Even though
Benedikt H. Hermannsonn comes from Iceland, the warmly melancholic
indie pop he plays with his group
Benni Hemm Hemm has much more to do with American acts
Neutral Milk Hotel or
Sufjan Stevens than compatriots
Bjoerk or
Sigur Ros. With his acoustic guitar and voice backed by horns, drums, glockenspiel, and harmonium,
Hermannsonn plays songs that speak of love and isolation using natural and meteorological imagery: hills, rain, snow, sun, and wind. All in Icelandic, of course, which gives an element of novelty, of exoticness, to otherwise fairly typical
lo-fi indie pop. Because, despite the relatively obscure language they're sung in, the tracks on
Kajak, the band's second full-length, are not much more than pretty, occasionally interesting (like when acoustic guitar and percussion band noisily together on the opening of
"Stoffer"), with drawn-out, repeating lines, slurred whole notes and major scales. The album is nice, in that summery background kind of way, but nothing is overly catchy or makes you want to sing -- or at the least, hum -- along.
Hermannsonn's voice is mildly expressive, but not resonant, and though the songs never drag, the endless layering, the
lullaby- or round-like melodies, and the shift in dynamics, can get a bit monotonous, or at least work to relegate
Kajak to the backdrop. That's not to say
Benni Hemm Hemm doesn't hold some appeal: there's certainly something touching in the quavering delivery, the rustling drums, the picked chords, but it comes only in moments -- in the first bars of
"Snjorljossnjor," when the horns enter in
"Skvavars," in the aggression in
"Sol a Heyhola" -- and can't, unfortunately sustain itself throughout the record's entirety. ~ Marisa Brown
