The Idea of Decline in Western History

The Idea of Decline in Western History

3.5 2
by Arthur Herman
     
 

View All Available Formats & Editions

Historian Arthur Herman traces the roots of declinism and shows how major thinkers, past and present, have contributed to its development as a coherent ideology of cultural pessimism.

From Nazism to the Sixties counterculture, from Britain's Fabian socialists to America's multiculturalists, and from Dracula and Freud to Robert Bly and Madonna, this work… See more details below

Overview

Historian Arthur Herman traces the roots of declinism and shows how major thinkers, past and present, have contributed to its development as a coherent ideology of cultural pessimism.

From Nazism to the Sixties counterculture, from Britain's Fabian socialists to America's multiculturalists, and from Dracula and Freud to Robert Bly and Madonna, this work examines the idea of decline in Western history and sets out to explain how the conviction of civilization's inevitable end has become a fixed part of the modern Western imagination. Through a series of biographical portraits spanning the 19th and 20th centuries, the author traces the roots of declinism and aims to show how major thinkers of the past and present, including Nietzsche, DuBois, Sartre, and Foucault, have contributed to its development as a coherent ideology of cultural pessimism.

Editorial Reviews

Publishers Weekly - Publisher's Weekly
Herman neatly sidesteps the question of whether the West is actually in decline. His disclaimer at the outset is that he only intends to trace the idea of decline as expressed by intellectual pessimists of various persuasions. Some doomsayers view the "inevitable" collapse with dread and resignation; others regard it with grim satisfaction. John Adams and Arnold Toynbee are typical of the first sort, Adams viewing Americans as squandering their birthright as the "redeemer nation," Toynbee realizing that the British empire is not immortal after seeing ruined Baroque palaces in Venice. Representing the second type are American thinkers such as Gore Vidal, Christopher Lasch, Thomas Pynchon, Susan Sontag and Kirkpatrick Sale. Each of these paints the modern world as spiritually bankrupt, displaced and isolated, psychologically scarred. In this typology of "decliners," the most interesting are the paradoxical ones, who welcome destruction as heralding a new order. Although Nietzsche and Herbert Marcuse deserve honorable mention in this category, it is Oswald Spengler who wins the prize, for The Decline of the West (1918-1922), in which he rejoices at the collapse of Europe and reassures his readers that the German master race is equal to the task of saving the soul of civilization. Herman, adjunct professor of history at George Mason University and coordinator of the Smithsonian's Western Civilization program, takes us through these heady thoughts with great panache and erudition, a brisk and cordial guide to the slough of despond. (Mar.)
Library Journal
Herman (history, George Mason Univ.; coordinator of the Smithsonian's Western Civilization Program) traces the idea of Western civilization's decline as it has appeared in the writings of political thinkers of the last two centuries. He begins with a brief review of the concept of decay as seen in societies from antiquity to the 18th century. He then turns to the writings of Nietzsche, Brooks Adams, W.E.B. Du Bois, and various others and examines their concepts of decline, whether racial, moral, cultural, or intellectual. Al Gore makes an appearance in one chapter on eco-pessimism: "Gore compares the modern West to a dysfunctional family." One chapter is devoted to Arnold Toynbee, who, typical of the writers under discussion, seems to welcome the end of Western civilization. Academic in subject but written in a style that appeals to informed readers, Herman's work is recommended for academic and large public libraries.-Norman Malwitz, Queensborough P.L., N.Y.
Kirkus Reviews
A learned study of the concept of decline since the Enlightenment, sure to generate widespread discussion and debate.

A recent spate of books has proclaimed the "end" of just about everything from education to science to history itself. Historian Herman, coordinator of the Smithsonian's Western Civilization Program, has provided us with an invaluable historical context from which to re-examine this persistent belief that everything is in an inevitable process of decline. Herman has an admirable command of his sources. Part I, "The Languages of Decline," reveals how a particular tradition of rhetoric combined with historical analysis and science (and sometimes pseudoscience) to produce a sense of doom. Part II, "Predicting the Decline of the West," shows how popular the idea of decline was in the West in the 19th and early 20th centuries. But valuable as the book is in tracing the evolution of these ideas through an impressive array of sources, it's not without faults. Herman rather startlingly moves (without any seeming self-consciousness about the gesture) from a masterful analysis of the concept of decline in the recent past to what seems to be a personal and heartfelt attack on modern systems of thought. In Part III, "The Triumph of Cultural Pessimism," readers who have read Allan Bloom's The Closing of the American Mind may feel a sense of déjà vu: Herman attacks the Frankfurt School and Critical Theory, as well as modern French philosophers from Sartre to Foucault. The book degenerates into a diatribe against multiculturalism and environmentalism, even making an implicit connection between the latter and Nazism. Hovering over the entire project, although never invoked, is the controversial 1989 essay "The End of History," by Francis Fukuyama.

A fascinating—and disturbing—study, and one that surely demands a response from those who firmly believe in the idea of progress.

Read More

Product Details

ISBN-13:
9781451603132
Publisher:
Free Press
Publication date:
06/15/2010
Sold by:
SIMON & SCHUSTER
Format:
NOOK Book
Pages:
528
Sales rank:
1,075,479
File size:
2 MB

Customer Reviews

Average Review:

Write a Review

and post it to your social network

     

Most Helpful Customer Reviews

See all customer reviews >