you here about Hush Puppy?"

"That's right. I'm one of Mrs. Everett's lawyers."

She considered that for a moment, then gathered up the reins and turned the big horse ninety degrees to port. She pointed with her chin to some buildings off in the distance.

"If you head that way and look for Doc Wells's truck — it's a big white pickup — you'll find them all there." Then she added wistfully, "What a nightmare."

"I guess Mrs. Everett's pretty broken up about it?"

"Oh, I wouldn't count on that," she said, wheeling the horse around. "It was nice to meet you, Jack. I hope you're a good lawyer."

* * *

In the courtyard central to the four barns sat a white pickup truck, its tailgate down, alongside a silver Chevy compact and a burgundy Jaguar. Arrayed on the pickup's tailgate were what looked like instruments of persuasion from the Spanish Inquisition — tongs and calipers, blades and files, hooks and giant syringes. I heard the low murmur of voices emanating from the westernmost barn, so I headed in that direction, fishing a couple of business cards from my wallet as I walked.

They were gathered in the barn aisle beneath a neatly lettered sign that read HUSH PUPPY. There were five of them in all: the two suits, a kid in white coveralls I assumed was a groom, the veterinarian crouched in the doorway to the stall, and, by process of elimination, Sydney Everett, who was speaking into a small tape recorder held by the bigger of the suits.

I snatched it from his hand and toggled the Off button.

"Hey!" he barked. "What do you think you're doing?"

I popped the microcassette and slipped it into my pocket.

"I'm saving us both a lot of paperwork," I said, tossing the device to his startled sidekick. "And now I'm having a private word with my client."

I steered her by the elbow, out of the barn and into the courtyard, where even in the fading sunlight I could see that my preconception of Sydney Everett — that of a blue-rinse biddy with her eyeglasses on a chain — could not have been further off mark.

Although I made her for around sixty, she could have passed for forty-five by candlelight. She had sleek black hair, a full mouth, and rich olive skin that gave her an exotic, almost Mediterranean appearance. She too was dressed in riding attire — gleaming high boots with little silver spurs, tight black breeches, and a white cotton blouse that stretched to contain breasts of a shape and size not ordinarily found in nature.

She had the look of a woman who'd been around the block a few times, and who'd ended up buying the neighborhood.

"I admire a man of action," she informed me in a whiskey voice poured straight from the French Quarter.

"I'm Jack MacTaggart," I said, handing her a card as we walked. "Man of action."

She stopped to examine the card, and to give me the full head to toe.

"I was expecting Jared Henley," she said. "But I can't say I'm disappointed."

"I believe Jared's in Akron, for the big Star Trek convention. Russ Dinsmoor asked me to pinch hit."

She slipped the card into her breast pocket. It was a tight squeeze.

"Russell is just so thoughtful," she purred. "Was I being dreadfully foolish, giving a statement like that?"

"Did you tell them you were waiting for your lawyer?"

"Why of course. They were right there when I called Russell from my car."

"That figures. I would have had to go to court for an order excluding the statement."

"Oh, my. That wasn't very sporting of them."

"Look, Mrs. Everett —"

"Sydney, please."

"Sydney. Those men in there are not your friends, okay? Their only purpose in coming out here was to find some way to avoid paying your claim. You need to understand that right up front."

She nodded earnestly. "If you say so, Jack."

"Now look, we've only got a couple of minutes. Tell me everything you know about ... what happened."

She cocked her hip and touched a manicured finger to her lips, a fleeting convergence of acrylic and collagen.

"Let's see. Enrique found Hush Puppy this morning, at feeding time. Enrique is the young man inside."

"Who was the last person to see the horse alive?"

She thought about that.

"I don't really know. I'd imagine it was Tara. Tara Flynn. She's the stable manager here at Fieldstone. She checks on the horses at night."

Lucky horses. "And when does she usually do that?"

"Oh, I don't know. Around six o'clock."

"And what time did Enrique find him this morning?"

"Around seven thirty. At least, that's what he said."

Which left a window of more than thirteen hours for the horse to turn belly-up.

