wide of the mark
The question how many colleges have beer busts and dumb jocks is of minor importance in considering this book. The problem is that Tom Wolfe has always prided himself on putting his finger on the pulse of our society, and he has missed it here. Beer parties and jocks have been around for ages and have done little harm to students or to society. In fact, some of those jocks become movie stars (e.g. John Wayne) or politicians (e.g. Gerald Ford). The fact is that colleges and universities in this country are in serious trouble, and it isn¿t because of parties or jocks. It is because professors in many departments (specifically Humanities, Studies, Art, and Education) have a political agenda, and some of that agenda has harmful social and political consequences and some of it even has detrimental effects on the cognitive capabilities of students. This is what this novel should have been about. To touch on this problem obliquely by couching it in one character (and an Asian character at that!) is a howler. (For a novel that does deal with this issue head-on, read The Rape of Alma Mater. Although that novel is primarily from the point of view of various faculty members, there are three students who play important roles.) As to the writing, having Charlotte change may be realistic (depending on what kind of character you want Charlotte to be), but that is irrelevant. This is not a nonfiction description book. This is a novel. Charlotte is our conductor, our partner, our point of view, as we travel through the story. To have her become a different person (a person we no longer want to have as a friend) leaves us without a place to stand. We are abandoned, stranded. We either stop reading or scan. The book is really an ensemble piece. Only a fourth focuses on Charlotte, the rest on the other characters. Problem is that the other characters are not that interesting and certainly not appealing. Tom Wolfe is at his best in the chapters dealing with the student newspaper. The writing there is genuine and involving, without the detached distance of the other chapters. Taking into account the prologue and the sections on neuroscience along with the particulars of this rather peculiar story, it seems clear that the author is trying to prove that any woman will have sex with a hyper testosterone male if the right chain of circumstances pushes the appropriate brain buttons. This explains the microscopic detail the book goes into in devoting literally hundreds of pages to the seduction of Charlotte (which cannot be justified on any literary grounds). However, this is simply the S-R paradigm on a physiological level, and in spite of decades of experiments, the S-R efforts did not succeed too well on higher-order feedback systems (such as humans) except in rare cases. The author programs his model with extreme care, but in several places it strains credibility. True, some ¿nice¿ and pretty girls do hop into bed with gorillas, but many more do not. Typically, even girls who feel lonely and feel that sexual reassurance is the answer, can easily find more appropriate companions. Setting up a false disjunction between Adam and Hoyt won¿t do. Let¿s hope this book was intended as a morality play. Otherwise, the depressing and repulsive story and the incredibly slow pace with which it is told would be too much.
Was this review helpful? Yes NoThank you for your feedback.
Report this reviewThank you, this review has been flagged.