"Had Hush Puppy been ill or ... out of sorts in any way?"

She considered this for a moment, then shook her head.

"Not that I'm aware of, no. Of course, you'd have to ask Barbara."

Of course. "And who's Barbara?"

"Why, Barbara Hauser. Barbara campaigned Hush Puppy."

I crossed to the pickup's tailgate. In addition to the stuff laid out on display, there were clear plastic drawers with gauze and swabs and, in one of the compartments, a .45 caliber revolver. Doc Wells, it seemed, was not averse to a little old-school euthanasia.

Sydney followed me, positioning herself so that her outsized ordinance targeted the general vicinity of my nose. It was like staring into the grille of a '54 Buick.

"Look, Mrs. ... ah, Sydney. I have to confess that I don't know a whole lot about horses, or what exactly one does with them at a place like Fieldstone. I assumed that you rode Hush Puppy because you owned him."

She thought this was amusing, the idea of a woman riding her own horse.

"No, I've never even sat on Hush Puppy, and I've had him for nearly four years. You see, Hush Puppy was a grand prix level show jumper. He and Barbara were working toward the Olympic trials in March."

"And where is Barbara now?"

"I think she's in San Juan Capistrano this week. Or is it Del Mar? You can check in the barn office. They'll have her schedule."

I knew that the suits would be getting antsy by now, and that I could get the details from Sydney later.

"Two more questions before we head on back. First, how large is the policy on Hush Puppy's life?"

"Oh, let's see," she said, her eyes rolling skyward. "I believe that it's two million dollars."

I nearly fell off the tailgate.

"What's your other question, Jack?"

"Forgive me for asking, but where were you between six o'clock last night and seven thirty this morning?"

Now a question like that can elicit any number of reactions from a client, ranging from surprise to mild annoyance to righteous indignation. Sydney Everett exhibited none of these.

"I had dinner at the Valley Hunt Club at seven, with friends from the Children's Hospital Guild. Plenty of witnesses there. Then several of us attended a concert at Descanso Gardens. The Pasadena Pops. They perform alfresco. If you haven't been, you should go. They're fabulous. That ended close to midnight. And then I went home. Alone. Tara called me at eight o'clock this morning, just as I was preparing to come for a hack. And that's it, I guess."

"And what about last night between six and seven?"

She thought for a moment.

"I believe I was bathing. Also alone."


Excerpted from Hush Money by Chuck Greaves. Copyright © 2012 Charles J. Greaves. Excerpted by permission of St. Martin's Press.
All rights reserved. No part of this excerpt may be reproduced or reprinted without permission in writing from the publisher.
Excerpts are provided by Dial-A-Book Inc. solely for the personal use of visitors to this web site.

Meet the Author

CHUCK GREAVES was born in Levittown, New York. He is an honors graduate of both the University of Southern California and Boston College Law School and spent twenty-five years as a trial lawyer in Los Angeles. Hush Money, his first novel, was named by SouthWest Writers as the Best Mystery/Suspense/Thriller/Adventure Novel of 2010, and won SWW's Storyteller Award. He lives in the American Southwest.

CHUCK GREAVES was born in Levittown, New York.  He is an honors graduate of both the University of Southern California and Boston College Law School and spent twenty-five years as a trial lawyer in Los Angeles. Hush Money, his first novel, was named by SouthWest Writers as the Best Mystery/Suspense/Thriller/Adventure Novel of 2010, and won SWW’s Storyteller Award. He lives in Santa Fe, New Mexico.

Customer Reviews

Average Review:

Post to your social network


Most Helpful Customer Reviews

See all customer reviews

Hush Money: A Mystery 4.5 out of 5 based on 0 ratings. 4 reviews.
Anonymous More than 1 year ago
Smart, funny and the main character Jack is sexy
Anonymous More than 1 year ago
A very clever and well written book- If you like mysteries, with twists and turns and quirky characters this book is for you. Loved every word of it!
Anonymous More than 1 year ago
Anonymous More than 1 year ago
Well paced and original plot twist makes this a worthy read. Looking forward to more.